Cinco de Mayo Bar and Restaurant

5724 Hammonds Mill Rd, Martinsburg
(304) 271-8887

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Donna Gardner

Food was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Aaliayah Roberts

Placed an online order and added cheese dip with is $5 extra and the cup was so small. When I went to eat the cheese dip it was so cold like someone had just given me a cup of milk and the salsa was even colder.

Food: 2

K20UCHIHA

Visited Cinco de Mayo Bar and Restaurant for dinner and enjoyed a few highlights worth sharing. We started with drinks—a red sangria and a jalapeño margarita. Both were visually appealing and hit the mark on flavor. The sangria was fruity and refreshing, while the margarita had just the right kick without overpowering the drink.

For food, we ordered 12 chicken wings with fries and 4 birria tacos. The wings were hot, crispy, and well-coated in sauce, and the fries were cooked just right. The birria tacos were flavorful, served with consommé on the side, and loaded with tender meat, onion, and cilantro.

Service stood out—Kelly was attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed. Her energy added to the experience.

There are a couple of areas for improvement. The music was playing too low, which took away from the energy of the space. A bit more volume would help bring out the vibe the place is clearly going for. Also, the air vents looked overdue for a good cleaning, which was hard to miss when looking around.

That said, I see a lot of potential here and plan to come back earlier in the evening to get a feel for the place when it’s more active. I get that toward closing time, things start winding down. Looking forward to seeing how it feels at full swing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Joseph Johansen

Not the traditional food you would expect, but it filled the void.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Mike Dollar

Nothing to write home about. There are better Mexican places in town. Taco loco for one. I’d only go here in a pinch

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

The Kaptain

They have/had no idea what a burrito was. Its on the menu, yet still comes with the rice OUTSIDE of the tortilla AND sauce on top preventing you from picking it up and eating it.

If i ordered a large pepperoni pizza and the pepperoni came on the side and they cut it up small, so you have to use a fork....how is that pizza?

I opted for McDonald's. And i hate McDonald's.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Berserkguy

Honestly, I have no idea what most of the scathing reviews are talking about. I just went here with my family and the food was great. The fajita quesadilla I got tasted and was presented great. My dad's mocahete bowl looked good and he loved it.

The worst part was the service though by far. Our server was, in the nicest way possible, brain dead. When we went to order, we asked if we could order something to go for someone at home. He said that he won't put it in now and that we should remind him later?????? Excuse me? He then proceeded to take our order and never put in that side order until we were finished and sitting waiting for over 5-10 minutes. So then we had to sit there and wait even longer for that to-go order before we could leave. Even though there were only 2 parties in the whole restaurant (including us) I never got my water filled and he never asked if we wanted more chips and salsa and he didn't remove them when they were empty. My dad asked for change at the payment counter and we were standing there for another 5+ minutes while he walked around serving tables instead of getting us our change. Why does this server not have access to a register?

TLDR: kitchen A+ Service F

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Star Frankhouser

Great food! Recommend the fajitas

Nick Skeens

Service was not good and food was not good either.

zokere1

I AM EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED 😞 AT THIS PLACE .I HAVE BEEN EATING HERE BUT YESTERDAY WAS THE WORST.I ORDERED 3 CARNE ASADA MEALS NO SOUR CREAM AND CHARO BEANS.
THIS PEOPLE BROUGHT ME REFRIED BEANS THAT LOOK LIKE DIARRHEA OR MESSED UP MASHED POTATOES 😠 😡 WE DONT EAT MASHED BEANS.
I ASK THE WAITER WHAT HAPPENED HE SAID THAT'S THE ONLY BEANS THEY MAKE THERE. I TOLD THEM TO TAKE IT BACK BECAUSE I DON'T EAT MASHED BEANS I WOULD THROW UP. THEY TOOK IT BACK AND NEVER OFFERED ANYTHING IN EXCHANGE
VERY BACK CUSTOMER SERVICES . IF YOU DONT MAKE CHARO BEANS WHY PUT IT ON YOUR MENU?? THAT STEALING FROM YOUR CUSTOMERS
NOT ONLY THEY MESSED UP THE BEANS , THEY ALSO PUT SOUR CREAM ON OUR SALAD
IT WAS THE WORST MEAL EVER
THE MEAT WAS NOT. WELL SEASONED
I WANTED TO USE SALD
BUT THEY HAVE SOME VERY WEIRD SIDE SALD (THEY ADDED UNCOOK RICE IN THE SALT BOTTLE/ NEVER SEEN THAT BEFORE THAT WAS UNSANITARY)
THEY DID NOT APOLOGIZE NOR OFFER AN EXCHANGE FOR THE SO CALLED CHARO BEANS THE TOOK IT BACK
I WISHED I DIDN'T GIVE A TIP
I REALLY DID NO WANT TO .MY DAUGHTER BEGGED ME TO GIVE I JUST ADD $7 SOME THING TO MAKE MY BILL EVEN WHICH CAME UP TO 90 DOLLAR
I WILL NEVER EAT THERE AGAIN
PLEASE GUYS TO GO THERE
THEY DO MAKE CHARO BEANS 🫘 THEY HAVE MASHED / REFRIED BEANS 🍮 INSTEAD

Michael Renshaw

I liked the nachos and super burrito. I liked the beef vs the chicken. All of the food has a great presentation to it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Xavier Morales

Came here for taco Tuesday. Tacos are very delicious. I still prefer La Lobera in Bunker Hill, but this food was tasty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa

josh allen

Ordered fajitas and queso for my pregnant wife. I noticed first thing how light the to go bag was. I spent 30$ on this meal. 17$ for fajits and some how they charge 13 for a tiny thing of quaso and salsa. Hard no on going back to this place.

Food: 1

Christina Burkett

About three years ago I used to eat the taco salad from this place almost every weekend, but I had my hat in three years, and decided to go back and spoil myself with my favorite taco salad. Sadly, to say I will not be going back and getting my not so favorite taco salad anymore. The salad itself inside a fishell was so watery that it made the shell very moist and
Gross. The taco shell was not the same as it was 3 years ago. Maybe they changed different tortillas. Either way, it was overpriced, not like it was. But I do have to say that the service is still phenomenal.And the atmosphere is still welcoming

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

archlord960

Very tasty and plentiful food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...