This place is GREAT! The staff was so wonderful in the bar and the dinning area, I am so sorry I don't remember their names. Please, please forgive me that I don't remember their names? Wine was good, salads were large and good quality. My ahi tuna salad and smoked salmon was GREAT. I SAID GREAT!!! I can't wait to come back to this area to visit again. They have the best house made garlic dressing and for a good price you can purchase a pint to take home! If you live here, you better be eating here weekly.
Cora Kromer
Didn't have the Chicken Livers I ordered, so I had the Spaghetti, garlic bread, and tossed salad. It was bland and the garlic bread was dry and not much garlic flavor, but very salty for $15.95. My partner had grilled shrimp. It was 3 Shrimp, undercooked small baked potato , toss salad with spoiled ranch dressing, and burnt toast for $24.50. Lemonade was okay. Was not worth it. The waitress was training a new woman. She was polite.
Kim Leone
We went to Lehmans on a recommendation foe our 36th anniversary. The bar service was great! The dining experience was not. The prime rib was lukewarm when served. The lobster, shrimp, and scallops were over cooked and served luke warm. Our waitress never came back to our table to check how everything was. It was a bad experience from the time we sat down until we paid our bill.
steven
I asked the bartender to change the channel to the brewer game because I’m going to the game tomorrow and was excited. I just moved to Rice Lake and like everyone used google to see where to celebrate my move. The bartender said I’ll change it for you when I have time. 30 minutes later I asked the waitress to change it she said the bartender will change it when he has time. There were staff in the bar standing around and still didn’t change it. The owner came out and said the game got done at 3 and it was a repeat, trying to justify the poor customer service. The steak was ordered as a medium rare and was medium. The waitress was a sweetheart and tried hard to accommodate me. I could see the frustration in her eyes and was not happy at the laziness of her bartender. She comped my meal because I didn’t eat it, but the rest of the experience especially with the price scale of this establishment made me less than impressed. I do not recommend this place at all.
T Lake
Had dinner with my wife the week before Memorial Day 2025. We weren't impressed by the stark atmosphere and interior design, nor the severely underdressed slobs at the bar, but these are things we could live with. BUT... the food was mediocre at best (my medium calf's liver was cooked into rubber land and the salad lacked character), but worst of all was the service.
Our server eventually showed up and quickly set the tone for delays by her absence, so serious in delayed service that she disappeared after her second appearance to take our food order. When it appeared that she forgot about us, I flagged down another server who seemed a bit perturbed that I was interrupting her and politely requested attention to our table.. More waiting. Finally one of the cooks (a sous chef?) showed up at our table with our overcooked food and no explanation over the delays at every step. My wife was also disappointed with the poorly cooked food. We left as soon as we could....... of course, the wait to request the check and the subsequent wait to receive the check had us seriously consider bolting (something we'd never do but since we felt invisible we thought about it). This place is a poorly run highway restaurant; it is not a Supper Club by any Wisconsin standard. Don't bother going there, why take the risk for poorly cooked food and lousy service?!
Paige Cleasby
Inattentive wait staff. Got seated at 7:30 and walked out at 8:00 after not getting approached by any staff.
Gen Gregg Brion
We celebrated our 40th Wedding Anniversary with a luncheon at Lehmans today. Total class act. The food was fantastic!! The service was excellent.We could not have asked for a better place to enjoy spending time with family.5 stars Lehmans!!! Thank you
Jay \u0026 Laurie
My wife and I were in Rice Lake around dinner time on Saturday and started looking for options and found this place with really good Google reviews And decided to give them a try.
At first, we thought the prices were a little bit high, but then as the food started arriving, we realized what a great deal this place was. We ordered drinks and two entrées and proceeded to receive more food than we could eat!! Our first course was a delightful relish tray that was made up of delicious fresh fruit and a few carrot sticks. Next stop was soup, Laurie had the French onion and I had the split pea and ham and they were both great! Next came the lettuce salads and they were a nice portion and tasted very fresh. The salads also came with a basket of dinner rolls. Then to our surprise, we were served popovers that are only served on certain nights and they show up whenever a batch comes out of the oven and they were absolutely delightful!! At this point, our main entrées arrived, and we realized that we were almost full! Ha! We split our entrées of filet mignon and grilled walleye, which also came with baked potatoes.
The food was so abundant, so good and we had a wonderful dining experience. Our waiter Paul was so pleasant and attentive and fun to talk with! We look forward to returning here again soon!!
Jason Meyer
Great Place! Food and drinks are excellent! Service is top notch
Denise Rice Bruffett
Tried Lehman’s for the very first time 12-26-24 with husband, daughter & her hubby.
We all agreed the meal & service was Fantastic! 2 of us had prime rib & 2 of us had filet mignon. Everything from the French onion soup, rice soup, to relish tray, rolls, poppers, salad & steaks were superb. We will be back.
Kudos 👏👏👏
Trudy helped us organize and pull off a wonderful rehearsal dinner in their private back room. Food was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffery Kallsen
I have the French Dip every time I go. Absolutely delicious and large. Price for 8 people, was about 180 with tip.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ken M. Shaurette
Great service, awesome steak. We were there as part of a presentation with about 30 others and both my wife's and my steak were different, but done exactly as ordered.
A true supper club atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MEC M.R.
We were so impressed with our meal here! We had a great server who anticipated all our needs. We ordered steaks and our daughter had the spaghetti. All of it was delicious! We can't wait to come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Rudolf
We stopped in without reservations at 8pm on a Saturday night. We had our choice to eat at the Bar, or be seated at a table. We chose the bar and were served by a friendly bartender - who made dinner suggestions and kept our glasses full. Dinner was perfect and we are glad we stopped.
