Blackwell's Catering LLC

Just be aware you have to order lunch from here 48 hours in advance. Thats right, you have to care enough about eating from here that you order your lunch two days in advance. I guess there is no changing your mind that day. And I guess it's loyal base has lives that this works for. Whom does this place cater to? Not your average person by any means. Certainly not people actually out working. Perhaps office or bank employees around town who know on Monday what they will want for lunch on Wednesday. Not knowing this. I googled them, saw no hours nor any explanation. We were only two minutes away so I just drove over. Nevermind that it took 15 minutes to park in downtown Lewisburg. It looked closed so I walked to the door to look for hours. Nothing but a menu taped to the window. I saw two women inside one looked right at me so I smiled and waved. She quite literally looked at me like she was exhausted with me already raised her eyebrows and shook her head no. Which I interpreted as we are closed. Fair enough. So I hop back in the truck and pull up their website. Funny, looks like most of the reaturaunt sites in Lewisburg, all made by the same company. And the only explanation on their website states it's a pick up and delivery. Okay great. Have to download their menu. Okay. Finally, it looks like we will be able to order. Not so fast. After downloading, and only after downloading the menu does it state you must order 48 hours in advance....wow. That's something your website designer should probably put on the front page of your site. Or maybe you as the business owner should put this on Google. Or at least hours and 48 hour advance pick up delivery ONLY somewhere on Google. Maybe a door sign for all the average people who think this is an actual resturaunt, so they don't get snooty looks when they smile at you. Some of us aren't aware of the odd way your business works. I've lived all over, I've managed four diamond resturaunts. Huge scale casino resturaunts, small boutique steakhouses, fifties style diners, etc and never seen this type of model for a resturaunt, small or large. Clearly people are fans, they do well enough. But as it is nothing they offer looks so good, unique or special that I would order 48 hours in advance. Like many of the resturaunts downtown they give the vibe that you are lucky to be getting food from them. Instead of appreciating your current AND would be customers. It's a hard pass for me given the experience and lack of pertinent information on their website, Google, or their door.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

From the door your are welcome, the order was taken accurate and with a kind and charmy cashier, we didn't wait long for our food and it was delicious. For me the most important part was the coffee.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wonderful! Wonderful! Food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smoked Trout Salad, Turkey Wrap w Chips, Chicken Sandwich

GREAT food!!!!!And the waitress was SO NICE!!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Potato/ham soup? Salted water with cut potato and lunch meat slices cut in little squares. Plus, a Ruben woke style.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

The pizza was fresh and delious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went in on Saturday to buy salt rising bread around 12 and the lady was incredibly rude saying they were closed. Asked when they were open again and she said “not today” asked again when they were open AGAIN and she said Tuesday. Based on customer service…will NEVER go back or recommend them to ANYONE. Shocked other places recommend this place

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Fresh, made-from-scratch food. Amazing Cream of Mushroom soup and Pulled Pork Quesadilla! Lattes were delicious as was the bread pudding. Look forward to returning and enjoying Lee Ann’s Carrot Cake!

Made-in-house sourdough and pizzas, fresh quality ingredients, locally sourced meats, attention to detail and friendly service. The variety in the menu makes it easy to return again and again, along with rotating lunch specials.

Dietary restrictions: The baked goods are well marked with ingredients and there is a selection of GF or vegan options.

We stopped here for lunch on our way to Kentucky and we were so pleased we did. From the moment we stepped in to see the charming hosts (owners?) and the bakery case full of fresh-baked goodies, we knew we picked a good restaurant. The sandwiches are made with fresh-baked bread and ingredients that are a step above the usual. The BLT had thick-sliced bacon and perfectly ripe avocado and tomatoes. The special ham and Brie sandwich on focaccia was great; the Brie was melted and the bread was soft with a nice little bit of crunch on the outside. The lemon bar was perfectly tart/sweet; and I could tell the iced shortbread cookie was made with butter. So good! We will return!

I bought a pizza from here and it wasn't good to say the least; it didn't even taste like a pizza. They do not know how to make authentic italian pizza. They also gave us the wrong order.

I had the pleasure of having lunch here last week. The food was delicious and the staff was more than friendly and patient. What a nice treat for the week!

We go here often when we get the chance to be in town or passing by Lewisburg. I love to get a slice of Vege pizza or avocado toast or a bagel and cream cheese (breads made in-house of course ?) … but there is a lot on the menu I’d like to try too… oh, the cold cucumber soup was really good! I bought a loaf of the Russian Bread and a loaf of Cereales Bread. Love them both. Perfect combination of chewy and crispy in all the right places. And so tasty.

Great vibe! Loved the Kombucha <3

Quality bakery and coffee. Pizzas, quiches and other small treats. Don't pass it!