Geno Nottolini's Pizza

1235 Indiana Ave, Sheboygan
(920) 458-4505

Recent Reviews

Trevor Stewart

Let’s start by saying there is nothing absolutely nothing Italian about this place that’s a lie the pizza is awful nothing short of horrible we ordered a basic pepperoni pizza and it was burnt the deep dish was not a deep dish at all your better off ordering from dominos but if your in Sheboygan and want a good pizza from a bar just go to franks place this place should stay with Mexican food that’s what fits there environment

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

NuckinFuts920

Ordered twice. The first pizza was deep dish and it was just tomato sauce in a bowl of dough with floating toppings. The second time i ordered a sandwich and paid with card and they left it sit at the restaurant for over an hour then when i called about it they brought me a cold sandwich and soggy fries. Avoid this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Doc Bowman

Deep dish pizza is deep dough! When you order, order a thin crust.that is what they put for a thin pizza. I will never order again!!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Jakwan J.

I don't appreciate phone numbers being displayed. And it not being accurate. And including the time also.

Jesus Miller

I made my order for delivery. The lady who answered the phone was very polite and helpful

Michael Katerski

Pizza was mediocre, think the Mexican food is really

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Enchiladas

Tony Konya

Place is inside a slummy, sketchy bar with horrible food. Complete scam don’t go in!! Dirty and I thought I would be mugged going in. I would rate this place negative if I could, pizza are not like the website which are stock photos, the place is actually a Mexican bar and not an Italian pizza shop. The city should stop this scam and force this “shop” to close

Jim Sherwin

This place is a total and utter sham. If anyone takes the time to place an order from this joint expect to starve! They are the worst.

Kameron S

Absolutely disgusting. I threw the entire thing in the trash what a waste of money.

Laura Goeckermann

Very expensive. Pizza was cold and little flavor . 48 dollars for a pizza and Garlic bread was not on my plan for a dinner we hardly ate

Stephanie Berner

We are from MN and found this pizza place on Google Maps. I was able to place an online order. Times on Google said they were open from noon to 12:45 AM, their online ordering system allowed order to be submitted. We got an online notification pizza will be ready at 12:30 PM that day. My brother who is also coming for a vacation notified me this business was not open based on a screenshot he shared with me. I tried to call the pizza place three times on Sunday beginning at 12PM to confirm their hours and nobody answered the phone. I called the merchant after getting a text today that our pizza was ready (when we are headed back home) and requested a refund for the amount of pizza plus tip. Manager said no because it was ready on time claiming today was the day for it to be ready when I placed the order on Sunday. She said they are open every day from noon to 12:45AM and she said there was nothing she could do since it was through another merchant the order was put through.

A Bcd

Love this place! Pizza, motz sticks with their marinara sauce. I could drink the marinara sauce buy the gallon it's absolutely THE best marinara you will ever come across.

Justin Teal

Great sized portions at reasonable prices. The food was excellent!

MistahZ

Don't just don't. This is hands down THE WORSE 'pizza' i have ever had the displeasure of eating, possibly the number one when it comes to restaurants overall. It's sad because the sides weren't too bad, good even but the 'pizza' I got completely overshadowed it with its awful texture and weird wattery over moist toppings. Stay away, don't waste your money here.Pictures are of the food I got and that's it.

Quinn Callender

Twice in the last two weeks the food I ordered arrived burnt. The first was cheese ravioli that was great but the bread was totally burned and inedible. Tonight I ordered an enchilada dinner that was pretty bad Hamburger meat was partially burned and tortillas were totally crispy and burnt around the edges. Rice was okay but after cutting tortillas and putting aside the burnt part of the hamburger meat there wasn't much left for $12+. However I did have ravioli meal a week ago that was perfect. So if it's just one cook, maybe they should be more careful or do something else there. I don't know if I'll continue to order from you when I'm not sure what condition the food will be in. Too bad because the meal itself was great when not burned.

Load More