Anthony's Pizza

300 N Queen St, Martinsburg
(304) 262-6100

Recent Reviews

Sort by
D M

Food is good or OK but do not plan on you're order being correct. I have never ordered from this place and had a correct order once and the one time I called bc the order was ridiculously wrong the owner agreed it was wrong but 10 minutes later called me back and accused me of lying
So of course I will never go back

Roy Lindemann

My heart is bad enough.

Benjamin Peoples

Great pizza! The thin crust is *just* thick enough to be a little chewy with a crispy bottom. The pie and crust are well-seasoned, and the pizza is one of my favorites in the area.

The Sun/Mon discount on large pies is a plus and applies to plain and pizzas with toppings. They use fresh mushrooms and vegetables, which beats canned toppings any day.

There are a few tables inside. I have only ever ordered for pickup. I haven't tried anything else on the menu.

I highly recommend trying Anthony's Pizza for yourself!

CB

The pizza is out of this world. All you need is cheese pizza and it's the best. My family goes here once a week at least to get pizza because it's that good.

Jeremy Butler

Need to update hours! Says open till 11 but stops answering phones at 930 won't deliver past 930. If your open till 11 then 1030 should be last call not hour n half before! I spend alot of money here and it's getting old! Get it back together or your going start loosing your long time customers!

Karmallow

10 out of 10 times they have gotten my order wrong I can't order here without having some amount of money owed to me. I do not recommend this restaurant the owner will call you a liar when you ask for a fix save your money and time do not order from here!!!!

Wendi Baugher

Always great

Michael McDaniel

I think this place has the best calzone in the area , I'll be coming here over the other pizza vendors

Ok, Mr. Browntown

Hot wings and a cheese steak, this is the place.

Angelitha

I love the service, the workers are very friendly. You can now eat there again.

Jessicca Yount

We got the pizzas great price and good food.

Starr Duhh

I discovered a used needle on the floor, and the state of the bathroom was completely unacceptable. I will be contacting the health department immediately.

Lisa hall

We ordered two taco salads and got only one and no sour cream or ranch for the bacon cheddar fries. Had to call back and make them send out the right taco salad. This is ridiculous with this place and no wonder why they are a 3.9 in a review. They will no longer get my business anymore.

Chaz Craig

Pizza was fantastic. A lil chilly inside but worth it

Lorraine

I've had problems with there food & arguments with the owner too. Xmas eve takes the cake. They take no pride in their food. I received an Italian sub with bologna on it. They insist they don't carry bologna but at 64 yrs old I know what bologna looks, smells & taste like. I'm allergic & got hives. Next i got an order of onion rings that more then half were so burnt & inedible. When I called i immediately told them I didn't want anything, just tell them nor did I wish to argue. Well the owners bad attitude has rubbed off on employees. They were 8nsistent i was wrong & wanted to argue. In the end he dismissed me n hung up. I will never order there again. They are supposed to be a chain & I've eaten many different Anthony's, which i loved but this place is dirty & they use a rotating pizza oven. Unlike all other Anthony stores.

Loading...