I visited for the first time yesterday and found this to be a cozy atmosphere with good food and friendly staff. I’m looking forward to coming back.
Jill Busch
We recently hosted my daughter’s baby shower at Timmer’s in their private event room. It was absolutely perfect. Working with Allison was amazing. She was so attentive to our needs and met with us several times to make sure everything was perfect. The room was set up beautifully. The food was wonderful. The staff seemed invisible but our guests were so well taken care of. Many of our guests commented on the room, the service, the beautiful location, and the food. Thank you Allison and the Timmer’s team!
Angela Czarnecki
Took my husband for his 51st birthday. The atmosphere and the food is amazing! The best part was our server Tiffany! She’s super funny and does an amazing job!
John Hanrahan
We dined last night (Saturday) with a large group for my father‘s 90th birthday dinner. The food and drinks were amazing, and Mitch our waiter was outstanding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Fredrick David
It was great as always! The staff also are so wonderful every time we go. Keep up the great work and we highly recommend others to eat here.
Meh. Had been here some years ago for an enjoyable experience and decided to come for our anniversary again recently. Setting is very picturesque and I would recommend dining outside if weather permits; inside has very limited views of lake and property. Waitress was already asking for drink order after we had only been seated 10 seconds and hadn't even had a chance to glance at limited wine list; felt like they were already looking to turn over the table as soon as we were seated. She also remarked several times about how this was her 2nd job and how she had only recently finished training and drinks were slow because bartender was also helping serve; impression was that management is not staffing sufficient to demand and not giving staff sufficient training or support. My wife enjoyed her lobster tails and we liked the brie appetizer. My burger was fairly rare (I asked for medium well) and pretty tasteless. Given the quite high prices, I was anticipating better. Menu selection was quite limited as well. Maybe they're just having some growing pains, but value for the money didn't seem to be there this time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Gail Olson
Our waitress made my husband and our party of 6 feel very special on his 75th birthday. Thank you for the excellent service and wonderful evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Braised Pork Shank, Walleye, Prime Rib Sandwich
John Katzer
if you want to experienie the true supper club dinner this ts the place to go. food was excellent along with the cocktails and the atmosphere .sat out on the patio what a great time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
claudia ericson
Allison was wonderful to work with for our event. Several Wisconsin supper club-connoisseur guests said it was the best fish fry they’d ever had!
Kid-friendliness: Lawn for outdoor play and Outdoor games and fire pit made great entertainment for every age group.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cod
Chris Krause
Good food. Server was fun and the atmosphere was very nice.
My husband and I rented the parlor for our daughter's post wedding celebration. Allison, the event planner was excellent in every way! She covered every detail, was organized, efficient and so pleasant to work with. She made the process of planning the event completely stress free! Bonnie, our server, was on top of everything and even followed up on my husband's gluten allergy to make sure Timmer's and we were on the same page. The appetizers were delicious and we received may compliments from our guests. Kirsten, our bartender, makes a great old fashion and is the sweetest girl ever! We could not have asked for a better experience! Tom & Laurie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary R Linehan
Brought my friend for the first time. Have been telling her about Timmer’s for years. It did not disappoint. We split the salmon and the watermelon salad. Nice Sauvignon Blanc as the finishing touch. Great staff and ambiance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef's Seasonal Salad
Kate Tranchita
Awful. To give the food 1 star is incredibly generous, ESPECIALLY FOR THE PRICE. We had a party of 9, paid $30-$50 per plate and nobody enjoyed their food. Even the kids didn’t like the Mac n cheese which says a lot!!! Basically every plate was nearly tasteless. The service was fine, but I’ll take good food over good service when that’s what you’re paying for. Extremely disappointing!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Alec Fantl
High expectations and overall a let down.
Awesome looking property. Nice to look at.
Coconut shrimp is processed and frozen, and that was the highlight of our meal.
Calamari appetizer was simply not good.
Worst part was the perch smelled like a swamp and came out cold even after the server assured us she would time it correctly.
I don't go out of my way to leave negative reviews and this place was highly rated, so I was not anticipating having to leave this sort of review.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Scott McKittrick
Crusted cod was overdone and extremely salty. Steak sandwich was very tough, low quality meat. It's very easy to make a good fish fry, but they fail miserably at even this simple task. We won't be going back.
