We ordered ribeyes, twice baked potatoes and French onion soup along with key lime pie for dessert. Ribeyes were cooked ok, typical ribeye with a lot of fat, the double baked potato’s were salty and way too much cheese on them. The French onion soup was ok but could have been a bit less salty and a little less bread in them. Key lime pie was great. Expected a 5 star dinner but got a 3 star meal. Portions were great, just lay off the salt and cheese. Service was excellent!
Laura Kron
Food was really good. We will definitely be back.
Jerry Camps
Jennifer and Jeff your place is amazing. Great food wonderful service. We have not had a bad meal ever. Servers like Emma make for a great night out. We will continue to spread the word how great a place the Off The Wolf is. Thank you.
Linda Lemerand
Pleasant, clean and friendly atmosphere. The old fashions were good, but you need to request that they muddle if that's how you like them. The food and service were excellent. Prices were average.
Zachary Pascarella
Excellent all around! The food is incredible, the drinks are great, and the service/staff are all extremely friendly and fast!
Dayra Stanek
I love this place! The food is always excellent. Service is excellent! We took a friend for his birthday last Friday and I got the Beer Battered Haddock special. THAT WAS THE BEST BEER BATTERED FISH I HAVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!!! I usually get the Salmon. I love that too, but I have a new favorite now. Please have this special list often. I usually make a reservation, but at the last minute we decided to go for our friend’s birthday, we arrived close to opening time. I want to thank the nice lady who checked us in at the front. Thank you so much for getting us a table. Thank you for making our friend Steve feel special on his birthday 🎂 He loved the ice cream and cake. We will definitely be back soon. Its so nice to have a fabulous restaurant in Winneconne close to home.I highly recommend 😃
Michael Testa
Great service, had the best pan fried grouper I have ever had. Love those crispy pieces of bread they serve as well, great experience and great value.
Manbear Pig
The service and the food was good, the appetizers looked really good. Especially the crab cakes
L M
Beautiful Quaint Setting with Quiet Calm Atmosphere Attentive Staff:) Heads Up The Tender Primerib Seasoned Strongly With Rosemary Very Pungent Even in the Aju' Sorry Was Scraped Off as Much as Possible too Piney Flavored:( Mushroom burger is a Loaded Crusty Bun Melted Cheese Guessing a Whole Pint of Baby Portabella Mushrooms with An Unique Seasoning Hard to Place what was it?:) Not Sure if I liked just Greatful there Was a Vegetarian Option Wishing Is Was More of a Butter Flavor Instead:) One Staying Safe With A Burger as You can't got Wrong along with The Delicious Fries Toʻ:) Over All Would Recommend for a Nice Night Out with Family or Freinds:)
Stip House
Killer Cocktails! Love the Old Fashioned Haddock dinner was seasoned perfectly. Our server was just lovely. Will be back again!
We were impressed with the quality and portions of our variety of meals. The excellent waitress stepped up with wonderful options for special dietary needs , making great suggestions. The atmosphere was cozy but not crowded.
Dietary restrictions: Gluten intolerance
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, French Onion Soup, Liver and Onions, Salad with French Roquefort
Al Feustel
Great steak and a huge mound of shrimp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Soup and Salad, Aged Ribeye Steak with Baked Potato, Thursday Night Shrimp Special
Stephany Brown
As with any supper club in WI, make sure you make a reservation!
We went here as a family for dinner. The food was amazing and the portion size was generous. The drinks were also amazing.
Our server was good and attentive.
It was a bit loud with the amount of people that were in there but everyone was polite and there weren't any rowdy groups or people.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Rick Bubolz
Nice little supper club. Very friendly staff, delicious food and drinks and cozy atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Barcheski
This was a fantastic supper club. We had the Haddock and the Grouper and it was outstanding. The atmosphere was very cozy, and the drinks were generous. I have read comments of people having to wait…. What I’ll say is that they fill up fast, likely because of the quality, and they take reservations. We got there when they opened at 4 and they start dinner service at 4:30. In the short time between opening and dinner they were full. I think this should speak to how good it was. We are not local, but I noted the bartender, also an owner, knew many of the early diners names. How great is that?!? We’re from about 2 1/4 hours away and we’ll be back!
