Silvercryst Supper Club Resort & Motel

Went out for New Years dinner there last night and when I tell you it was absolutely AMAZING! The food was fantastic and service was on point considering how busy it was! Definitely would go back and recommend for anyone looking for some simply amazing food and service.

we had newyears reservations,checked in and they did great from start to finish! Great staff and some of the best food in the area.A++

Food and drinks: Food is excellent and wait staff is super.
Have eaten in the dinning room dozen of times

Service: 5

Been a regular customer, enough that the hostess recognize my girlfriend Renee. We told her a table for 2 and to put Renee on the waiting list. We were told wait time would be about 30 minutes. So as normal, we went to the bar to wait. Ordered drinks and after an hour wait I went up to ask how much longer as we had been waiting an hour. We'll the hostess looked up at me and said Renee you can come up now. I said to her that her tone was very rude and condescending. Her response was, Well that's just how I talk. So the other hostess took us to a table because she wouldn't move. I asked the hostess that took us to the table if she could let the manager or owner know that I would like to talk to them. She looked me, said ok but I'm sure she never said anything to them. At this point I'm sure I will never come there again. It wasn't super busy as I've seen in the past so that isn't the reason for the problems. What a shame to put such disrespectful people as your greeters.
Greg Chiconas
FYI Table waitress as always was very nice, and respectful.

Service: 4

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Silver Crest Supper Club in Wautoma, Wisconsin, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience. The steaks were the true stars of the evening. Each cut was seasoned to absolute perfection, bringing out the rich, savory flavors that only come from top-quality meat and expert preparation.

The tenderloin was simply outstanding—a melt-in-your-mouth cut that was cooked exactly to my liking. It was clear that a lot of care had gone into selecting and preparing this piece of meat. The prime steak was equally impressive, juicy, and bursting with flavor in every bite.

What truly added to the experience was the service. Our server was incredibly friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the meal. Their warm and welcoming attitude added to the overall enjoyment of the evening.

If you're looking for a place that knows how to do steak right, Silver Crest Supper Club is a must-visit. I can't wait to return!

Service: 5

Outstanding old fashion, food is very good, rooms are haunted. Ghost visited our room, and We dont even believe in that stuff.

Service: 4

great dining and exceptionnel service

Excellent service, view and food! Highly recommend!

Service: 5

Good food and great sunset view

As always,the food was excellent. Staff were very friendly. The service was excellent. No complaints.

Food and drinks: Food and drinks at the restaurant were phenomenal

Service: 5

We were not welcomed when we arrived. We were told they did not open for another hour so we put our name in for when they opened. At 5:00 we went up to give our name and were rudely told that the girl who supposedly wrote our name down was not the hostess she was. I wanted to turn around and leave. Very rude!!! We did go into the restaurant and the waitress was a sweetheart. Food was very good.

Some of the best prime rib ever. Beautiful setting on lake. Highly recommend.

Service: 5

Lunch outdoors on beach. So pleasent.

Stopped in for dinner tonight(July 16th). Was sat at our table around 5:25pm. First thing I noticed was how slow our server was. Once we put our order in, we waited over 40 minutes for our food, and during this not once did our server stop in for refills or to check in. Then the food came, my mom's top sirloin was so tough it could barely be cut, we did not bring this to the waiters attention because once again he did not stop at the table one time, and we didn't feel like waiting another 40 minutes for a replacement. $100 for 4 people, not even close to worth the price. My Alfredo was okay but not worth $22, far from it. The place was not busy either, no excuse for the service we received or the quality of the food for the price we payed.

Service: 1

We were lucky enough to score a room last minute. It wasn’t ready when promised as they are as everyone….understaffed. Leslie, the bar manager was super sweet and accommodating and did everything to make our stay exceptional! Every business needs a Leslie on their staff. Leslie, thank you for being so nice to us! Every time we’ve ever eaten here, it’s been nothing but superb! Definitely recommend!

Service: 5