This place was ok. Pretty pricey. Paid a stupid amount for a bourbon drink and a regular lemonade and they don't even bring it to ur table-you have to go to the bar to get it. The waitress doesn't take your order either--you have to order it at the cash register. Not sure why i even tipped. Food was decent. Staff was friendly. Won't return.
Cody Collins
the most full ive ever been from a breakfast and i love putting a gay lil coffee shop in a church
Jim Bennett
Had breakfast/brunch on a Saturday, party of 5, wait time was 30 minutes. The menu selection is good, with a broad variety of choices. You self place your order at the counter, and food is brought to your table. I ordered the omelette, it was good but a little dry, and just ok. The bagel with salmon was very tasty. I also enjoyed a blackberry bourbon ice tea, refreshing and tasty.
Alisa Weigandt
Gosh, I love this place and have so many memories of eating here with family over the years. We took our kids a few days ago and my daughter and her friend said their panini was the best sandwich they’ve ever had in their lives :-) I got the chicken salad croissant, so good! If you’re in Fayetteville, it’s a must do. Also such a great ambience and vibe with the lovely, stained glass windows.
Cheryl Peck
AWESOME! 😎 Loved everything about Cathedral Cafe. We were told their mixed berry cobbler was famous and it was delicious with lots of mixed berries and not overly sweet so you tasted the berries and creamy vanilla of the ice cream. The Teriyaki Chicken and Cashew Salad was delicious as well as beautifully presented. The homemade vinaigrette dressing was out of this world. I had the blackberry iced latte and my husband the blackberry iced tea and both were delicious and not overly sweet, just the way we like things. The service was spot on! Everyone was so nice 😊! Would give them 10 stars if I could .
Aimee Henderson
Even though the building is cool, the food was bland, and the young ladies seemed annoyed to be working. One lady (manager/owner) possibly was pleasant. Overall not recommended for more conservative tastes.
Rebekah Neal
Sadly their food isn’t good quality and their vegan options are gross so I wouldn’t waste my time coming here if you like high quality food. Their drinks are the best thing they have but not the best overall for Fayetteville. Super cool place but very busy and overwhelming at times. It feels hot or miss so staff being friendly some are and others are rude.
Ryanne Brown
We visited Fayetteville last November and tried twice to eat here, but the wait times were an hour and a half. We were back in the area with my parents last week and were able to stop by and snag a table pretty quickly. You get seated at a table, then order at the counter. Because we paid for two separate orders there was a little mix up and my parents didn't get their order. This was remedied fairly quickly by the server that brought out our food. You do need to go up the counter to get any drink orders. All of the food was delicious. Pancakes, cheese panini, cinnamon buns, breakfast bagel sandwich and home fries. The seasonal caramel, banana shaken expresso is pretty good if you like bananas. Not sure it would have been worth it if we would have had to wait, but if you want pretty good breakfast/brunch option in the Fayetteville area I would give it a try.
Atmosphere is great and the stained glass windows are absolutely beautiful, but when my mother asked two different employees about the history and where the front of the church was (where the pulpit would have been located) neither could tell her.
Donald .Richardville
Delicious food! Reasonable prices and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, Vegan
Jonathan Fox
Always stop in Fayetteville when passing thru. Beautiful converted church with excellent beverage choices
The food was delicious!! The service was great and having lunch in an old church was a cool experience!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Wolf
The food was absolute trash; slimy sloppy eggs, dense/soggy french toast, and burnt ass coffee. Atmosphere is cool but the people were kind of rude and didn't even ask if there was an issue with meals hardly touched. Would not recommend
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Steven Smutko
Fantastic food and excellent service one of the most unique places in Fayetteville. If your stopping by to grab lunch they have wonderful soup and BLTs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, blt Sandwich
Benjy Braude
Really cool spot that from the second you walk in you immediately understand why it’s rated so highly. Really unique interior, with both cool and cozy vibes.
