We got our wedding cake done at Craigs', and we loved it! They worked with us to get exactly the cake we wanted. It was amazingly delicious!!! And it fit our theme and colors perfectly. We will absolutely be back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Janelle Tanaglia
We had a wonderful experience with Craig’s Cake Shop for our wedding! We didn’t book them until about 2 months before our wedding but regardless they never made us feel rushed. They were so friendly and easy to work with. We loved the option of taking a tasting plate to go and had so much fun pairing different flavors. Our 2 tier cake was beautiful and delicious on the wedding day. We also had a variety of other desserts that our guests absolutely devoured(I can’t speak on how they were personally because they were completely eaten up by the time we got to them) but I’m sure that was a good sign! Thank you Elisa and Craig’s for a great job!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trinity Middlebrook
I ordered a cake for my boyfriends birthday party hre! They were quick to give me a quote within 2-3 days. I was not the easiest customer, as I had to change my pickup time twice. They still accomidated, kept the price affordable to my budget, and everyone liked the cake, like... EVERYONE! Thank you guys so much you really made it special and affordable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Megan Houston
We had Craig's Cakes do our wedding cake and desserts and wouldn't change a thing! The tasting option was great- we got to pick up plates, taste on our own time, then schedule a call. Elisa was helpful throughout this whole process. There were a few times during the busy season where I had to follow up and it took a little bit of time to get our contract, but they squeezed us in only a few months before. People are still talking about our cake- the wedding cake was their Neapolitan with buttercream frosting. We added cupcakes for ease (chocolate espresso with chocolate mousse, vanilla with buttercream (gluten free), and vanilla with raspberry jam. They were all wonderful. We ordered over what we expected and had a ton of leftovers to enjoy the week after. As part of our package, delivery was included (downtown Madison), and they showed up timely and set things up beautifully. We even get a mini version of our wedding cake on our one-year anniversary. Friends and family are still talking about the cake and we think about it regularly. It was recommended to us by a local who only uses Craig's Cakes for their family events- look no further!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcakes
Kait Schmidt Thabet I Celebrait by Kait
Great wedding cake for our clients! As a Wedding Planner I definitely recommend them. Photo by The McNiels of course:)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Audrey McIntosh
Beautiful delicious wedding cake and wonderful customer service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Vaughn Greenwood
Craig's cake shop!!!! To make a long story short, the cake we ordered for our wedding was outstanding! All perfectly done!!!! Thank you so much!!! Customer service, professionalism was top notch and taste !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holly Muth
From tasting to catering our wedding and all the custom cakes in between - cant recommend Elizabeth and Craigs enough! The cake is amazing and theres so many options for cake and mousse, and they worked with me and created our own personalized wedding cake! Everything was perfect - we got cupcakes for the guests at the wedding and everyone raved about them!! Our favorite flavors are banana cake with vanilla mousse, lemon poppyseedcake with lemon mousse and carrot cake with cream cheese mousse! Book them!
Craig’s Cakes catered dessert for our wedding and did a phenomenal job! They were great to work with from the initial tasting to the delivery/set up of our dessert table! We got a cutting cake, 4 flavors of cupcakes, and (what I was most excited about) a groom’s cake! My husband has a pet tortoise he adores and I wanted to surprise him by incorporating him into a cake and Elisa and her team blew our minds with the end result! It looked and tasted better than I could have imagined! I will definitely be using them for any future cake needs and am already looking forward to our first anniversary cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Corey Silvis
My wife and I recently got married, and Craig's Cake Shop provided the cakes we served at our 140-ish guest wedding. We had a neopolitan (vanilla cake, chocolate cake, strawberry filling) and pumpkin cake, and they were both wonderful! We didn't even get a chance to try the pumpkin cake before it flew off the tables and into stomachs. The process of getting everything organized was painless, and the price point was far more affordable than expected. We'd definitely use Craig's Cake Shop for future events where cake is necessary!
Amazing vanilla buttercream single layer cake for our wedding, with vanilla mousse filling and delicate decorative roses. Absolutely delicious, exactly what I wanted (I’m a full-on buttercream fan and their recipe nails it). Also shout out to staff who called me 30 minutes before they closed to remind me to pick up my cake (thus averting a cake-pocalypse caused by a miscommunication between me and my cake pick-up volunteer). They’re at the top of my list for cake orders. Thank you!
I needed to order a cake for my mom’s 90th birthday in Verona. I’m in Cincinnati. I google searched for a bakery in the Verona area and loved the cakes I saw on Craig’s website. I crossed my fingers and sent in an order. Elisa worked with me to make sure I got exactly the cake I wanted at the time I needed it. To say the cake was beautiful is an understatement. It was stunning. Everyone at the party raved about how beautiful it was as well as how delicious it was. I highly recommend Craig’s Cake Shop.
Erin Roelke
I can't thank Craig's Cakes enough for providing beautiful and delicious desserts for our wedding day. The cupcakes, shooters and cookies are amazing! They were also very helpful in our meetings and phone calls. On the day of they set up everything so nicely. We received many compliments on the desserts!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Toy
Got our small wedding cutting cake from Craig's, their tasting and order process was easy and fun. The cake was delicious, and it made our day that much more special! Thank you!
Jenna Storbeck
We had Craig's Cake Shop do the desserts for our wedding and everything was so delicious! We got cream puffs, cupcakes (strawberry, lemon, and chocolate), and our cutting cake (carrot cake), and people are still talking about how good it all was. One of our favorite details was that we had them decorate our cutting cake with little versions of our cats, which was such a fun and personal touch. We can’t wait to go back for our anniversary cake next year. Highly recommend them if you want desserts that are both super tasty and super cute!
