Pies & Pints - Morgantown, WV

Good pizza

I’ve always loved Pies and Pints, but just visited for my birthday and was totally put off. The entire time we were eating (we were seated in the back), gnats were all over our food and table. When I mentioned this to our waiter, we were told the issue was coming from “next door but not in the kitchen.” Even if that was the case, the gnats were still all around our food. Not sure if I’ll be back. Definitely disappointed as this was my first time visiting since the reopen and I was really looking forward to it, not to mention it was a special occasion.

It's a great pizza place. The house beers are also great. Left with a belly full of pizza, wings, and beer.
Who could ask for more?😁

It just hasn’t been the same since reopening. The pizza is inconsistent when it used to be perfect every time. For the price of a pie, it should be great every single time as it used to be.

Always constantly out of beers and selection has dissipated. Last time I was there they were out of 3 different beers, 2 of which were common (Bud Light & Michelob Ultra - HOW?). The other one was Halleck which they’ve been out of for a while (informing me there’s an issue with getting this beer when Buffalo Wild Wings has it in walking distance.

It’s just not the same awesome place it used to be. It never seems busy anymore either so I guess others feel the same.

Advertising on their brownie dessert is way off. Was looking for a fun dessert to surprise a friend for their birthday. Found this at Pies and Pints and picked it up and was disappointed and embarrassed to deliver this to them. Overly priced I spent $20 on 3 of these.

We usually have excellent food .. I'm not sure what happened today... Nachos looked like the were left out over night

Really enjoyed their pizza; I made my own with onions, pepperoni, and mushrooms. Crust was crisp, not real thin. My wife had their gluten-free crust and it was crispy too. Great selection of beer to accompany the pizza.

Best Nashville Hot pizza ever! Salads were good too. Really enjoyed Daunte as our server!!! Great food and atmosphere.

Great food and amazing service!

Best pizza in town. Wings are amazing too. But the main highlight is there homemade salad dressing. Pro tip: ask for a side of it to dip your pizza crust in. 🤪

The service at Pies & Pints in Morgantown was outstanding, especially considering how packed it was after Saturday's WVU vs UCF game! Despite the post-game rush, our server remained attentive and friendly, navigating the crowded restaurant with ease. Our drinks stayed full, food arrived promptly and at the perfect temperature, and the staff maintained their composure and smiles even as game day fans filled every table. They expertly balanced efficiency with personalized attention, making us feel valued despite the hectic atmosphere. The way they handled the game day crowd while still delivering excellent service speaks volumes about their professionalism. Definitely worth visiting, even on the busiest of game days!

We live in Pittsburgh and this was our first time here. It was fantastic!!

The pizza hardly had any sause on it at all. Super thin pizza and it cost a lot just for it. I do not think we will get pizza here. The rest of the place was awesome. One reason I gave it 4 stars is because they did make the pizza on a stone oven rotator. That was really cool. We might go back for drinks but not pizza sorry guys. Great service though.

Pies and Pints is the best! We love stopping here when we’re in West Virginia. House salad with both dressings is always the perfect starter and we love that you can get two different types of toppings on a large pizza.

Excellent choice for upscale pizza!