Latte was massive and really good, and the breakfast bagel sandwich was exactly what I needed before a day of hiking. Would happily come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich
Patricia Spears
This is highly rated by others but we were really underwhelmed.
This place was ok. Pretty pricey. Paid a stupid amount for a bourbon drink and a regular lemonade and they don't even bring it to ur table-you have to go to the bar to get it. The waitress doesn't take your order either--you have to order it at the cash register. Not sure why i even tipped. Food was decent. Staff was friendly. Won't return.
the most full ive ever been from a breakfast and i love putting a gay lil coffee shop in a church
Had breakfast/brunch on a Saturday, party of 5, wait time was 30 minutes. The menu selection is good, with a broad variety of choices. You self place your order at the counter, and food is brought to your table. I ordered the omelette, it was good but a little dry, and just ok. The bagel with salmon was very tasty. I also enjoyed a blackberry bourbon ice tea, refreshing and tasty.
Gosh, I love this place and have so many memories of eating here with family over the years. We took our kids a few days ago and my daughter and her friend said their panini was the best sandwich they’ve ever had in their lives :-) I got the chicken salad croissant, so good! If you’re in Fayetteville, it’s a must do. Also such a great ambience and vibe with the lovely, stained glass windows.
AWESOME! 😎 Loved everything about Cathedral Cafe. We were told their mixed berry cobbler was famous and it was delicious with lots of mixed berries and not overly sweet so you tasted the berries and creamy vanilla of the ice cream. The Teriyaki Chicken and Cashew Salad was delicious as well as beautifully presented. The homemade vinaigrette dressing was out of this world. I had the blackberry iced latte and my husband the blackberry iced tea and both were delicious and not overly sweet, just the way we like things. The service was spot on! Everyone was so nice 😊! Would give them 10 stars if I could .
Even though the building is cool, the food was bland, and the young ladies seemed annoyed to be working. One lady (manager/owner) possibly was pleasant. Overall not recommended for more conservative tastes.
Sadly their food isn’t good quality and their vegan options are gross so I wouldn’t waste my time coming here if you like high quality food. Their drinks are the best thing they have but not the best overall for Fayetteville. Super cool place but very busy and overwhelming at times. It feels hot or miss so staff being friendly some are and others are rude.
We visited Fayetteville last November and tried twice to eat here, but the wait times were an hour and a half. We were back in the area with my parents last week and were able to stop by and snag a table pretty quickly. You get seated at a table, then order at the counter. Because we paid for two separate orders there was a little mix up and my parents didn't get their order. This was remedied fairly quickly by the server that brought out our food. You do need to go up the counter to get any drink orders. All of the food was delicious. Pancakes, cheese panini, cinnamon buns, breakfast bagel sandwich and home fries. The seasonal caramel, banana shaken expresso is pretty good if you like bananas. Not sure it would have been worth it if we would have had to wait, but if you want pretty good breakfast/brunch option in the Fayetteville area I would give it a try.
Atmosphere is great and the stained glass windows are absolutely beautiful, but when my mother asked two different employees about the history and where the front of the church was (where the pulpit would have been located) neither could tell her.
Delicious food! Reasonable prices and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, Vegan
Always stop in Fayetteville when passing thru. Beautiful converted church with excellent beverage choices
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was delicious!! The service was great and having lunch in an old church was a cool experience!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was absolute trash; slimy sloppy eggs, dense/soggy french toast, and burnt ass coffee. Atmosphere is cool but the people were kind of rude and didn't even ask if there was an issue with meals hardly touched. Would not recommend
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fantastic food and excellent service one of the most unique places in Fayetteville. If your stopping by to grab lunch they have wonderful soup and BLTs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, blt Sandwich
Really cool spot that from the second you walk in you immediately understand why it’s rated so highly. Really unique interior, with both cool and cozy vibes.
Latte was massive and really good, and the breakfast bagel sandwich was exactly what I needed before a day of hiking. Would happily come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich
This is highly rated by others but we were really underwhelmed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...