Awesome Pizza! Sorry we missed you Cody. Next time.
Kid-friendliness: Got a booster right away and colors and a pizza board for her to “make” her own pizza.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Great Pizza
Michael Jaber
Their pizza is fantastic!! The crust is thin and amazing. A great cozy place for pizza and incredible garlic bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Great Pizza
Jessica Ann Grunewald-Stein
Ordered a large sausage mushroom onion green pepper pizza paid $18 was waiting the 20mins outside in the truck my husband inside he comes out and says she messed up and we owed $6 more for other half of the sausage on the pizza?! Why is it our the customers fault they screwed up putting it in the computer?! And I get told you want a discount because they screwed up ya that’s usually how it works. Not my fault u have incompetence for workers. I understand people make mistakes but I don’t know the prices your workers should. Then I get told they are a small town local business so it’s ok to steal from them seriously it was not my mistake I paid the $6. More than tried to charge me more so I paid $24.total. When I could have gotten a Faye’s deluxe pizza for like $21. And just not have olives on it why wouldn’t you just put it into the register as a deluxe because you are greedy and want to over charge your customers??!?! Ridiculous customer service.
Paid $24 for like 8 pieces of sausage on the pizza. So like only put on half anyways but I paid the extra for the whole pizza.
Glenn Steeber
It was our first time there, pizza was very good, and crust was crispy. The jalapeño poppers were different but very tasty. We're from Manitowoc, but we will stop again when we're in Sheboygan.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Coco Luvly
Faye’s Pizza is hands down some of the best in town! The crust is the perfect combo of crispy and chewy, and the toppings are always fresh and loaded with flavor. Whether you're a thin crust fan or love a good deep dish, they’ve got you covered. The staff is welcoming, and the cozy, nostalgic feel of the place makes every visit special. Definitely a must-try for any pizza lover!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Frank Schmitt
My go to place to eat when visiting sheboygan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Sheila Davidson
Changed . Bad pizza , can’t recommend
Jaspar Bailey
Pizza was not good . They have changed crust recipe.. it seemed like a frozen crust and was bland . Soup cold .. salad with rotten lettuce , this place was good years ago .. but not now . Service was horrible.
Lexie Neevel
Went here for lunch with a friend of mine for the first time. Ordered a small pepperoni pizza with the chicken strips and dessert. Pizza was all right. Staff was very friendly.
Awesome Pizza! Sorry we missed you Cody. Next time.
Kid-friendliness: Got a booster right away and colors and a pizza board for her to “make” her own pizza.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Great Pizza
Their pizza is fantastic!! The crust is thin and amazing. A great cozy place for pizza and incredible garlic bread.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Great Pizza
Ordered a large sausage mushroom onion green pepper pizza paid $18 was waiting the 20mins outside in the truck my husband inside he comes out and says she messed up and we owed $6 more for other half of the sausage on the pizza?! Why is it our the customers fault they screwed up putting it in the computer?! And I get told you want a discount because they screwed up ya that’s usually how it works. Not my fault u have incompetence for workers. I understand people make mistakes but I don’t know the prices your workers should. Then I get told they are a small town local business so it’s ok to steal from them seriously it was not my mistake I paid the $6. More than tried to charge me more so I paid $24.total. When I could have gotten a Faye’s deluxe pizza for like $21. And just not have olives on it why wouldn’t you just put it into the register as a deluxe because you are greedy and want to over charge your customers??!?! Ridiculous customer service. Paid $24 for like 8 pieces of sausage on the pizza. So like only put on half anyways but I paid the extra for the whole pizza.
It was our first time there, pizza was very good, and crust was crispy. The jalapeño poppers were different but very tasty. We're from Manitowoc, but we will stop again when we're in Sheboygan.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Faye’s Pizza is hands down some of the best in town! The crust is the perfect combo of crispy and chewy, and the toppings are always fresh and loaded with flavor. Whether you're a thin crust fan or love a good deep dish, they’ve got you covered. The staff is welcoming, and the cozy, nostalgic feel of the place makes every visit special. Definitely a must-try for any pizza lover!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
My go to place to eat when visiting sheboygan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Changed . Bad pizza , can’t recommend
Pizza was not good . They have changed crust recipe.. it seemed like a frozen crust and was bland . Soup cold .. salad with rotten lettuce , this place was good years ago .. but not now . Service was horrible.
Went here for lunch with a friend of mine for the first time. Ordered a small pepperoni pizza with the chicken strips and dessert. Pizza was all right. Staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great Pizza and Cheese Bread.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza around hands down!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
I love Faye’s
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza and service were great my friend from Australia and I very much enjoyed our time at Faye's and I will be coming back again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Worst frozen pizza ever. If you buy this, throw it right in the garage, your body will thank you later.
Food: 1
The best gluten free pizza we've had. Excellent service. Great spot. We will definitely be back on our next visit to Sheboygan!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Loading...