Geno Nottolini's Pizza

1235 Indiana Ave, Sheboygan
(920) 458-4505

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica Longoria Denny

I'm so.
Upset.I ordered $45 worth of food for my kids.And I on the 3rd of July and I never received it but yet I was charged for it on the fourth and management is swearing that I received it so they won't refund me yet.I have all of the footage from my security camera proving that I didn't. Gino's pizza is a horrible company

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jenny

This was the best pizza that my husband and I have had in a long time. The Slice app is good for ordering but they give you a time that is not correct.

Food: 5

Service: 4

Dakota

Ordered twice. The first pizza was deep dish and it was just tomato sauce in a bowl of dough with floating toppings. The second time i ordered a sandwich and paid with card and they left it sit at the restaurant for over an hour then when i called about it they brought me a cold sandwich and soggy fries. Avoid this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Trevor Stewart

Let’s start by saying there is nothing absolutely nothing Italian about this place that’s a lie the pizza is awful nothing short of horrible we ordered a basic pepperoni pizza and it was burnt the deep dish was not a deep dish at all your better off ordering from dominos but if your in Sheboygan and want a good pizza from a bar just go to franks place this place should stay with Mexican food that’s what fits there environment

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Steven M

Food was ok. The service wasn't great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

NuckinFuts920

Ordered twice. The first pizza was deep dish and it was just tomato sauce in a bowl of dough with floating toppings. The second time i ordered a sandwich and paid with card and they left it sit at the restaurant for over an hour then when i called about it they brought me a cold sandwich and soggy fries. Avoid this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Doc Bowman

Deep dish pizza is deep dough! When you order, order a thin crust.that is what they put for a thin pizza. I will never order again!!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Jakwan J.

I don't appreciate phone numbers being displayed. And it not being accurate. And including the time also.

Aaron B

Food was ok. The service wasn't great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Libni Juarez

Pepperoni ?

Jesus Miller

I made my order for delivery. The lady who answered the phone was very polite and helpful

Michael Katerski

Pizza was mediocre, think the Mexican food is really

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Enchiladas

K A

Absolutely disgusting. I threw the entire thing in the trash what a waste of money.

Tony Konya

Place is inside a slummy, sketchy bar with horrible food. Complete scam don’t go in!! Dirty and I thought I would be mugged going in. I would rate this place negative if I could, pizza are not like the website which are stock photos, the place is actually a Mexican bar and not an Italian pizza shop. The city should stop this scam and force this “shop” to close

Jim Sherwin

This place is a total and utter sham. If anyone takes the time to place an order from this joint expect to starve! They are the worst.

Loading...