Waiter was lovely. Food was great. The noise level inside was high. Some was due to customers that were clearly hard of hearing. Made it difficult to have a conversation even tho we sat by windows. Great outdoor seating, recommend you ask for outdoor seating.
Carole
Great food and excellent service. We arrived early at 5:00pm and were seated right away. Perfect timing to see a show at the Belfry.
John
Our go to restaurant when I am near Williams Bay, Wisconsin. I have stopped in at least a half dozen times through the years and have always left full and satisfied. We normally order the Chicken Picatta and the Chicken Lucca which leaves with just enough space for dessert (The carrot cake is our fav). The food never disappoints and we had outstanding service. Our waiter took great care of us the entire time. Easy to locate and plenty of parking available. Highly recommend if in the area
Elizabeth
We had a lovely dinner and the food was great! Our server was very attentive and efficient. Our bus people were so polite and nice!!! We were with friends who hadn't previously been there and they had a wonderful time! I always love going to Cafe!!
Kim
We were first timers. Numerous mistakes with our order given to a generally happy but unconcerned server. 3 of the 4 of us did not even finish our meal, it was that bad. At 3 out of 4 you know it's not fixable just don't go back.
Dawn
We've dined here several times, the food is always good. It's not cheap, but good. Service, not so much. Waitstaff is inattentive.
Lucinda
Outdoor dining was lovely, the fans kept it comfortable and it felt chic classy. Tammy made it memorable, she has a gift of making you feel at ease even when just learning to dine alone.
Jim
Beautiful evening dining outdoors Service and food excellent as we have come to expect A favorite dining spot when in Lake Geneva
David
Overall, the food was good not great. we had the Barata which was good and the seafood pasta also good. The service was great.  they accommodated us by having a table with a view of the lake across the street. They get extra points for doing that.
Mary Alice
We had a wonderful dinner, on the patio, last evening. We enjoyed Terlato Pinot Grigio, along with multiple Toto's on the rocks. Brooke was very sweet and attentive. I ordered the salmon, and my friends had a pasta dish and spinach stuffed chicken. We had no room for dessert; but we will definitely return.
We have to keep Cage Calamari on our “mental radar”! The prices are quite good given the quality and ambiance. Drinks are a little pricey but generous. We loved our dinner and experience!
sarah
What a great experience, fabulous ambiance and even better food! Loved celebreting our anniversary here! Will go back!!
Kailey
super good experience! our server was great and the food was amazing, the volume was perfect to hear conversation without yelling
Rosellen
Been there a few years back, but always busy on weekends. Loved the oroginal calamari and generous portions. We will definitely be regulars when in town .
Amy
Highly recommend Cafe Calamari for a great customer experience! Thank you to the front staff to the back of the house. Every dish was delicious and served with a smile. Amy D.
Waiter was lovely. Food was great. The noise level inside was high. Some was due to customers that were clearly hard of hearing. Made it difficult to have a conversation even tho we sat by windows. Great outdoor seating, recommend you ask for outdoor seating.
Great food and excellent service. We arrived early at 5:00pm and were seated right away. Perfect timing to see a show at the Belfry.
Our go to restaurant when I am near Williams Bay, Wisconsin. I have stopped in at least a half dozen times through the years and have always left full and satisfied. We normally order the Chicken Picatta and the Chicken Lucca which leaves with just enough space for dessert (The carrot cake is our fav). The food never disappoints and we had outstanding service. Our waiter took great care of us the entire time. Easy to locate and plenty of parking available. Highly recommend if in the area
We had a lovely dinner and the food was great! Our server was very attentive and efficient. Our bus people were so polite and nice!!! We were with friends who hadn't previously been there and they had a wonderful time! I always love going to Cafe!!
We were first timers. Numerous mistakes with our order given to a generally happy but unconcerned server. 3 of the 4 of us did not even finish our meal, it was that bad. At 3 out of 4 you know it's not fixable just don't go back.
We've dined here several times, the food is always good. It's not cheap, but good. Service, not so much. Waitstaff is inattentive.
Outdoor dining was lovely, the fans kept it comfortable and it felt chic classy. Tammy made it memorable, she has a gift of making you feel at ease even when just learning to dine alone.
Beautiful evening dining outdoors Service and food excellent as we have come to expect A favorite dining spot when in Lake Geneva
Overall, the food was good not great. we had the Barata which was good and the seafood pasta also good. The service was great.  they accommodated us by having a table with a view of the lake across the street. They get extra points for doing that.
We had a wonderful dinner, on the patio, last evening. We enjoyed Terlato Pinot Grigio, along with multiple Toto's on the rocks. Brooke was very sweet and attentive. I ordered the salmon, and my friends had a pasta dish and spinach stuffed chicken. We had no room for dessert; but we will definitely return.
Restaurantji Recommends
We have to keep Cage Calamari on our “mental radar”! The prices are quite good given the quality and ambiance. Drinks are a little pricey but generous. We loved our dinner and experience!
What a great experience, fabulous ambiance and even better food! Loved celebreting our anniversary here! Will go back!!
super good experience! our server was great and the food was amazing, the volume was perfect to hear conversation without yelling
Been there a few years back, but always busy on weekends. Loved the oroginal calamari and generous portions. We will definitely be regulars when in town .
Highly recommend Cafe Calamari for a great customer experience! Thank you to the front staff to the back of the house. Every dish was delicious and served with a smile. Amy D.
Loading...