Excellent food, great atmosphere, excellent service!
Cassie Geoffrion
Love the old school supper club decor. Great service and big portions. Shrimp cocktail some of the best I’ve had. Comparable to The Del Bar in Lake Delton. It is an open dining area so it was a bit loud to try and have a conversation across the table.
Jennifer Jacqueline
Amazing food, drinks, service & staff! The Chicken Cordon Bleu was delicious, and highly recommended. We can’t wait to enjoy the outdoor seating in summer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Cox
Phenomenal. Literally, this rivals Ishnala in my book. Maybe it’s not on a lake, but everything else? Completely on par, in my opinion.
I walked in to a cozy atmosphere, very upscale supper club vibes. Everyone walking out had at least one box and I found out why - the portions are massive.
My husband had the ribeye, you could’ve cut it with a fork, I swear. I had the shrimp. Initially I was skeptical, but they were huge prawns, perfectly cooked and perfectly seasoned.
DELICIOUS! You can’t miss this place. Mary is a sweetheart and will take great care of you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
Sheri Olson
After the new remodel, the atmosphere now reminds me of a version of a small retro supper club. Everything was great. I had a margarita, the steak sandwich and fries. All was delicious. Enough to eat and still plenty to take some home. Our bartender was phenomenal but I didn't catch her name.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Schwingle
Water Street Tavern has a supper club feel - vintage decor and dimmer lighting. The service was top notch. Our food was GREAT. The steak was seasoned so well, I did not need the bleu cheese topping. I didn't know I would love brussels sprout, but here we are! Try the relish tray!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Heider
An amazing place to have a great dinner with friends and family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Suter Teeter
Absolutely love it here! The remodel is stunning and everyone is so welcoming, great service, food and drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Cook
Long time Stoughton resident here. I took my family in for apps and drinks over the holidays and couldn't have been more impressed with the atmosphere, the service, and the food. We had the brussels sprout side, stuffed mushrooms, and steak sandwiches. All of them were amazing, and the steak sandwich was completely on point!
If you visited Water Street prior to their metamorphosis into a supper club, you owe it to yourself to visit it again. No TVs, super classic decor, and an Art-o-mat machine full of fun, kitschy, handmade art.
Highly recommend for a special night out. Prices were very reasonable considering the overall quality of the food and the experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Wanninger
We had an excellent meal! The chicken cordon blue was amazing. Served with yummy mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts that were cooked perfectly! Everyone was very kind and service was fast and friendly. We will definitely be back! Don’t forget to make a reservation! It is online and very easy.
This establishment is a MUST if your a foodie! Our group of 4 dined here last evening we started with the relish tray, calamari, as well as a nice bottle of wine. I had the wedge salad, mashed potatoes, Brussels & ribeye w/marsala mushrooms which was cooked to absolute perfection! The ambiance, staff quality of everything that was placed on our table is just chefs kiss! Cannot wait to go back again! thanks to the owners for providing such a great establishment and team! Truly a remarkable 👏 dining experience!
wavetrainSUP
I ordered a perch dinner. My wife had a steak sandwich. Plenty to go around! Cole slaw was perfect. Fries were just right. Cheesecake dessert to top it off. Also had a wonderful batch of calamari and a relish platter for appetizers. One of our favorite dinners in quite awhile! Already looking forward to going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie Cubbage
Definitely coming back! We had reservations for 3 but they seemed able to accommodate walk ins. Food was great, steaks were cooked correctly, and service was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
Samantha Bausch
My hubby and had a little date night here last Friday 12/6. I made the reservation online and we were seated right away. I was surprised to see that it was almost a full house! The renovations look fantastic and really added to the "supper club" ambience. It has a much more upscale look now, and the candles on the tables were a nice touch. We both ordered the 10 Oz. sirloin, both cooked to medium, with a house salad. My husband had french fries, and I had the mashed potatoes. They were garlic mash, I believe, and were delicious. The house salads were pretty good, too, with a mix of baby greens and arugula. He also had the coleslaw, and I chose a cup of their French onion soup - both were very delicious! My husband's steak came out perfectly, but mine was a touch overdone. They were very busy, so I didn't ask to have it remade, and it was still very tasty. My husband remarked that he could taste the grilled char taste on his steak, which he liked very much. He also had the grilled shrimp as an add-on, and that was probably the best part of the meal! They were very busy, so I understand, but we had a few service issues, such as I had to remind our server that I also ordered the cup of soup, and also had to remind her to bring out my husband's french fries. Also, we had to request salt/pepper - which I would prefer just already be placed on the tables. I had the lemon-vodka Cosmopolitan, which was delicious, and my husband ordered a Korbel Old Fashioned. His drink initially just came out as a glass of Korbel, so we did send it back to request it be made into an old fashioned. All issues were resolved quickly and politely. We also got to chat with Dylan, the operations manager, for a bit, and we could tell he was really invested in getting the new digs up to speed. He was very friendly, and accommodating, and seemed to be talking to a lot of other patrons, which is good to see. All in all, we really enjoyed our dinner. The food came out fairly quick. I would suggest to have salt/pepper shakers on the tables, and to have toothpicks and/or mints available on the hostess stand to grab on the way out. We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Meaghan Maybee
If you're having a bad day, go to Water Street Tavern - because I guarantee you will leave there in a great mood! The food, service, and environment are awesome. I would highly recommend the steak sandwich with the bacon Brussels sprouts. I was blown away at how great they tasted! Our server was very kind, and management stopped by our table to make sure everything was perfect. Also, the atmosphere at Water Street Tavern is so cozy and chic. Looking forward to visiting here in the summer!
