Wish was exceptional in all aspects of our dining experience last night! Cindy is a very talented server with a pleasant demeanor and knows all the details about the entire menu! Nice work Cindy! The food and drinks were the best of the best!
Wayne Michelli
We come in every year for the Oshkosh airshow and have a group of 15-20 visit WISH Steakhouse for dinner. It has always been an issue getting reservations in the past and once there seemed like we were a nuisance being a larger group. This year was different, group of 14 called on a Friday afternoon and no problem. There seems to be a reason for that as when we arrived at 6:30 there was only a few cars on the lot and a couple of tables in the dinning room.
Servers were great but the food was the issue. I had a ribeye blackened as I have ordered in the past medium rare. The ribeye was so tough and after 3 bites and splitting out 2 of them I informed the server that steak was tough and just take away. She offered to replace with something else but as slow as the kitchen is I knew everyone would have been finished before a replacement would have arrived. After not eating my steak the check arrived with 9.40 discounted off a 96.50 check. My ribeye was 44.00 plus 3.00 blackened, had a baked potato with butter and asked for more butter as all the butter had melted before entree came to table and run into plate. Guess what I got charged 1.00 for a small scoop of extra butter. Really, serve a in editable tough steak with potato for 48.00 and discount 9.40 off.
Funny when we were Oshkosh this week went to a Texas Roadhouse and ordered and ribeye at 1/2 the price and was so tender, keep that in mind when you visit WISH, they do not stand behind their meals and their attitude is to bad pay your bill and we do not care if you come back which may have reflected on why the parking lots was empty on a Friday night .
Rachel Voeks
Good food, on the pricier side. I had salmon. Wife had sirloin. Not a very extensive menu
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelsea Racine
Food was great, wait staff was less so. We were the first people in the resteraunt. It took 40 minutes to get our drinks and appetizer (they literally showed up at the same time). It took over an hour to get our food. We complained. After ordering a second drink at the 1 hour mark, we got it 30 minutes later, after the food was gone and we were impatiently waiting for our bill. Despite our complaint, the waitress seemed clueless. Our complaint did nothing. Didn't make her remember that we existed, and certainly wasn't reflected in our bill. Will not go back.
Grant
It was ok but I feel at the price they charge they dint meet the standards they should be held at. The service was slow and we ordered 2 ribeye stakes one was over cooked and the other was under done. They were still good but expected them to be cooked right for that price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Lord Dracon
Expect a long wait (took about 45 minutes for the food), they only have alcoholic beverages or tap water, very expensive, they said you need a reservation but it was mostly empty almost the entire time
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
royal anderson
Very nice restaurant with huge bar and outdoor seating. Service is spectacular, everyone was friendly and helpful with questions. There were 5 of us, 3 ordered the filet mignon and 2 of us had a New York strip. Everyone except my wife, order them medium, she had them burn her filet. The steaks came out hot and cooked perfectly to order. I even had leftovers. Is not a cheap place though, our bill without tip was $410. We did all have at least two drinks each. And the ladies ordered a bottle of wine as well. For a special occasion it was worth every penny. I almost forgot, the cheese curds are the best any of us ever had!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
Jacob Carlson
Really lovely dinner and great service, totally fair prices for what you’re getting
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Liberty Tax Service
Service was prompt and with a smile. Our server, Doug, was awesome. Steaks were superb and cheese curds to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jane Bianca N.
Wait staff was excellent! A big group of 16 & we all got our delicious food together. Tempura green bean & roasted brussel sprouts are to die for.
We frequently go to, or order carryout from, WISH Steakhouse. Friday night fish fry is our staple, and other evenings we enjoy the burgers. When looking for a good place to sit down and dine in, it’s always at the top of our list. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Helen H
Wish is the best! Last night, we had a server, Kyle who was so kind, polite, and funny! For a meal, I got the salmon, which was perfectly seared and had delicious vegetables underneath. My mom got the shrimp scampi, my sister got a ceaser salad with salmon, and my grandma got a filet mignon with a twice-baked potato (Which is a must-try). All were amazing! For dessert, we tried the BEST caramel budino, the key lime pie which is fresh, and I had some churro cinnamon ice cream, which was very good. Overall, a great experience!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butterscotch Budino, Cesar Salad, Key Lime Pie, Filet Mignon 6oz, Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Brook J
I recently dined at Wish for the second time, hoping for an improved experience. While the scallops and asparagus were well-prepared and enjoyable, the lobster bisque was unfortunately average. It lacked the lobster lumps often used as garnish, which would have helped to elevate the flavor.
Unfortunately, my date was underwhelmed by his 6 oz filet and twice-baked potato, which didn’t live up to expectations. The food was good, but not special.
Despite the decent food, the service and ambiance were lacking, which made it difficult to fully appreciate the meal. While I wanted to like this place more, the consistent shortcomings in service and atmosphere make it hard to justify a return visit.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Nancy Prigge
My Shrimp Scampi great! Fresh corn from cob. Cut off cocc. Delicious! 4 gals had 1/2 rack ribs. There were not hot/ just warm. The meat was tough. Wish gave those gals $5 off their meals. 1 gal had walleye, very good. Choice of sides were very good. Id go again. Not sure I'd get steak or ribs. But shrimp was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake, Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Brutus Brasi
Looks ok. Service was trash. Food was okay but not worth price. Would I recommend ? Probably not.
