The Cotter Pin
$ • Wine Bars, Bars, Pizza
Hours:
20671 WI-27, Sparta
(608) 487-8118
About The Cotter Pin
Customers' Favorites
The Cotter Pin Reviews
Share your opinion about The Cotter Pin
Cotter Pin is a favorite of ours! Love their bloody Mary’s with their bacon vodka…so yummy! Always a great atmosphere!
Poor management! Racism, ungrateful, fake friendliness, chaos. Teenager serving food in the kitchen, play favorites, owner drinks while on duty, yells and argues at employees right in front customer, unprofessional behavior! Owner gives false excuses/information with a text message to fire employee! Criticism, judgmental, owner doesn’t make its own decisions based from experience this business is a joke! Very unprofessional! If this is the business you don’t mind working for...read full review
Great visit today! Enjoyed the Hillsboro Octoberfest beer and pretzels and beer cheese. Delish! Great staff and the furniture is beautiful! Thanks Neal for a great afternoon.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
The Cotter Pin is a popular restaurant known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant's clean and attractive setting makes it a pleasant place to dine, and the friendly staff provide excellent service. The menu offers a variety of options, including pretzel bites with beer cheese dip, Rubens, and other sandwiches. Customers have praised the restaurant's generous portions, prompt service, and exceptional food quality, with no menu item being considered less than fantastic. The interior has an up north feel, and there are games to play while waiting. The Queen prime rib special was very good, served smoked with a salad, potato, green beans, and bread. The beer cheese pretzel bites are amazing, and the side salad is fresh with homemade bleu cheese dressing. The Reuben has a complex flavor and is perfectly toasted. Although the restaurant does not have a fryer or grill, they still serve good food quickly with friendly and attentive staff. The atmosphere is nice and clean, making it a great place for a quick bite or a satisfying meal. Recent reviews highlight the friendly staff, great conversation, and the seafood mac and cheese, which customers find amazing. Many visitors appreciate the welcoming vibe, even if they are not locals, and often plan to return. The restaurant also features a nice selection of spirits and a tap selection to please any palate, with a cozy cabin-like ambiance that makes guests feel at home.