PJ's Pizza

118 N Church St, Watertown
(920) 261-5299

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Adam Fillmore

Always friendly and helpful staff. Food is fantastic!

Nathan

Friendly staff, great pizza and subs. Taco pizza is a favorite.

Bre Lloyd

Usually the pizza is great but this time it was burnt! Ordered multiple and they were all burnt for the price I paid I'm not very happy about it!!!

Sara Wendt

Such great food always! And service with a smile. Cant beat a small town sandwich shop! And the best pizzas!!

Todd

I love their pizza, in my opinion it is the best in town and the people who work there are extremely friendly.

Jessica H

Ordered lunch for a group at work today and the food was good. They did forget a couple items, which the owner/manager refunded these items when they were made aware of it. The only thing I was unhappy about was the meat to sub roll ratio. I realize the meat it weighed out for consistency, but compared to the roll it is in, it's just too small of a portion. I order Philly steak sandwiches quite often and usually a good one is where the bread and meat ratio is more even. The meat was tasty and the bread they use is great...it's just a small portion. I'd rather pay a little bit more and get a full roll. I did order no onions or mushrooms, but the meat should still reach each end of the roll in my opinion. Just saying-
My co-workers all love the food here and we will keep ordering in the future!!

Jeff

I would be worried to get a cold cut sandwich. Watched them make my pizza and no rubber cloves. Al the end crap onions and put on pizza. Then make sandwiches with the same hands they touched raw pork with. Not right. Won’t be back

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Christopher Warnecke

Super expensive for a sub ordered online

premierleaguepaul

This place has got to figure something out. They’re open till 9 PM But they are very inconsistent on whether they’ll make you something late. They need to change their closing time to 830 or 8 o’clock if they’re not gonna make any food past a certain time what’s the point of being open till 9 PM?

Service: 1

Amanda Glisch

Subs and pizza are amazing was a little disappointed last time because the cashier was obviously NOT paying attention ans got my order wrong twice!

Parking: Parking kinda sucks

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Subs, Sausage & Pepperoni Pizza, Combo Sub

Tyler Jung

I love this place, always fresh, crunchy veggies, great food, nice employees, always. I've never had a bad experience. I Just showed up 10 minutes before close and still got a footlong sub and was out the door before closing time.

Andrea

Tried a Hawaiian pizza. Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Hady

Went for lunch takeout. Had a taco salad. There was enough that I was able to have taco salad for lunch two days.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Taco Salad

Shelly Buchta

Seriously! I thought at these prices you'd get more, or at least your money's worth. My husband's pizza was supposed to have black olives on it and he only got one. This sub is more than embarrassing, especially for the price. Won't be doing them again anytime soon. What a shame, so disappointed. ? Not to mention that I gave a time for pickup (45 minutes after I ordered) and when my husband got there, they hadn't even started the order yet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Lisa Banks

Great place! Great Food! Great People!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...