Excellent food, great atmosphere, excellent service!
Love the old school supper club decor. Great service and big portions. Shrimp cocktail some of the best I’ve had. Comparable to The Del Bar in Lake Delton. It is an open dining area so it was a bit loud to try and have a conversation across the table.
Amazing food, drinks, service & staff! The Chicken Cordon Bleu was delicious, and highly recommended. We can’t wait to enjoy the outdoor seating in summer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phenomenal. Literally, this rivals Ishnala in my book. Maybe it’s not on a lake, but everything else? Completely on par, in my opinion.
I walked in to a cozy atmosphere, very upscale supper club vibes. Everyone walking out had at least one box and I found out why - the portions are massive.
My husband had the ribeye, you could’ve cut it with a fork, I swear. I had the shrimp. Initially I was skeptical, but they were huge prawns, perfectly cooked and perfectly seasoned.
DELICIOUS! You can’t miss this place. Mary is a sweetheart and will take great care of you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
After the new remodel, the atmosphere now reminds me of a version of a small retro supper club. Everything was great. I had a margarita, the steak sandwich and fries. All was delicious. Enough to eat and still plenty to take some home. Our bartender was phenomenal but I didn't catch her name.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Water Street Tavern has a supper club feel - vintage decor and dimmer lighting. The service was top notch. Our food was GREAT. The steak was seasoned so well, I did not need the bleu cheese topping. I didn't know I would love brussels sprout, but here we are! Try the relish tray!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
An amazing place to have a great dinner with friends and family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely love it here! The remodel is stunning and everyone is so welcoming, great service, food and drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Long time Stoughton resident here. I took my family in for apps and drinks over the holidays and couldn't have been more impressed with the atmosphere, the service, and the food. We had the brussels sprout side, stuffed mushrooms, and steak sandwiches. All of them were amazing, and the steak sandwich was completely on point!
If you visited Water Street prior to their metamorphosis into a supper club, you owe it to yourself to visit it again. No TVs, super classic decor, and an Art-o-mat machine full of fun, kitschy, handmade art.
Highly recommend for a special night out. Prices were very reasonable considering the overall quality of the food and the experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had an excellent meal! The chicken cordon blue was amazing. Served with yummy mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts that were cooked perfectly!
Everyone was very kind and service was fast and friendly. We will definitely be back!
Don’t forget to make a reservation! It is online and very easy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This establishment is a MUST if your a foodie! Our group of 4 dined here last evening we started with the relish tray, calamari, as well as a nice bottle of wine. I had the wedge salad, mashed potatoes, Brussels & ribeye w/marsala mushrooms which was cooked to absolute perfection! The ambiance, staff quality of everything that was placed on our table is just chefs kiss! Cannot wait to go back again! thanks to the owners for providing such a great establishment and team! Truly a remarkable 👏 dining experience!
I ordered a perch dinner. My wife had a steak sandwich. Plenty to go around! Cole slaw was perfect. Fries were just right. Cheesecake dessert to top it off. Also had a wonderful batch of calamari and a relish platter for appetizers. One of our favorite dinners in quite awhile! Already looking forward to going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely coming back! We had reservations for 3 but they seemed able to accommodate walk ins. Food was great, steaks were cooked correctly, and service was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
My hubby and had a little date night here last Friday 12/6. I made the reservation online and we were seated right away. I was surprised to see that it was almost a full house! The renovations look fantastic and really added to the "supper club" ambience. It has a much more upscale look now, and the candles on the tables were a nice touch. We both ordered the 10 Oz. sirloin, both cooked to medium, with a house salad. My husband had french fries, and I had the mashed potatoes. They were garlic mash, I believe, and were delicious. The house salads were pretty good, too, with a mix of baby greens and arugula. He also had the coleslaw, and I chose a cup of their French onion soup - both were very delicious! My husband's steak came out perfectly, but mine was a touch overdone. They were very busy, so I didn't ask to have it remade, and it was still very tasty. My husband remarked that he could taste the grilled char taste on his steak, which he liked very much. He also had the grilled shrimp as an add-on, and that was probably the best part of the meal! They were very busy, so I understand, but we had a few service issues, such as I had to remind our server that I also ordered the cup of soup, and also had to remind her to bring out my husband's french fries. Also, we had to request salt/pepper - which I would prefer just already be placed on the tables. I had the lemon-vodka Cosmopolitan, which was delicious, and my husband ordered a Korbel Old Fashioned. His drink initially just came out as a glass of Korbel, so we did send it back to request it be made into an old fashioned. All issues were resolved quickly and politely. We also got to chat with Dylan, the operations manager, for a bit, and we could tell he was really invested in getting the new digs up to speed. He was very friendly, and accommodating, and seemed to be talking to a lot of other patrons, which is good to see. All in all, we really enjoyed our dinner. The food came out fairly quick. I would suggest to have salt/pepper shakers on the tables, and to have toothpicks and/or mints available on the hostess stand to grab on the way out. We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
If you're having a bad day, go to Water Street Tavern - because I guarantee you will leave there in a great mood! The food, service, and environment are awesome. I would highly recommend the steak sandwich with the bacon Brussels sprouts. I was blown away at how great they tasted! Our server was very kind, and management stopped by our table to make sure everything was perfect. Also, the atmosphere at Water Street Tavern is so cozy and chic. Looking forward to visiting here in the summer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...