Panera Bread

850 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa
(414) 375-0379

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Della Scott

The two individuals that took my order were both kind and professional beyond. Special shout out to the person that took my drive thru order! They brightened my day!

Andrew M

Ordered a southwest chicken salad to go. Got a sad blend of mostly yellow lettuce. Very little chicken and the avocado was completely missing. Would expect better for a $13 salad. The coffee and bread were good.

Chris Eicher

Really seems like they're having a hard time figuring it out at this location. Inconsistent, smaller portions, and horrible wait/promise times. I knoq the lunch rush is crazy but this is bad.

J H

Terrible service

Ruby Williams

I don’t usually leave reviews, but after the third time Panera Bread has messed up my order, I’ve had enough. I keep giving this place chances, hoping it was just a one-time mistake, but clearly accuracy and attention to detail are not a priority.

Each time, I’ve either received the wrong item entirely, had missing ingredients, or gotten something I didn’t even order. Whether it's the wrong sandwich, missing soup, or a completely botched customization, it’s always something—and it's incredibly frustrating, especially when you’re paying premium prices for what should be a simple, healthy meal.

To make it worse, there’s little accountability. No real apology, no offer to make it right, just a “we’ll let the team know.” That’s not good enough when this keeps happening.

I really wanted to like Panera, but at this point, I’m done. If you care about getting what you actually paid for, look elsewhere.

Meghan Struck

Ordered lunch for a work meeting and the doordasher stated the order was delivered, but it never was. I called the store and spoke with the manager Barb who apologized for the mishap, remade the order, and had it sent out for delivery by a team member Rob so it would get here on time for the meeting. Excellent customer service!

Life With Animals

Be prepared to wait for a long time. Make sure you have lots of free time available. They get backed up on orders.

Jonathan Kim

They close before the advertised time consistently. Most likely the staff just wants to go home early

Aly

This Panera is great. Staff is always warm and friendly, and the food hasn’t missed.

Sky Sirinek

So delicious, their smoothies are more like slushies though

TeaParty Madness

Overall a bad experience for lunch from poor quality soup (that they knew wasn't good because she made a new batch after we said something) to slow wait times because they accidentally deleted the order. Would not come back to this location.

Theresa Turner

This place is new. It was a pleasure getting to go inside for the first time. This is right by where I work so it's going to be trouble. And they have a drive thru too?!?! I'm be there real soon.

Nancy L.

It was just a pickup order so really no employee interaction.

Saad Habayeb

Severely understaffed during lunch time. Wait time is almost an hour.

Theresa Chada

I always get the ham, egg and cheese (cheddar because with Swiss so I substitute) and the passion papaya green iced tea are both amazing. As well as their salads. I recommend!

Loading...