The pizza crust was burnt and the tomato sauce tasted like pasta sauce/tomato paste... there was not a lot of flavor. The bbq chicken pizza was better...
Food: 3
Joyce Pauley
💕Ahh, another perfect experience! Speedy delivery and always delivered piping hot! The BEST Pizza and Garlic Bread w/Cheese. Till we meet again💕
Keith Fowler
Amazing food, and service!! Everything fresh and house made.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Schultz
We loved the meat lovers pizza and stuffed breadsticks. We ate at the counter and the guys working were very nice and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jean
ordered 14 " meat pizza and order of o-rings. Delivered.
40.00 a bit pricey, and thin crust was not crispy, pizza was limp and had to be eaten w/a fork. Even tried to air fry to crisp it up with no result. Will not be ordering from them again.
Kathleen Herbst
This is a staple for my family, we love it, fresh ingredients, quick service and the team there is is always nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denise LG
Went here for my husband's birthday while out of town. He wanted pizza and we were very pleased with our experience. Pizza and service were good. They do have a small area to eat in however they are really more of a takeout place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam Weber
My new favorite pizza in the Lake Country Area! We got an extra thick meatball and basil pizza and everything about it was great. I loved the thickness and consistency of the crust. The basil was fresh tasting and smelled so good. And the meatballs were tender and tasty. We will definitely be ordering from Pizza Guy again in the near future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Kerr
Chicken Ranchero Calzone and pepperoni cheese breadsticks 🔥
Heather Scharles
It’s just ok. It’s typical Wisconsin pizza. Pretty mediocre. Sausage is a bit too large and chewy. Pizza sauce tastes like store bought marinara. Nothing spectacular. For that reason. I’d say it’s overpriced.
First time trying this place. Loved it! Got the cheese filled breadsticks and a sausage, pepperoni and mushroom pizza hand tossed. Best cheese sticks! Loaded with cheese that oozed out after taking a bite. Liked the pizza sauce taste and it was well balanced with the cheese and toppings.
Nicole Wittkopp
The cheese sticks are worth the hype! My husband LOVED them- I like them because they’re basically giant mozzarella sticks (nothing wrong with that!). The pizza was very good and good quality. A little on the pricier side but local and convenient so worth it. Overall, good pizza and great cheese sticks. Will be trying their thin crust next time!
Theresa Maddox
Pizza is so much better than dominoes and Pizza hut. The jalapeño poppers and cheese sticks are to die for! The best food I've had in a long rime!
Deanna Brownell
Great Pizza! Great Delivery Service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Raszeja
That is a Philly cheesesteak on garlic bread worthy of a five star google rating!
The pizza crust was burnt and the tomato sauce tasted like pasta sauce/tomato paste... there was not a lot of flavor. The bbq chicken pizza was better...
Food: 3
💕Ahh, another perfect experience! Speedy delivery and always delivered piping hot! The BEST Pizza and Garlic Bread w/Cheese. Till we meet again💕
Amazing food, and service!! Everything fresh and house made.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We loved the meat lovers pizza and stuffed breadsticks. We ate at the counter and the guys working were very nice and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ordered 14 " meat pizza and order of o-rings. Delivered. 40.00 a bit pricey, and thin crust was not crispy, pizza was limp and had to be eaten w/a fork. Even tried to air fry to crisp it up with no result. Will not be ordering from them again.
This is a staple for my family, we love it, fresh ingredients, quick service and the team there is is always nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went here for my husband's birthday while out of town. He wanted pizza and we were very pleased with our experience. Pizza and service were good. They do have a small area to eat in however they are really more of a takeout place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My new favorite pizza in the Lake Country Area! We got an extra thick meatball and basil pizza and everything about it was great. I loved the thickness and consistency of the crust. The basil was fresh tasting and smelled so good. And the meatballs were tender and tasty. We will definitely be ordering from Pizza Guy again in the near future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chicken Ranchero Calzone and pepperoni cheese breadsticks 🔥
It’s just ok. It’s typical Wisconsin pizza. Pretty mediocre. Sausage is a bit too large and chewy. Pizza sauce tastes like store bought marinara. Nothing spectacular. For that reason. I’d say it’s overpriced.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying this place. Loved it! Got the cheese filled breadsticks and a sausage, pepperoni and mushroom pizza hand tossed. Best cheese sticks! Loaded with cheese that oozed out after taking a bite. Liked the pizza sauce taste and it was well balanced with the cheese and toppings.
The cheese sticks are worth the hype! My husband LOVED them- I like them because they’re basically giant mozzarella sticks (nothing wrong with that!).
The pizza was very good and good quality.
A little on the pricier side but local and convenient so worth it.
Overall, good pizza and great cheese sticks. Will be trying their thin crust next time!
Pizza is so much better than dominoes and Pizza hut. The jalapeño poppers and cheese sticks are to die for! The best food I've had in a long rime!
Great Pizza! Great Delivery Service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
That is a Philly cheesesteak on garlic bread worthy of a five star google rating!
Loading...