Wish was exceptional in all aspects of our dining experience last night! Cindy is a very talented server with a pleasant demeanor and knows all the details about the entire menu! Nice work Cindy! The food and drinks were the best of the best!
We come in every year for the Oshkosh airshow and have a group of 15-20 visit WISH Steakhouse for dinner. It has always been an issue getting reservations in the past and once there seemed like we were a nuisance being a larger group. This year was different, group of 14 called on a Friday afternoon and no problem. There seems to be a reason for that as when we arrived at 6:30 there was only a few cars on the lot and a couple of tables in the dinning room. Servers were great but the food was the issue. I had a ribeye blackened as I have ordered in the past medium rare. The ribeye was so tough and after 3 bites and splitting out 2 of them I informed the server that steak was tough and just take away. She offered to replace with something else but as slow as the kitchen is I knew everyone would have been finished before a replacement would have arrived. After not eating my steak the check arrived with 9.40 discounted off a 96.50 check. My ribeye was 44.00 plus 3.00 blackened, had a baked potato with butter and asked for more butter as all the butter had melted before entree came to table and run into plate. Guess what I got charged 1.00 for a small scoop of extra butter. Really, serve a in editable tough steak with potato for 48.00 and discount 9.40 off. Funny when we were Oshkosh this week went to a Texas Roadhouse and ordered and ribeye at 1/2 the price and was so tender, keep that in mind when you visit WISH, they do not stand behind their meals and their attitude is to bad pay your bill and we do not care if you come back which may have reflected on why the parking lots was empty on a Friday night .
Good food, on the pricier side. I had salmon. Wife had sirloin. Not a very extensive menu
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great, wait staff was less so. We were the first people in the resteraunt. It took 40 minutes to get our drinks and appetizer (they literally showed up at the same time). It took over an hour to get our food. We complained. After ordering a second drink at the 1 hour mark, we got it 30 minutes later, after the food was gone and we were impatiently waiting for our bill. Despite our complaint, the waitress seemed clueless. Our complaint did nothing. Didn't make her remember that we existed, and certainly wasn't reflected in our bill. Will not go back.
It was ok but I feel at the price they charge they dint meet the standards they should be held at. The service was slow and we ordered 2 ribeye stakes one was over cooked and the other was under done. They were still good but expected them to be cooked right for that price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Expect a long wait (took about 45 minutes for the food), they only have alcoholic beverages or tap water, very expensive, they said you need a reservation but it was mostly empty almost the entire time
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Very nice restaurant with huge bar and outdoor seating. Service is spectacular, everyone was friendly and helpful with questions. There were 5 of us, 3 ordered the filet mignon and 2 of us had a New York strip. Everyone except my wife, order them medium, she had them burn her filet. The steaks came out hot and cooked perfectly to order. I even had leftovers. Is not a cheap place though, our bill without tip was $410. We did all have at least two drinks each. And the ladies ordered a bottle of wine as well. For a special occasion it was worth every penny. I almost forgot, the cheese curds are the best any of us ever had!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
Really lovely dinner and great service, totally fair prices for what you’re getting
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was prompt and with a smile. Our server, Doug, was awesome. Steaks were superb and cheese curds to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wait staff was excellent! A big group of 16 & we all got our delicious food together. Tempura green bean & roasted brussel sprouts are to die for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brussels Sprouts, Cheese Curds, Filet Mignon 6oz
Restaurantji Recommends
We frequently go to, or order carryout from, WISH Steakhouse. Friday night fish fry is our staple, and other evenings we enjoy the burgers. When looking for a good place to sit down and dine in, it’s always at the top of our list. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wish is the best! Last night, we had a server, Kyle who was so kind, polite, and funny! For a meal, I got the salmon, which was perfectly seared and had delicious vegetables underneath. My mom got the shrimp scampi, my sister got a ceaser salad with salmon, and my grandma got a filet mignon with a twice-baked potato (Which is a must-try). All were amazing! For dessert, we tried the BEST caramel budino, the key lime pie which is fresh, and I had some churro cinnamon ice cream, which was very good. Overall, a great experience!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butterscotch Budino, Cesar Salad, Key Lime Pie, Filet Mignon 6oz, Shrimp Scampi Pasta
I recently dined at Wish for the second time, hoping for an improved experience. While the scallops and asparagus were well-prepared and enjoyable, the lobster bisque was unfortunately average. It lacked the lobster lumps often used as garnish, which would have helped to elevate the flavor.
Unfortunately, my date was underwhelmed by his 6 oz filet and twice-baked potato, which didn’t live up to expectations.
The food was good, but not special.
Despite the decent food, the service and ambiance were lacking, which made it difficult to fully appreciate the meal. While I wanted to like this place more, the consistent shortcomings in service and atmosphere make it hard to justify a return visit.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
My Shrimp Scampi great! Fresh corn from cob. Cut off cocc. Delicious! 4 gals had 1/2 rack ribs. There were not hot/ just warm. The meat was tough. Wish gave those gals $5 off their meals. 1 gal had walleye, very good. Choice of sides were very good. Id go again. Not sure I'd get steak or ribs. But shrimp was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake, Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Looks ok. Service was trash. Food was okay but not worth price. Would I recommend ? Probably not.
Loading...