We have been here several times and the food has always been excellent. The restaurant is charming and has ample outdoor seating. Be aware that it can get very crowed when APT lets out, so expect a wait.
Kallista
I absolutely love the food here! This is one of my most favorite restaurants! I get upset when I finish the pasta and want more because it's so good! The pizzas here are fantastic! I love that the menu is seasonal and keeps changing. The owners are wonderful too! I don't get to visit these guys enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Libra_K1960
We were very pleased to find this option for our second night in Spring Green as our first meal had been very disappointing. The pizzas were perfect - and plenty large enough for us to keep some for lunch the following day. Staff were friendly and helpful, though they do ask you to clear your table yourself. The only downside was that they had run out of 'Spotted Cow' beer.
Carrie W.
The perfect spot to stop after visiting Taliesin. We ordered a pizza and the beet salad, both of which were fresh and delicious. It was a perfect fall evening to sit outside and we were lucky to grab the last table. I noticed some folks had brought a blanket and set up a little picnic since there were no tables left, which I thought was a great idea. The backyard is really sweet with string lights, the pizza oven, and view of the historic schoolhouse.Excellent all around and I will definitely keep it in mind if we're ever in the area again. Just please don't pair your delightful meal here with a stay at the Usonian Inn, a sketchy place and terrible owner.
Rhonda Foster
Limited seating and continual orders taken leaves a chaotic atmosphere and people standing beside your table as u eat waiting for u to leave. Pizza was not hot and we ate quickly with onlookers standing behind our chairs. Order at counter and bus your table yourself. Won’t go againVegetarian options: Limited
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Josh Weigand
Great food. Amazing atmosphere. Checked this place out with my brother, and was impressed with how good the food was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Candace Fagerlind
Such a neat place. The food is SO GOOD - obviously made by talented, experienced chefs. It's a different concept in that you do all your ordering at the counter and they bring it out to your table. Grab your own plates and silverware and head outside in beautiful weather, or stay inside the old schoolhouse. The menu changes often depending on what local produce is available but their woodfired pizzas seem to be a staple (at least in the summer time). Picture is their Roasted Squash Toast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eva Wingren
So tasty and fun! Everything was wonderful, and you can't beat the garden
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trisha B.
Homecoming is one of our very favorite places. While we love dining al fresco in the charming backyard, it's also quite cozy indoors when the weather makes outdoor dining impossible.The service is always friendly and you can see that they work well as a team.The olives are an absolute must (I thought I hated olives before these), and we've rarely had a bad entree. Sometimes dishes run out before we get there, but you can't go wrong with the pizza.
Zander Marshall
Pesto Pizza? Nay. Jalapeño pizza with pesto for looks! So spicy it had me in fight or flight!It's hard to rate "Service" 5 Stars as there was little service. A sign said "wait your table if you are able" so we put our dishes in the adjacent dish bin ourselves, but you can't expect a town with as many $9 coffees and charm as Spring Green to also have dedicated wait staff :)They also let us bring a homemade cake and eat it there!Wheelchair accessibility: Despite being an *old* schoolhouse, there is a wheelchair ramp.
We read the great reviews and decided to stop for dinner prior to a show at American Players Theatre. We were not disappointed! They offer a creative, small menu and nice wine and beer selection in the unique ambiance of a former old schoolhouse. We had a pesto wood-fired pizza, roasted egg plant and shared a generous salad. We ended up with a yummy honey cake. Everything was delicious and the staff was very friendly. We will return if ever back in Spring Green.
Bonnie M.
We ate outside at the Homecoming on a perfect Wisconsin summer night. The food was inventive and delicious. A wonderful option in a town with few dining choices.
s pags
A fantastic find in Spring Green. VERY popular. Expect to sit outside, although that may be preferable (indoors was warm). Great food and drink. Quite a vibe!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A. Corrine Kennedy
The place could use some cleaning up, as the paint is chipping just about everywhere, but other than that it's a cute vibe. The food was good but over priced - 10 bucks for a single zucchini? Some of the pizza pieces had no cheese on them - I appreciate that they use real mozzarella, but that sucked when you grabbed a slice with no cheese at all! I'm sure this is a great spot if you are just dropping by for some drinks with friends. It was good food, but it's expensive for the dinner you get.Also, the outdoor seating was kinda sad and gross looking. Someone's old plastic lawn chairs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Igor Sadovyi
The only even remotely constructive thing I can say about Homecoming is that I wish they were open for lunch on the weekends! A brilliant time, every time - constantly updated menu, great drinks, thoughtful and interesting wine selection. This place is an absolute treat for my wife and I! Can't wait to see what Reunion looks like.