We ordered ribeyes, twice baked potatoes and French onion soup along with key lime pie for dessert.
Ribeyes were cooked ok, typical ribeye with a lot of fat, the double baked potato’s were salty and way too much cheese on them. The French onion soup was ok but could have been a bit less salty and a little less bread in them.
Key lime pie was great.
Expected a 5 star dinner but got a 3 star meal. Portions were great, just lay off the salt and cheese.
Service was excellent!
Food was really good. We will definitely be back.
Jennifer and Jeff your place is amazing. Great food wonderful service. We have not had a bad meal ever. Servers like Emma make for a great night out. We will continue to spread the word how great a place the Off The Wolf is. Thank you.
Pleasant, clean and friendly atmosphere. The old fashions were good, but you need to request that they muddle if that's how you like them. The food and service were excellent. Prices were average.
Excellent all around! The food is incredible, the drinks are great, and the service/staff are all extremely friendly and fast!
I love this place! The food is always excellent. Service is excellent! We took a friend for his birthday last Friday and I got the Beer Battered Haddock special. THAT WAS THE BEST BEER BATTERED FISH I HAVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!!! I usually get the Salmon. I love that too, but I have a new favorite now. Please have this special list often. I usually make a reservation, but at the last minute we decided to go for our friend’s birthday, we arrived close to opening time. I want to thank the nice lady who checked us in at the front. Thank you so much for getting us a table. Thank you for making our friend Steve feel special on his birthday 🎂 He loved the ice cream and cake. We will definitely be back soon. Its so nice to have a fabulous restaurant in Winneconne close to home.I highly recommend 😃
Great service, had the best pan fried grouper I have ever had. Love those crispy pieces of bread they serve as well, great experience and great value.
The service and the food was good, the appetizers looked really good. Especially the crab cakes
Beautiful Quaint Setting with Quiet Calm Atmosphere Attentive Staff:) Heads Up The Tender Primerib Seasoned Strongly With Rosemary Very Pungent Even in the Aju' Sorry Was Scraped Off as Much as Possible too Piney Flavored:( Mushroom burger is a Loaded Crusty Bun Melted Cheese Guessing a Whole Pint of Baby Portabella Mushrooms with An Unique Seasoning Hard to Place what was it?:) Not Sure if I liked just Greatful there Was a Vegetarian Option Wishing Is Was More of a Butter Flavor Instead:) One Staying Safe With A Burger as You can't got Wrong along with The Delicious Fries Toʻ:) Over All Would Recommend for a Nice Night Out with Family or Freinds:)
Killer Cocktails! Love the Old Fashioned
Haddock dinner was seasoned perfectly. Our server was just lovely. Will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Haddock Oscar
Restaurantji Recommends
We were impressed with the quality and portions of our variety of meals. The excellent waitress stepped up with wonderful options for special dietary needs , making great suggestions. The atmosphere was cozy but not crowded.
Dietary restrictions: Gluten intolerance
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, French Onion Soup, Liver and Onions, Salad with French Roquefort
Great steak and a huge mound of shrimp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Soup and Salad, Aged Ribeye Steak with Baked Potato, Thursday Night Shrimp Special
As with any supper club in WI, make sure you make a reservation!
We went here as a family for dinner. The food was amazing and the portion size was generous. The drinks were also amazing.
Our server was good and attentive.
It was a bit loud with the amount of people that were in there but everyone was polite and there weren't any rowdy groups or people.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Nice little supper club. Very friendly staff, delicious food and drinks and cozy atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was a fantastic supper club. We had the Haddock and the Grouper and it was outstanding. The atmosphere was very cozy, and the drinks were generous. I have read comments of people having to wait…. What I’ll say is that they fill up fast, likely because of the quality, and they take reservations. We got there when they opened at 4 and they start dinner service at 4:30. In the short time between opening and dinner they were full. I think this should speak to how good it was. We are not local, but I noted the bartender, also an owner, knew many of the early diners names. How great is that?!? We’re from about 2 1/4 hours away and we’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...