I visited for the first time yesterday and found this to be a cozy atmosphere with good food and friendly staff. I’m looking forward to coming back.
We recently hosted my daughter’s baby shower at Timmer’s in their private event room. It was absolutely perfect. Working with Allison was amazing. She was so attentive to our needs and met with us several times to make sure everything was perfect. The room was set up beautifully. The food was wonderful. The staff seemed invisible but our guests were so well taken care of. Many of our guests commented on the room, the service, the beautiful location, and the food. Thank you Allison and the Timmer’s team!
Took my husband for his 51st birthday. The atmosphere and the food is amazing! The best part was our server Tiffany! She’s super funny and does an amazing job!
We dined last night (Saturday) with a large group for my father‘s 90th birthday dinner. The food and drinks were amazing, and Mitch our waiter was outstanding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was great as always! The staff also are so wonderful every time we go. Keep up the great work and we highly recommend others to eat here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef's Seasonal Salad, Grilled Filet Mignon
Meh. Had been here some years ago for an enjoyable experience and decided to come for our anniversary again recently. Setting is very picturesque and I would recommend dining outside if weather permits; inside has very limited views of lake and property. Waitress was already asking for drink order after we had only been seated 10 seconds and hadn't even had a chance to glance at limited wine list; felt like they were already looking to turn over the table as soon as we were seated. She also remarked several times about how this was her 2nd job and how she had only recently finished training and drinks were slow because bartender was also helping serve; impression was that management is not staffing sufficient to demand and not giving staff sufficient training or support. My wife enjoyed her lobster tails and we liked the brie appetizer. My burger was fairly rare (I asked for medium well) and pretty tasteless. Given the quite high prices, I was anticipating better. Menu selection was quite limited as well. Maybe they're just having some growing pains, but value for the money didn't seem to be there this time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Our waitress made my husband and our party of 6 feel very special on his 75th birthday. Thank you for the excellent service and wonderful evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Braised Pork Shank, Walleye, Prime Rib Sandwich
if you want to experienie the true supper club dinner this ts the place to go. food was excellent along with the cocktails and the atmosphere .sat out on the patio what a great time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allison was wonderful to work with for our event. Several Wisconsin supper club-connoisseur guests said it was the best fish fry they’d ever had!
Kid-friendliness: Lawn for outdoor play and Outdoor games and fire pit made great entertainment for every age group.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cod
Good food. Server was fun and the atmosphere was very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I rented the parlor for our daughter's post wedding celebration. Allison, the event planner was excellent in every way! She covered every detail, was organized, efficient and so pleasant to work with. She made the process of planning the event completely stress free! Bonnie, our server, was on top of everything and even followed up on my husband's gluten allergy to make sure Timmer's and we were on the same page. The appetizers were delicious and we received may compliments from our guests. Kirsten, our bartender, makes a great old fashion and is the sweetest girl ever! We could not have asked for a better experience! Tom & Laurie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brought my friend for the first time. Have been telling her about Timmer’s for years. It did not disappoint. We split the salmon and the watermelon salad. Nice Sauvignon Blanc as the finishing touch. Great staff and ambiance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef's Seasonal Salad
Awful. To give the food 1 star is incredibly generous, ESPECIALLY FOR THE PRICE. We had a party of 9, paid $30-$50 per plate and nobody enjoyed their food. Even the kids didn’t like the Mac n cheese which says a lot!!! Basically every plate was nearly tasteless. The service was fine, but I’ll take good food over good service when that’s what you’re paying for. Extremely disappointing!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
High expectations and overall a let down.
Awesome looking property. Nice to look at.
Coconut shrimp is processed and frozen, and that was the highlight of our meal.
Calamari appetizer was simply not good.
Worst part was the perch smelled like a swamp and came out cold even after the server assured us she would time it correctly.
I don't go out of my way to leave negative reviews and this place was highly rated, so I was not anticipating having to leave this sort of review.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Crusted cod was overdone and extremely salty. Steak sandwich was very tough, low quality meat. It's very easy to make a good fish fry, but they fail miserably at even this simple task. We won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loading...