We got our wedding cake done at Craigs', and we loved it! They worked with us to get exactly the cake we wanted. It was amazingly delicious!!! And it fit our theme and colors perfectly. We will absolutely be back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
We had a wonderful experience with Craig’s Cake Shop for our wedding!
We didn’t book them until about 2 months before our wedding but regardless they never made us feel rushed. They were so friendly and easy to work with. We loved the option of taking a tasting plate to go and had so much fun pairing different flavors. Our 2 tier cake was beautiful and delicious on the wedding day. We also had a variety of other desserts that our guests absolutely devoured(I can’t speak on how they were personally because they were completely eaten up by the time we got to them) but I’m sure that was a good sign! Thank you Elisa and Craig’s for a great job!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a cake for my boyfriends birthday party hre! They were quick to give me a quote within 2-3 days. I was not the easiest customer, as I had to change my pickup time twice. They still accomidated, kept the price affordable to my budget, and everyone liked the cake, like... EVERYONE! Thank you guys so much you really made it special and affordable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
We had Craig's Cakes do our wedding cake and desserts and wouldn't change a thing! The tasting option was great- we got to pick up plates, taste on our own time, then schedule a call. Elisa was helpful throughout this whole process. There were a few times during the busy season where I had to follow up and it took a little bit of time to get our contract, but they squeezed us in only a few months before.
People are still talking about our cake- the wedding cake was their Neapolitan with buttercream frosting. We added cupcakes for ease (chocolate espresso with chocolate mousse, vanilla with buttercream (gluten free), and vanilla with raspberry jam. They were all wonderful. We ordered over what we expected and had a ton of leftovers to enjoy the week after. As part of our package, delivery was included (downtown Madison), and they showed up timely and set things up beautifully. We even get a mini version of our wedding cake on our one-year anniversary. Friends and family are still talking about the cake and we think about it regularly. It was recommended to us by a local who only uses Craig's Cakes for their family events- look no further!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcakes
Great wedding cake for our clients! As a Wedding Planner I definitely recommend them. Photo by The McNiels of course:)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Beautiful delicious wedding cake and wonderful customer service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Craig's cake shop!!!!
To make a long story short, the cake we ordered for our wedding was outstanding! All perfectly done!!!! Thank you so much!!! Customer service, professionalism was top notch and taste !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From tasting to catering our wedding and all the custom cakes in between - cant recommend Elizabeth and Craigs enough! The cake is amazing and theres so many options for cake and mousse, and they worked with me and created our own personalized wedding cake! Everything was perfect - we got cupcakes for the guests at the wedding and everyone raved about them!! Our favorite flavors are banana cake with vanilla mousse, lemon poppyseedcake with lemon mousse and carrot cake with cream cheese mousse! Book them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcakes, Custom Cake
Craig’s Cakes catered dessert for our wedding and did a phenomenal job! They were great to work with from the initial tasting to the delivery/set up of our dessert table! We got a cutting cake, 4 flavors of cupcakes, and (what I was most excited about) a groom’s cake! My husband has a pet tortoise he adores and I wanted to surprise him by incorporating him into a cake and Elisa and her team blew our minds with the end result! It looked and tasted better than I could have imagined! I will definitely be using them for any future cake needs and am already looking forward to our first anniversary cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I recently got married, and Craig's Cake Shop provided the cakes we served at our 140-ish guest wedding. We had a neopolitan (vanilla cake, chocolate cake, strawberry filling) and pumpkin cake, and they were both wonderful! We didn't even get a chance to try the pumpkin cake before it flew off the tables and into stomachs. The process of getting everything organized was painless, and the price point was far more affordable than expected. We'd definitely use Craig's Cake Shop for future events where cake is necessary!
Food: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing vanilla buttercream single layer cake for our wedding, with vanilla mousse filling and delicate decorative roses. Absolutely delicious, exactly what I wanted (I’m a full-on buttercream fan and their recipe nails it). Also shout out to staff who called me 30 minutes before they closed to remind me to pick up my cake (thus averting a cake-pocalypse caused by a miscommunication between me and my cake pick-up volunteer). They’re at the top of my list for cake orders. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Custom Cake, Sheet Cake
I needed to order a cake for my mom’s 90th birthday in Verona. I’m in Cincinnati. I google searched for a bakery in the Verona area and loved the cakes I saw on Craig’s website. I crossed my fingers and sent in an order. Elisa worked with me to make sure I got exactly the cake I wanted at the time I needed it. To say the cake was beautiful is an understatement. It was stunning. Everyone at the party raved about how beautiful it was as well as how delicious it was. I highly recommend Craig’s Cake Shop.
I can't thank Craig's Cakes enough for providing beautiful and delicious desserts for our wedding day. The cupcakes, shooters and cookies are amazing! They were also very helpful in our meetings and phone calls. On the day of they set up everything so nicely. We received many compliments on the desserts!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got our small wedding cutting cake from Craig's, their tasting and order process was easy and fun. The cake was delicious, and it made our day that much more special! Thank you!
We had Craig's Cake Shop do the desserts for our wedding and everything was so delicious! We got cream puffs, cupcakes (strawberry, lemon, and chocolate), and our cutting cake (carrot cake), and people are still talking about how good it all was. One of our favorite details was that we had them decorate our cutting cake with little versions of our cats, which was such a fun and personal touch. We can’t wait to go back for our anniversary cake next year. Highly recommend them if you want desserts that are both super tasty and super cute!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...