Potbelly Sandwich Shop

3320 University Ave, Shorewood Hills
(608) 819-3097

Recent Reviews

Valerie Swiecichowski

My boyfriend and I absolutely LOVE potbellies. We are dying to get this store back because they have always took care of us when our orders were wrong or missing something. Please open this store back up. We use to go here weekly and now we are stuck with other sub-par sandwich shops. ???

Colleen O'Brien

Love the food. I had gotten a powerhouse salad without avocado but they didn't put the hummus on which I wanted. Salad was good but would liked to have tried it with the hummus. also got the mushroom melt and added chicken, delicious! sugar cookie is delicious as well just right not too hard or soft.

Tim Virnig

Consistently delicious subs. Sure you can get a cheaper sub at that place named after public transportation but Potbelly subs have better ingredients and better meats. And it's actually toasted in a oven not a microwave. Get a smoothie too. You won't regret it.

Swapna Shanmugavelayutham

The young men working yesterday evening were pretty inattentive. Disappointing, as I was an out-of-town visitor and expecting a reliable customer experience at this location.

Quinton Westrich

I always get the Mediteranean with chicken and it's always good at a fair price.

Oscar L.

The best grilled chicken sub I've ever had in my life! It's 11:30am 10/23/2019. I ordered it with everything except onions. I think what makes this sub so good it's some kind of pickled peppers or vegetables they use. Man that pickled juice makes it taste delicious. First time I ever eat at this restaurant. I chose it because of the high reviews on yelp. I'm so glad I did. Cod sandwich from Culver's and now Grilled chicken sub with everything from Potbelly Shop two of my favorite foods in the world!!!

Shamik Misra

Salads are awesome here...

Matt Busko

Great sandwich! Great cookie! Nice place. Fast!

Kevin Dulli

Very tasty sandwich was had here. Would definitely come back.

Andrew Foley

Surprisingly great subs & I love the fact that they have a lot of different options and shakes

José Andrés García González

Good place although the AC was too low

Eric

Food is usually good and tastes fresh overall. I've had multiple experiences where the online order ticket is ignored until you come to pick up the food. Worse is when you've already paid for a side dish/chips/dessert and they tell you it's out once you get there and offer no refund for what you already paid.

David McNler

Excellant turkey sub.

Ivan Imes

Great subs, reasonably priced.

Jordan Levy

It is a sandwich shop. Potbelly usually has good sandwiches and these were what I expected. The location was clean and the people friendly.

Load More