Cancun Bay

1422 Superior Ave, Tomah
(608) 567-0085

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alexandra Cattron

Me and my boyfriend came here for valentines day. It was our first visit to the new location and the experience was amazing👏

They did tell us itd be a 45min wait to sit down but they were absolutely packed. We ended up only having to wait 10minutes. It did take a couple minutes for someone to take our drink order but once again they were absolutely packed. With how busy it was I was surprised we only had to wait about 30minutes for our food!!

There was also a mariachi band playing live and they were walking around, towards the end of our meal we got surrounded and they sounded amazing and it was just a magical experience, or maybe it seemed magical because I was drunk 😂😂 but 10/10 I WOULD RECOMMEND I LOVE THIS PLACE

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Speerbrecher

I’ll start off with the Food was AMAZING! The margaritas were huge and priced well. The atmosphere had Mexican music playing and decor took you to Mexico as soon as you walked in the door. The only con was our waiter didn’t speak very good English and we questioned whether or not he knew what we asked. But the food was so good we quickly didn’t mind the language barrier.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Tomah Food

Great place for COLD Mexican food

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Justin King

Food is mediocre. Service is probably THE WORST service I’ve ever had in a very long time and I was sitting at the bar. It almost seems like the restaurant doesn’t have enough workers primarily at the bar. The place is HUGE and they have one girl that works the bar. There should be at the very minimum two people working the bar. Food shouldn’t also take 45 minutes to cook 5 enchiladas and 3 tacos. It’s very unfortunate this place moved here. It’s frustrating when you go out for a simple dinner and the service sucks. PLEASE DO BETTER.

justinallanking707

Food is mediocre. Service is probably THE WORST service I’ve ever had in a very long time and I was sitting at the bar. It almost seems like the restaurant doesn’t have enough workers primarily at the bar. The place is HUGE and they have one girl that works the bar. There should be at the very minimum two people working the bar. Food shouldn’t also take 45 minutes to cook 5 enchiladas and 3 tacos. It’s very unfortunate this place moved here. It’s frustrating when you go out for a simple dinner and the service sucks. PLEASE DO BETTER.

Tamara Rousseau

I was surprised the amount of food you got for the money. And it was really good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Herzogblumer

I love ALL of the food and salsa is outstanding. I would recommend this place to anyone who likes mexican food. The blended margaritas are out of this world because they are sooooo smooth. All of the wait staff is attentive to what you need and very polite.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

larrymicke

Traveling back from Chicago, we decided to spend the night in Tomah, WI and needed a place to eat, as well. In the mood for Mexican food, we decided to try Cancun Bay. The four of us were very happy with our food. I didn't want to have a lot to eat so I opted for the 3 soft shell tacos from the ala carte menu. I expected the usual - tacos that would consumed in 3 bites. I was wrong. The tacos were huge! And, tasty! 3 tacos for $6.99 is a good deal. Others had the tostados, fajita quesadilla, and the deluxe burrito. All were generous portions, reasonably priced, and they said the food was good. Recommend this restaurant.

Mary C

I am never disappointed when I go there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler

Amazing food and margaritas. This place never disappoints and I go here every time I'm in the area for training.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

John Ruehle

Not as good as the Reedsburg location but still very good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mr Velocity

The food is amazing and the service is instant. It's rare to find actually good Mexican restaurants in Wisconsin. Amazing place to eat at, highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am Ghost

Very tasty food! I've been all over the US in very good Mexican restaurants and i can consider this restaurant one of the best Mexican food.
These guys must be helped to grow in order to provide very good quality food to the community.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Keding

Great food! Steak tacos are excellent! Good service; Super fast. Reasonable prices.

Food: 5

Tia Marshall

We ordered a carry out order, because we were traveling.
The food was amazing! My friend loved the steak tacos and I got the beef chimichangas. The meat wasnt fatty at all, and had great flavor.
The only reason I gave 4 stars on the atmosphere is because it was a pretty congested area when coming into wwaiting.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...