This place is GREAT! The staff was so wonderful in the bar and the dinning area, I am so sorry I don't remember their names. Please, please forgive me that I don't remember their names? Wine was good, salads were large and good quality. My ahi tuna salad and smoked salmon was GREAT. I SAID GREAT!!! I can't wait to come back to this area to visit again. They have the best house made garlic dressing and for a good price you can purchase a pint to take home! If you live here, you better be eating here weekly.
Didn't have the Chicken Livers I ordered, so I had the Spaghetti, garlic bread, and tossed salad. It was bland and the garlic bread was dry and not much garlic flavor, but very salty for $15.95. My partner had grilled shrimp. It was 3 Shrimp, undercooked small baked potato , toss salad with spoiled ranch dressing, and burnt toast for $24.50. Lemonade was okay. Was not worth it. The waitress was training a new woman. She was polite.
We went to Lehmans on a recommendation foe our 36th anniversary. The bar service was great! The dining experience was not. The prime rib was lukewarm when served. The lobster, shrimp, and scallops were over cooked and served luke warm. Our waitress never came back to our table to check how everything was. It was a bad experience from the time we sat down until we paid our bill.
I asked the bartender to change the channel to the brewer game because I’m going to the game tomorrow and was excited. I just moved to Rice Lake and like everyone used google to see where to celebrate my move. The bartender said I’ll change it for you when I have time. 30 minutes later I asked the waitress to change it she said the bartender will change it when he has time. There were staff in the bar standing around and still didn’t change it. The owner came out and said the game got done at 3 and it was a repeat, trying to justify the poor customer service. The steak was ordered as a medium rare and was medium. The waitress was a sweetheart and tried hard to accommodate me. I could see the frustration in her eyes and was not happy at the laziness of her bartender. She comped my meal because I didn’t eat it, but the rest of the experience especially with the price scale of this establishment made me less than impressed. I do not recommend this place at all.
Had dinner with my wife the week before Memorial Day 2025. We weren't impressed by the stark atmosphere and interior design, nor the severely underdressed slobs at the bar, but these are things we could live with. BUT... the food was mediocre at best (my medium calf's liver was cooked into rubber land and the salad lacked character), but worst of all was the service.
Our server eventually showed up and quickly set the tone for delays by her absence, so serious in delayed service that she disappeared after her second appearance to take our food order. When it appeared that she forgot about us, I flagged down another server who seemed a bit perturbed that I was interrupting her and politely requested attention to our table.. More waiting. Finally one of the cooks (a sous chef?) showed up at our table with our overcooked food and no explanation over the delays at every step. My wife was also disappointed with the poorly cooked food. We left as soon as we could....... of course, the wait to request the check and the subsequent wait to receive the check had us seriously consider bolting (something we'd never do but since we felt invisible we thought about it). This place is a poorly run highway restaurant; it is not a Supper Club by any Wisconsin standard. Don't bother going there, why take the risk for poorly cooked food and lousy service?!
Inattentive wait staff. Got seated at 7:30 and walked out at 8:00 after not getting approached by any staff.
We celebrated our 40th Wedding Anniversary with a luncheon at Lehmans today. Total class act. The food was fantastic!! The service was excellent.We could not have asked for a better place to enjoy spending time with family.5 stars Lehmans!!! Thank you
My wife and I were in Rice Lake around dinner time on Saturday and started looking for options and found this place with really good Google reviews And decided to give them a try.
At first, we thought the prices were a little bit high, but then as the food started arriving, we realized what a great deal this place was. We ordered drinks and two entrées and proceeded to receive more food than we could eat!! Our first course was a delightful relish tray that was made up of delicious fresh fruit and a few carrot sticks. Next stop was soup, Laurie had the French onion and I had the split pea and ham and they were both great! Next came the lettuce salads and they were a nice portion and tasted very fresh. The salads also came with a basket of dinner rolls. Then to our surprise, we were served popovers that are only served on certain nights and they show up whenever a batch comes out of the oven and they were absolutely delightful!! At this point, our main entrées arrived, and we realized that we were almost full! Ha! We split our entrées of filet mignon and grilled walleye, which also came with baked potatoes.
The food was so abundant, so good and we had a wonderful dining experience. Our waiter Paul was so pleasant and attentive and fun to talk with! We look forward to returning here again soon!!
Great Place! Food and drinks are excellent! Service is top notch
Tried Lehman’s for the very first time 12-26-24 with husband, daughter & her hubby. We all agreed the meal & service was Fantastic! 2 of us had prime rib & 2 of us had filet mignon. Everything from the French onion soup, rice soup, to relish tray, rolls, poppers, salad & steaks were superb. We will be back. Kudos 👏👏👏
Restaurantji Recommends
Trudy helped us organize and pull off a wonderful rehearsal dinner in their private back room. Food was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have the French Dip every time I go.
Absolutely delicious and large.
Price for 8 people, was about 180 with tip.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service, awesome steak. We were there as part of a presentation with about 30 others and both my wife's and my steak were different, but done exactly as ordered.
A true supper club atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were so impressed with our meal here! We had a great server who anticipated all our needs. We ordered steaks and our daughter had the spaghetti. All of it was delicious! We can't wait to come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped in without reservations at 8pm on a Saturday night. We had our choice to eat at the Bar, or be seated at a table. We chose the bar and were served by a friendly bartender - who made dinner suggestions and kept our glasses full. Dinner was perfect and we are glad we stopped.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...