Maxfield's Pancake House

2727 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa
(414) 453-6000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jeremiah Brod

The food is 7-10. Some dishes are good, others are very good, and some are very exceptional. If the worst you get is good, have no worries. We live in Oshkosh but made the drive just to eat breakfast here! Service was so exceptional that we left $20 on a $59 bill.

Blintz vs crepes

The crepes are good 7/10, but I would pick the blintz over the crepe every day. Blintz are 9/10.

Sausage links are very large and outstanding quality! You get 4 per order. There is enough to share with another person. But order one for each person, you'll want extra to take home. 9.5/10. The only sausage links I've had in my life that were better are reindeer sausage in Alaska

Hash browns (hollandaise), the star(s) of the show, The hash browns are nearly perfect. Extra crispy, fluffy and light, but slightly dry. I am VERY glad they do not overdo the amount of oil they use. A side of hollandaise is only $2, and is enough for 2 order of hash browns. Without the hollandaise, the hash browns are a solid 8.5 for me. With the hollandaise they are a solid 9.9. I could eat these all day long.

We got here almost right away when they opened. We had always come later. If you go early the place is quiet, you don't have to wait for a table and the food comes so fast you'll think the roadrunner has to be in the kitchen. If you go later in the morning you'll have to contend with the availability of parking, waiting for a table, and the noise. These 'negatives' are all hallmarks of an amazing place. Driving 1h 15m one way just to eat here, is incredibly worth it.

Great thanks to the kitchen and the waitstaff. You guys are amazing. Your efforts make us happy, content, full, and even though we were bursting at the seams, we still want just one more bite!

Mark King

Angel was the perfect host, he may forget a fork but he did ok!!

John Stelmaszek

The service was exceptional. My waiter showed that he truly cared for me & my every need. The food was good not exceptional. The fresh squeezed orange juice had no pulp making me question if it was actually fresh squeezed though it was tasty. The atmosphere was at the level of an average diner. It was a good value for the price.

J F

Visiting from out of town and best place we’ve been to to eat so far. Waitress was great and friendly, remembered all of our orders and didn’t even need to write it down. Everyone was polite and pleasant and we would definitely come back! (And they had the best coffee!!)

J Will

Food was very good staff was very excellent

Callie Barfield

Always great service & just a great classic breakfast spot!

Toni Kelly

Food was good. I'm biased because I still prefer IHOP.

Adin Rekow

It's a nice restaurant and has about 5 pages for a menu. A large selection for breakfast and lunch. Limited hours for being open. You get a lot of food, when you order. Service was very good and the food was tasty. The staff was friendly and knew about what choices were available for making a change on your order. Prices are fair for what you get They offer specials for kids and seniors. Place was clean and good atmosphere for a date. Parking is limited and free.

Jennifer Mackus

Been going to the Maxfields for years. They’re using the egg price increase to raise their prices and add a surcharge for any plate with eggs, including the kids menu. The eggs they serve are terrible, comparable to cheap, fake buffet eggs you’d find at a Holiday Inn free breakfast buffet. Food portions are much smaller too. This is not the quality of food I’ve ever experienced from Maxfields and it was very disappointing, especially after paying $50+ on breakfast for two adults and a toddler. The hostess was also very rude but our server was great, very nice and attentive.

Brett Malcom

Our server was so very nice!:-) She made us feel very welcome and comfortable by being so attentive! I’m definitely going back for the great food and atmosphere!!!

Dietary restrictions: They have lots of different choices for this!

Parking: Parking spaces were abundant when we arrived!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Country Fried Steak, Breakfast Burrito, Salad

Eric Marx

Great dinner food, and outstanding pancakes.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacy Reyes

My family came here to eat and everything was so good. Excellent customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Crafty AF

Great breakfast and they have GF bread! 1st time here and will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shaye Lewis

My granddaughter and I totally enjoyed our meal. Along with the courtesious service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Britt Saunders

Great quality food and excellent service! Love the staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Omelette, Crêpes, Country Fried Steak, Banana French Toast, Breakfast Burrito, Steak and Eggs, Chicken and Waffles, Chocolate Chip Pancakes, Eggs Benedict

Loading...