I’ve had an amazing experience with Toppers during the two years I’ve been at Whitewater, great deals, great pizza, and super kind staff. I always get carryout because the deals are amazing, but this time when I placed my order and got to my car, it wouldn’t start. I called them, and they delivered the pizza with no extra charge. I made sure to tip the driver well.
11/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samantha La Breche
Ordered a pizza through Doordash, my pizza was missing half of its toppings and the crust seemed undercooked though it had clearly been through the oven and was warm. My mac n cheese was fine. I'll probably stick with ordering Domino's in the future.
Anne indermuehle
Pizza is Usually always pretty good from here. A bit pricey without a deal. Deals usually aren’t that great. Definitely disheartening to see the fake dyes and artificial crap in their nacho cheese dipping sauce. Especially when their headquarters is in Wisconsin! Makes one wonder how much other artificial Ingredients in their food!
eric esser
i ordered a large pepperoni pizza and had 10 pepperoni slices on it since when do we use that little? that definitely felt like a ripoff
Cesar Mendoza
Best pizza place In whitewater! Pizza is always on point
Malinda Aney
I have been ordering Toppers since my undergrad days, which was quite a while ago now, it was practically the only reason I had a checkbook lol. I loved the days of getting pepperoncinis with the cheese pizza. I think the biggest draw back these days is the prepackaged nacho cheese that comes with the triple order of breadsticks. I loved the old nacho cheese and it’s been quite a deal breaker for me. The new nacho cheese is saltier and has a processed side taste. Bring back the old nacho cheese sauce lol!! Still love your variety of pizzas though and great customer service:)
Rev J
Great people. The specialty pizzas, especially the one with tots and chives, was excellent. The mundane pizzas are more so-so. The Garlic Cheese bread is absolutely amazing. The people are super friendly. My only complaint is that it's pretty expensive for pizza, but if you find the stuff you like there, it's worth it.
Tony Pennuto
The marinara sauce used to be good. Now, it tastes like ketchup. Pizza and stix are always good, but for real - taste your marinara Toppers. It's runny and lacks real flavor.
Kyler Satterstrom
Sat at the register for 10 minutes. Four people were working and I talked to every one of them saying they’ll “get to me in a minute.” Not one person came to the register, disrespectful as hell.
Lucas Madecky
Love this pizza, favorite chain for pizza, hands down. The Topperstix are also great anytime. Not much place to sit and eat, definitely meant for take-out and delivery. The staff here are always cool and the options are varied. Tried the Pan crust recently and loved it, toppings and cheese all the way to the edge! I've been having Toppers since I was a kid and will always be going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Original Topperstix, Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
I’ve had an amazing experience with Toppers during the two years I’ve been at Whitewater, great deals, great pizza, and super kind staff. I always get carryout because the deals are amazing, but this time when I placed my order and got to my car, it wouldn’t start. I called them, and they delivered the pizza with no extra charge. I made sure to tip the driver well.
11/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a pizza through Doordash, my pizza was missing half of its toppings and the crust seemed undercooked though it had clearly been through the oven and was warm. My mac n cheese was fine. I'll probably stick with ordering Domino's in the future.
Pizza is Usually always pretty good from here. A bit pricey without a deal. Deals usually aren’t that great. Definitely disheartening to see the fake dyes and artificial crap in their nacho cheese dipping sauce. Especially when their headquarters is in Wisconsin!
Makes one wonder how much other artificial Ingredients in their food!
i ordered a large pepperoni pizza and had 10 pepperoni slices on it since when do we use that little? that definitely felt like a ripoff
Best pizza place In whitewater! Pizza is always on point
I have been ordering Toppers since my undergrad days, which was quite a while ago now, it was practically the only reason I had a checkbook lol. I loved the days of getting pepperoncinis with the cheese pizza. I think the biggest draw back these days is the prepackaged nacho cheese that comes with the triple order of breadsticks. I loved the old nacho cheese and it’s been quite a deal breaker for me. The new nacho cheese is saltier and has a processed side taste. Bring back the old nacho cheese sauce lol!! Still love your variety of pizzas though and great customer service:)
Great people. The specialty pizzas, especially the one with tots and chives, was excellent. The mundane pizzas are more so-so. The Garlic Cheese bread is absolutely amazing. The people are super friendly. My only complaint is that it's pretty expensive for pizza, but if you find the stuff you like there, it's worth it.
The marinara sauce used to be good. Now, it tastes like ketchup. Pizza and stix are always good, but for real - taste your marinara Toppers. It's runny and lacks real flavor.
Sat at the register for 10 minutes. Four people were working and I talked to every one of them saying they’ll “get to me in a minute.” Not one person came to the register, disrespectful as hell.
Love this pizza, favorite chain for pizza, hands down. The Topperstix are also great anytime. Not much place to sit and eat, definitely meant for take-out and delivery. The staff here are always cool and the options are varied. Tried the Pan crust recently and loved it, toppings and cheese all the way to the edge! I've been having Toppers since I was a kid and will always be going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Original Topperstix, Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Chipotle ranch
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Nachostix
Parking: Tons of spots
Kid-friendliness: It has no hazards and is full of seats
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Original Topperstix
Wonderful location. We always have fantastic food and the service has always been great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clearly no quality control when a pizza is half finished.
Food: 2
Nice wings
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...