We have been here several times and the food has always been excellent. The restaurant is charming and has ample outdoor seating. Be aware that it can get very crowed when APT lets out, so expect a wait.
I absolutely love the food here! This is one of my most favorite restaurants! I get upset when I finish the pasta and want more because it's so good! The pizzas here are fantastic! I love that the menu is seasonal and keeps changing. The owners are wonderful too! I don't get to visit these guys enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were very pleased to find this option for our second night in Spring Green as our first meal had been very disappointing. The pizzas were perfect - and plenty large enough for us to keep some for lunch the following day. Staff were friendly and helpful, though they do ask you to clear your table yourself. The only downside was that they had run out of 'Spotted Cow' beer.
The perfect spot to stop after visiting Taliesin. We ordered a pizza and the beet salad, both of which were fresh and delicious. It was a perfect fall evening to sit outside and we were lucky to grab the last table. I noticed some folks had brought a blanket and set up a little picnic since there were no tables left, which I thought was a great idea. The backyard is really sweet with string lights, the pizza oven, and view of the historic schoolhouse.Excellent all around and I will definitely keep it in mind if we're ever in the area again. Just please don't pair your delightful meal here with a stay at the Usonian Inn, a sketchy place and terrible owner.
Limited seating and continual orders taken leaves a chaotic atmosphere and people standing beside your table as u eat waiting for u to leave. Pizza was not hot and we ate quickly with onlookers standing behind our chairs. Order at counter and bus your table yourself. Won’t go againVegetarian options: Limited
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great food. Amazing atmosphere. Checked this place out with my brother, and was impressed with how good the food was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a neat place. The food is SO GOOD - obviously made by talented, experienced chefs. It's a different concept in that you do all your ordering at the counter and they bring it out to your table. Grab your own plates and silverware and head outside in beautiful weather, or stay inside the old schoolhouse. The menu changes often depending on what local produce is available but their woodfired pizzas seem to be a staple (at least in the summer time). Picture is their Roasted Squash Toast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So tasty and fun! Everything was wonderful, and you can't beat the garden
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Homecoming is one of our very favorite places. While we love dining al fresco in the charming backyard, it's also quite cozy indoors when the weather makes outdoor dining impossible.The service is always friendly and you can see that they work well as a team.The olives are an absolute must (I thought I hated olives before these), and we've rarely had a bad entree. Sometimes dishes run out before we get there, but you can't go wrong with the pizza.
Pesto Pizza? Nay. Jalapeño pizza with pesto for looks! So spicy it had me in fight or flight!It's hard to rate "Service" 5 Stars as there was little service. A sign said "wait your table if you are able" so we put our dishes in the adjacent dish bin ourselves, but you can't expect a town with as many $9 coffees and charm as Spring Green to also have dedicated wait staff :)They also let us bring a homemade cake and eat it there!Wheelchair accessibility: Despite being an *old* schoolhouse, there is a wheelchair ramp.
Restaurantji Recommends
We read the great reviews and decided to stop for dinner prior to a show at American Players Theatre. We were not disappointed! They offer a creative, small menu and nice wine and beer selection in the unique ambiance of a former old schoolhouse. We had a pesto wood-fired pizza, roasted egg plant and shared a generous salad. We ended up with a yummy honey cake. Everything was delicious and the staff was very friendly. We will return if ever back in Spring Green.
We ate outside at the Homecoming on a perfect Wisconsin summer night. The food was inventive and delicious. A wonderful option in a town with few dining choices.
A fantastic find in Spring Green. VERY popular. Expect to sit outside, although that may be preferable (indoors was warm). Great food and drink. Quite a vibe!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The place could use some cleaning up, as the paint is chipping just about everywhere, but other than that it's a cute vibe. The food was good but over priced - 10 bucks for a single zucchini? Some of the pizza pieces had no cheese on them - I appreciate that they use real mozzarella, but that sucked when you grabbed a slice with no cheese at all! I'm sure this is a great spot if you are just dropping by for some drinks with friends. It was good food, but it's expensive for the dinner you get.Also, the outdoor seating was kinda sad and gross looking. Someone's old plastic lawn chairs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
The only even remotely constructive thing I can say about Homecoming is that I wish they were open for lunch on the weekends! A brilliant time, every time - constantly updated menu, great drinks, thoughtful and interesting wine selection. This place is an absolute treat for my wife and I! Can't wait to see what Reunion looks like.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5