Gallagher's Pizza - Suamico

The only consistency is the disappointment I feel after ordering with Gallaghers.

Great pizza honestly. It beats anywhere I grew up for pizza in Wisconsin Dells. Easy. Simple. Good spot. Place is just pretty basic.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent mostacali dinner, an excellent waitress Ruby.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

As soon as I lifted a slice out of our deep dish pizza and saw the stretchy strings of mozzarella, I knew it was gonna be a good one. The crust was crispy, the sauce wasn’t too salty, spicy or bland, and there was a thick layer of tasty cheese that you don’t get on a normal pizza. Way better than an average local pizza place. And delicious root beer!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Order a minestrone soup. It was spicy and tasted like can soup.
I took obviously a spoonful of it and returned. They did not discount the soup from my bill because "i ate from it"... well I had to try it and then find out it was gross.
The manager was rude and unhelpful.
No wonder they are always empty.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

bagged salad for sure, lettuce was rotten. chicken was not fresh didn’t seem real honestly. hair in my food also :/ i was rooting for this place as im new to the area..

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

First time I was there we had the buffet. Half of the food out was cold and only half of the listed items were available. Fast forward to tonight, I ordered the perch which says it's lightly breaded. Needless to say it's all of 75% breading. It tastes like paste and it's not even a clean crunchy paste from using good oil. It's a mix of all the fried foods you taste with the paste. I ate 2 of the 6 filets because I could peel most of the breading off, the other 4 with the crazy breading paste I threw out. I always give a second chance but this place has failed me twice. Not going back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Delicious Mac and cheese pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

was in there the other night. bar was very dirty and unkept. bad service, very slow, not too friendly either. certainly not great food, not terrible, but a little overpriced for the quality you receive. won't be back. don't recommend at all.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Food is good but not consistent. My last pizza was missing the mushrooms I ordered and was over baked. Woman behind the counter wearing a knee length sweater was rude. I showed up 5 minutes early and she said "you know it won't be done yet" but then it comes over baked.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Wish I knew her name, but our server was super friendly. We ordered a chicken bacon pizza, apparently it's her favorite, and cheese curds.
This pizza is the best, hands down. Alfredo sauce, crispy bacon loaded up across the top, melty cheese, and plenty of herbs and spices. The crust is puffy, light, and so delicious. I normally skip the crust, but not on this pizza.
The cheese curds are wonderful. Just enough breading and melty cheese.

Would definitely recommend Gallagher's if you'd like an amazing pizza. Even the next morning, cold from the fridge, this pizza is wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Terrible service. After an hour of waiting, we finally received our appetizers. After 45 more minutes we asked when our food was coming. They didn’t even start it so we got our bill and left. In the time we were there, they served everyone around us and had a line a mile deep waiting for pick up. If you don’t have the staff, stop taking orders.

Really tired of paying so much to have half our food missing or it tastes like it was sitting for hours. They were great when they first came town… unfortunately not a fan after so many screw ups.

Came in to place an order for 2 sandwiches to go. Only 2 tables of customers in whole place. Over 20 minutes passed and young girl who took order had went back to kitchen 6 times and they hadn’t even started it. No one came to pick up any orders during this time. Hardly any meat on sandwich and meat looked old as dirt. Won’t be back!

Service: 2

We get pizza delivered regularly from here and we are never disappointed. Last night we dined in before going to a play. We chose the Friday night buffet. Plenty of options especially loads of shrimp. Our complaint as we paid the bill was that the food was luke warm except for the pizza. Tasted good but.... Hopefully the cashier informed the kitchen which was the reason for speaking up.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3