Our first visit tonight and it won’t be our last! Amazing service from the moment you walk in the door, excellent food, great drinks, great atmosphere, and very very clean! We spent a little more because we also had some dessert😉
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Vicchiollo
The waitress was in full court press to move us through even though we had reservations and we were just trying to enjoy a meal with our friends. Will not go back again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Laura TheDutchy
Food was good, but pretty expensive for the portion size.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
C J
Great atmosphere for a quiet dining experience. Food was exceptional, a bit pricier but well worth it as it is not your run of the mill food. My complements to the chef. Staff was also very attentive
Heidi L
We have eaten at The Lost Key many times. The food is always good and they use fresh ingredients. The risotto and salmon are both fabulous. The bartender made a great old fashioned. The trout special with the creamed corn and smashed baby reds was a great combination. We were able to eat at the bar which we like to do. The bartender was friendly and attentive. A little dark for eating, but the inside is very beautiful and clean.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
DJ Hansen
We never would’ve thought to check out this restaurant had we not gotten a gift card! It was hands down the most impressive meal we’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lyndon Lattie
I rode by one day and thought, this place looks pretty cool. I was not wrong. Wife had an amazing Paper Plane and recommended wine was outstanding
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Shedlosky
Was pretty good. My calamari was good but bottom was soggy(change of plating would help crispness) aged porkchop was fantastic and my wifes trout fillet was good minus the center bones. Our server was super bubbly and did a great job. All in all would go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Daniel Schmidt
Amazing little gem in Wrightstown, very great interior and very friendly service, the food as well, amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Schwaller
The food, service and staff were great. This place is a treasure. We're lucky to have such a gem in the neighborhood.
Fantastic food and wine! Service is always wonderful. I always try a featured dinner when I visit!
Noah Wichman
First time going to Lost Key last night and we will definitely be going back. Waitresses was fantastic, food was amazing, and overall experience was just what we were looking for.
Andrew Fluger
Lost Key Tap is an excellent spot. It’s Outside of the main parts of the valley, so it’s kind of a hidden gem. I enjoy it because so many places in Appleton that are good are always packed, the wait for a table is long, and they don’t take reservations ahead of time. LKT was the opposite. They took reservations, but they had seating available regardless, it wasn’t packed and loud, and the interior was very inviting. I had the NY Strip. Probably my favorite in the valley as of now. The way they made the smashed potatoes crispy and put them on a bed of garlic and herbs was top tier, so so good! The steak was cooked perfectly. My wife had the stuff gnocchi and the made in house pasta was top tier as well. Delicate, lump Asiago stuffed pillows of joy in a rich and flavorful sauce. Superb. If you are celebrating, doing date night, taking someone out for dinner, or even having a treat yourself day, LKT is the right call. They will take care of you WELL. They’re doing upscale casual dining right and are an excellent, much needed addition to the local food scene.
Nicole Vartanian
We love that this restaurant is in Wrightstown! The service is great and food is great!
michelle tourville
Went 5/3/25 the guy in the vest and dressed sharp was so helpful and energized and service with engagement....bartender nice but no energy least amnt of words possible and monotone no smile, same with woman at the hostess desk....food delicious and pregnant daughter had a delicious mocktail. Vibe was low energy and serious. Except for the gentleman with the vest...need more like him. Wasnt a welcome or any energy that was up upbeat from woman at desk when we arrived.
Our first visit tonight and it won’t be our last! Amazing service from the moment you walk in the door, excellent food, great drinks, great atmosphere, and very very clean! We spent a little more because we also had some dessert😉
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The waitress was in full court press to move us through even though we had reservations and we were just trying to enjoy a meal with our friends. Will not go back again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Food was good, but pretty expensive for the portion size.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great atmosphere for a quiet dining experience. Food was exceptional, a bit pricier but well worth it as it is not your run of the mill food. My complements to the chef. Staff was also very attentive
We have eaten at The Lost Key many times. The food is always good and they use fresh ingredients. The risotto and salmon are both fabulous. The bartender made a great old fashioned. The trout special with the creamed corn and smashed baby reds was a great combination. We were able to eat at the bar which we like to do. The bartender was friendly and attentive. A little dark for eating, but the inside is very beautiful and clean.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We never would’ve thought to check out this restaurant had we not gotten a gift card! It was hands down the most impressive meal we’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I rode by one day and thought, this place looks pretty cool. I was not wrong. Wife had an amazing Paper Plane and recommended wine was outstanding
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was pretty good. My calamari was good but bottom was soggy(change of plating would help crispness) aged porkchop was fantastic and my wifes trout fillet was good minus the center bones. Our server was super bubbly and did a great job. All in all would go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Amazing little gem in Wrightstown, very great interior and very friendly service, the food as well, amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food, service and staff were great. This place is a treasure. We're lucky to have such a gem in the neighborhood.
Restaurantji Recommends
Fantastic food and wine! Service is always wonderful. I always try a featured dinner when I visit!
First time going to Lost Key last night and we will definitely be going back. Waitresses was fantastic, food was amazing, and overall experience was just what we were looking for.
Lost Key Tap is an excellent spot. It’s Outside of the main parts of the valley, so it’s kind of a hidden gem. I enjoy it because so many places in Appleton that are good are always packed, the wait for a table is long, and they don’t take reservations ahead of time. LKT was the opposite. They took reservations, but they had seating available regardless, it wasn’t packed and loud, and the interior was very inviting. I had the NY Strip. Probably my favorite in the valley as of now. The way they made the smashed potatoes crispy and put them on a bed of garlic and herbs was top tier, so so good! The steak was cooked perfectly. My wife had the stuff gnocchi and the made in house pasta was top tier as well. Delicate, lump Asiago stuffed pillows of joy in a rich and flavorful sauce. Superb. If you are celebrating, doing date night, taking someone out for dinner, or even having a treat yourself day, LKT is the right call. They will take care of you WELL. They’re doing upscale casual dining right and are an excellent, much needed addition to the local food scene.
We love that this restaurant is in Wrightstown! The service is great and food is great!
Went 5/3/25 the guy in the vest and dressed sharp was so helpful and energized and service with engagement....bartender nice but no energy least amnt of words possible and monotone no smile, same with woman at the hostess desk....food delicious and pregnant daughter had a delicious mocktail. Vibe was low energy and serious. Except for the gentleman with the vest...need more like him. Wasnt a welcome or any energy that was up upbeat from woman at desk when we arrived.
Loading...