They were very nice but the food was mediocre. I didn’t care for the falafel.
Crystal Howard
One of our absolute favorite spots to eat. We stopped in one day totally on accident- the restaurant we were going to eat at had a long wait. I’m so glad it worked out that way. The family that runs it is soooo kind, you feel like you’re part of the family. The food is so so good. We’ve had the falafel pita, salmon sandwich, jerk chicken pita, and their giant cheeseburger, and the Mediterranean platter and it was all incredible. The cheeseburger is seriously so big. The fries are super great too. What I’m getting at is that the food is incredible, the customer service is unmatched, and the prices have you feeling like you’re eating out in 2015.
Mike Vance MTB (Milwaukee)
Family-owned and family run. Amazing authentic Greek entrees. A must stop if you're in Wauwatosa, WI.
Thomas Kirchen
Always good food and worth the wait.
Evan Ferree
Fantastic food, owners running the place, just great.
Daphne Wang
Amazing food, everything is fresh, seasoned, made with care. Love the salads and gyros.
lolita latson
Listennnn!! This fooood was soooooo good there are no left overs! I recommend the jerk pita! It is out of this world!!!
Kate B
Amazing spot for lunch. The hummus was incredible along with the Greek chicken and Tzatziki sauce. Will be back!
Bryce Ger.
Stopped in at around 12pm on a Tuesday after seeing a recommendation on Reddit.
The guy running the counter was super friendly and offered a suggestion to order when I asked for one (the jerk chicken on pita).
The fries and chicken pita were super good and the atmosphere was very comfortable when I came through.
Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a nice spot with tasty food.
Great fish fry. Staff very friendly. Amazing selection of food on the board. I also appreciate that they clean the tables well between use. Highly recommend this small but wonderful Wauwatosa treasure!
Ashley M
I have been obsessed with the jerk chicken pita for the last few years. I moved out of the area and haven't had it in several months. I was excited to be back in Tosa and chose to get lunch at Cosmos. Unfortunately the quality has gone down hill. The fries came out and were different.. that's ok but the problem was they were very over cooked and hard. Didn't eat them and let them know. The chicken pitas came out and were also overcooked. The chicken was very charred and dry. Let them know and excuses were given. Not sure if I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Jacob Silverstein
Food was amazing. What really stood out was that the whole staff turned a horrible day for our family into a wholesome experience. Made us feel like family.
Always delicious. The tenderness of the chicken is perfect. Thank you Cosmos for always being warm and friendly. If you want to visit an unpretentious spot for all the locals that are in the know, this place is it.
They were very nice but the food was mediocre. I didn’t care for the falafel.
One of our absolute favorite spots to eat. We stopped in one day totally on accident- the restaurant we were going to eat at had a long wait. I’m so glad it worked out that way. The family that runs it is soooo kind, you feel like you’re part of the family. The food is so so good. We’ve had the falafel pita, salmon sandwich, jerk chicken pita, and their giant cheeseburger, and the Mediterranean platter and it was all incredible. The cheeseburger is seriously so big. The fries are super great too. What I’m getting at is that the food is incredible, the customer service is unmatched, and the prices have you feeling like you’re eating out in 2015.
Family-owned and family run. Amazing authentic Greek entrees. A must stop if you're in Wauwatosa, WI.
Always good food and worth the wait.
Fantastic food, owners running the place, just great.
Amazing food, everything is fresh, seasoned, made with care. Love the salads and gyros.
Listennnn!! This fooood was soooooo good there are no left overs! I recommend the jerk pita! It is out of this world!!!
Amazing spot for lunch. The hummus was incredible along with the Greek chicken and Tzatziki sauce. Will be back!
Stopped in at around 12pm on a Tuesday after seeing a recommendation on Reddit.
The guy running the counter was super friendly and offered a suggestion to order when I asked for one (the jerk chicken on pita).
The fries and chicken pita were super good and the atmosphere was very comfortable when I came through.
Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a nice spot with tasty food.
Great food, great service. A gem of Wauwatosa.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great fish fry. Staff very friendly. Amazing selection of food on the board. I also appreciate that they clean the tables well between use. Highly recommend this small but wonderful Wauwatosa treasure!
I have been obsessed with the jerk chicken pita for the last few years. I moved out of the area and haven't had it in several months. I was excited to be back in Tosa and chose to get lunch at Cosmos. Unfortunately the quality has gone down hill. The fries came out and were different.. that's ok but the problem was they were very over cooked and hard. Didn't eat them and let them know. The chicken pitas came out and were also overcooked. The chicken was very charred and dry. Let them know and excuses were given. Not sure if I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Food was amazing. What really stood out was that the whole staff turned a horrible day for our family into a wholesome experience. Made us feel like family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cozy with great food and friendly people.
Parking: Very small but dedicated lot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Falafel 5, Soup, Feta Fries, Baklava, Hummus, Gyro Platter
Always delicious. The tenderness of the chicken is perfect. Thank you Cosmos for always being warm and friendly. If you want to visit an unpretentious spot for all the locals that are in the know, this place is it.
Loading...