Wow! Taste of home. Pizza reminds me a lot of my old neighborhood pizza place in Darien, CT just north of NYC. Wish I would have discovered it sooner!
Torie Lasko
We have slowly been trying different pizza places in town and most are meh. The pizza game could be a lot better in Watertown. We tried Rock River Pizza Co tonight and it was delicious. Had the New Yorker 16”. A lot better than most places we have been too in the area. It is only take out which was perfect for us. Thanks for making a great pizza while you are still in the business.
M R
The pizza here is amazing if you like a little char on your crust. My son loves their cheese pizza and he promptly got us hooked on it as well! They currently are only offering take out, but I highly recommend this gem of a place!
Jen Callies
I’m new to town so I decided to give this place a chance. Was not disappointed! Great pizza! Got the buffalo chicken- perfect zest of spice. Not too spicy -just enough. Would love to see the Rock River Pizza Co get back in full swing post Covid. Rooting for you folks!
Stacey A
We arrived before their advertised closure time but they came to the door & said they were closed and it was about 45 minutes to an hour early. Very disappointing.
John Luetzow
Great pizza. Carry out only at this time
wisconsin bike life
Used to be the highlight of Watertown as far as pizza. Now you can’t get anyone to answer the phone ever. And it was a dine in restaurant before covid.. now with the hours and new set up you can’t even go in there and or get ahold of anyone to make you a pizza. Thoroughly disappointed with this place
Mike Hawkey
Owner was 1st class and the pizza was amazing he got us in just before close and was wicked quick about getting our pizza done. If your in town I would definitely recommend
Friendship Bangle
Dining local is important to me and my husband. We ordered take out at Rock River Pizza Co and the Tiramisu was 10 out of 10! Wow! Everything we try is amazing. I definitely recommend this restaurant. Friendly and patient owner as well.
Savannah Katula
The BEST pizza I’ve had in a long time and I enjoy trying different pizza places. I will probably be back later this week for another pizza and garlic bread! We had the Rock River Monster and it was delicious!
I’m new to town so I decided to give this place a chance. Was not disappointed! Great pizza! Got the buffalo chicken- perfect zest of spice. Not too spicy -just enough. Would love to see the Rock River Pizza Co get back in full swing post Covid. Rooting for you folks!
Jess
We love Rock River Pizza, Randy is so great and his pizza is INCREDIBLE. Only place that has that great stone fired pizza crust that reminds me of New York pizza. Highly recommend!
JessNess Monster
Pizza and appetizers were amazing. Some of the best pizza in town, in my opinion. Unfortunately, due to staffing issues, they are take-out only and have a limited menu. The owner was so nice and he let us sit inside while we waited for our food. I recommend supporting this guy and send business his way while he struggles to get back up and running.
Caitlin Vohen
Honestly I’m not sure how they’re still in business.. they don’t do dine in and won’t make half the menu when you call to order. The Monterey was my favorite pizza ever and now I can’t even order it because they don’t want to make it anymore. Like update your menu then.
Mark Hady
Carry out only but pizza was very good and the staff was very friendly
Wow! Taste of home. Pizza reminds me a lot of my old neighborhood pizza place in Darien, CT just north of NYC. Wish I would have discovered it sooner!
We have slowly been trying different pizza places in town and most are meh. The pizza game could be a lot better in Watertown. We tried Rock River Pizza Co tonight and it was delicious. Had the New Yorker 16”. A lot better than most places we have been too in the area. It is only take out which was perfect for us. Thanks for making a great pizza while you are still in the business.
The pizza here is amazing if you like a little char on your crust. My son loves their cheese pizza and he promptly got us hooked on it as well! They currently are only offering take out, but I highly recommend this gem of a place!
I’m new to town so I decided to give this place a chance. Was not disappointed! Great pizza! Got the buffalo chicken- perfect zest of spice. Not too spicy -just enough. Would love to see the Rock River Pizza Co get back in full swing post Covid. Rooting for you folks!
We arrived before their advertised closure time but they came to the door & said they were closed and it was about 45 minutes to an hour early. Very disappointing.
Great pizza. Carry out only at this time
Used to be the highlight of Watertown as far as pizza. Now you can’t get anyone to answer the phone ever. And it was a dine in restaurant before covid.. now with the hours and new set up you can’t even go in there and or get ahold of anyone to make you a pizza. Thoroughly disappointed with this place
Owner was 1st class and the pizza was amazing he got us in just before close and was wicked quick about getting our pizza done. If your in town I would definitely recommend
Dining local is important to me and my husband. We ordered take out at Rock River Pizza Co and the Tiramisu was 10 out of 10! Wow! Everything we try is amazing. I definitely recommend this restaurant. Friendly and patient owner as well.
The BEST pizza I’ve had in a long time and I enjoy trying different pizza places. I will probably be back later this week for another pizza and garlic bread! We had the Rock River Monster and it was delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
I’m new to town so I decided to give this place a chance. Was not disappointed! Great pizza! Got the buffalo chicken- perfect zest of spice. Not too spicy -just enough. Would love to see the Rock River Pizza Co get back in full swing post Covid. Rooting for you folks!
We love Rock River Pizza, Randy is so great and his pizza is INCREDIBLE. Only place that has that great stone fired pizza crust that reminds me of New York pizza. Highly recommend!
Pizza and appetizers were amazing. Some of the best pizza in town, in my opinion. Unfortunately, due to staffing issues, they are take-out only and have a limited menu. The owner was so nice and he let us sit inside while we waited for our food. I recommend supporting this guy and send business his way while he struggles to get back up and running.
Honestly I’m not sure how they’re still in business.. they don’t do dine in and won’t make half the menu when you call to order. The Monterey was my favorite pizza ever and now I can’t even order it because they don’t want to make it anymore. Like update your menu then.
Carry out only but pizza was very good and the staff was very friendly