So, here I was, on a mission to find the perfect sweet birthday bash bites for my hubby’s big 40th. I suddenly remembered a neighbor mentioning a place to me last year-enter The Cupcakerie, a.k.a. Cupcake Wonderland! Their website was like a treasure chest, brimming with cupcakes of every stripe and swirl. Imagine a flavor, and bam, they had it, plus more you hadn’t thought of!A week before the celebration, I placed an order for an assortment of both regular and mini-sized cupcakes, choosing flavors that spanned from the adventurous to the classic: P’NUTTY FOR CHOCOLATE, SWEET & SALTY, CHOCOLATE CARAMEL KISSES, MOUNTAIN MAMA, and COOKIES ‘N CREAM.Let me tell you, biting into these cupcakes was like stepping into a flavor festival. After having one you found yourself having this inner battle on whether you should or should not go back for more. The P’Nutty for Chocolate? A crowd-pleaser with a secret Reese’s stash that had everyone buzzing. And my husbands favorite is Reese’s so I already knew he would like them. However he was ready to fight wars over them. The Sweet and Salty was like the beach—sunshine and waves in cupcake form. And MOUNTAIN MAMA? A hike through deliciousness with a surprise apple butter campsite in the middle.But wait, thats not all. The cake was so moist, it was like biting into a cloud (if clouds were edible and tasted like heaven). And the frosting? Not the usual sugar shock that I’ve been known to just push off because it’s overbearing. I’m talking just-right sweetness that danced perfectly with the cake. That peanut butter icing on the P’Nutty was like floating on a fluffy cloud of peanut butter yum.If you’re reading this with your mouth watering but on the fence about ordering from The Cupcakerie, hop off and just order. Seriously, these cupcakes stole the show at the party which I am really glad too because I’m trying to stay in shape for an upcoming cruise, and I just cannot take the temptation of left over cupcakes. Not these ones.It’s rare for me to leave reviews about something, let alone at 1 am, but here I am, typing away because these cupcakes deserve it. They’re not just treats; they’re little bundles of joy that spark conversations and smiles. So, whether it’s a big bash or a quiet night in, let The Cupcakerie’s magic turn your moments into memories. Although my figure may not like it, I am already looking forward to next month’s cupcake and beer festival so I can dive into their other flavors. Keep that cupcake magic coming!-Ariel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large and Mini Cupcakes
Trevor Dolan
Reached out to them on a Thursday to see if they could make a cake with an image on it. They got right back to me and had the cake ready to go that Saturday. It was for a friend’s Birthday and it was a huge hit. The cake was perfect and it tasted amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
caitlin furbee
Eating my way through the menu! French toast is the best flavor!
Nathan
Overpriced junk. They charge $20 extra for sprinkles or any slight customization.
Joseph Petrillo
For the girls.
J K
Have had a couple different cupcakes from here, never been impressed by them. Cake is usually dry and the icing is too sweet. Wouldn't call cake or icing "gourmet". Very over priced and over rated.
Google user
I got a few of their top-selling cupcakes and I thought they were just mediocre for the price. The cupcake itself didn't have much flavor and the frosting tasted like Betty Crocker. I was disappointed for almost $20/half dozen regular sized cupcakes. Personally, I liked Giant Eagle's cupcakes better and they were a fraction of the cost.
Kimi V
I got a few of their top-selling cupcakes and I thought they were just mediocre for the price. The cupcake itself didn't have much flavor and the frosting tasted like Betty Crocker. I was disappointed for almost $20/half dozen regular sized cupcakes. Personally, I liked Giant Eagle's cupcakes better and they were a fraction of the cost.
Jaime Ames
I’m always impressed with what I get from the cupcakerie! Not only is their location warm and inviting, but their cupcakes are fantastic. For every special occasion, birthdays, anniversaries and even my wedding… it was no question where I’d get my cake! While I’ve tried many of their flavors, I don’t think it gets much better than their red velvet with cream cheese frosting, any of the lemon flavors or the peanutty for chocolate. It’s no surprise that this (woman owned!) precious gem of a shop has been in business for so long! Highly recommend the Cupcakerie
I do Not recommend The Cupcakerie.I was told the order would be delivered between 1pm and 3pm and that I would get a text upon delivery.When 3:30pm came and no delivery confirmation, I called only to be told the order would hopefully be picked up in the next hour and taken for delivery. Again, no text received.When I tried to call again, they were closed.I emailed them and was told that the order had indeed been delivered. After going back and forth several times, it turns out that they in fact did not deliver the order! The order finally got delivered after 8:30pm only because I kept pushing back on them sayingit was delivered and they finally admitted they had in fact not delivered the order!!At first I was told I would receive a refund but after a few days of no refund, I inquired and they said that since the order did get delivered, they wouldn't do anything else.After being lied to several times, I would not place trust in this company to take care of your special occasion.Edit to note that they contacted me and said they will be suing me for posting my experience and honest review.
Neo Hadoop
Ordered anniversary cake. Cake is hard. Asked for related design but was thrown with just names. Genuinely not worth $70. Also not sure she is the owner or manager and not at all welcoming and even felt kind of ignored. Based on my experience I would not recommend it.
Martha Stafford
I ordered cupcakes for a loved one's birthday. We had them delivered to a Morgantown business to be shared with coworkers. The recipient said they were absolutely delicious. Delivery for a reasonable fee exceeded our expectations. Highly recommend.
Tina Walcott
Ordered my daughters 1st bday smash cake from here and it was beautifully decorated and tasted amazing as well. It was absolutely perfect!
Tayler Vossen
My boyfriend and I tried the cupcakes for the first time a couple weekends ago. Kyle was working and he was kind enough to tell us he had fresh Peanut Butter cupcakes he was getting ready to decorate. He proceeded to tell us he was a master baker. When we got home to try the cupcakes, I knew he wasn't lying. They were amazing!!
Best red velvet you will find!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large and Mini Cupcakes
So, here I was, on a mission to find the perfect sweet birthday bash bites for my hubby’s big 40th. I suddenly remembered a neighbor mentioning a place to me last year-enter The Cupcakerie, a.k.a. Cupcake Wonderland! Their website was like a treasure chest, brimming with cupcakes of every stripe and swirl. Imagine a flavor, and bam, they had it, plus more you hadn’t thought of!A week before the celebration, I placed an order for an assortment of both regular and mini-sized cupcakes, choosing flavors that spanned from the adventurous to the classic: P’NUTTY FOR CHOCOLATE, SWEET & SALTY, CHOCOLATE CARAMEL KISSES, MOUNTAIN MAMA, and COOKIES ‘N CREAM.Let me tell you, biting into these cupcakes was like stepping into a flavor festival. After having one you found yourself having this inner battle on whether you should or should not go back for more. The P’Nutty for Chocolate? A crowd-pleaser with a secret Reese’s stash that had everyone buzzing. And my husbands favorite is Reese’s so I already knew he would like them. However he was ready to fight wars over them. The Sweet and Salty was like the beach—sunshine and waves in cupcake form. And MOUNTAIN MAMA? A hike through deliciousness with a surprise apple butter campsite in the middle.But wait, thats not all. The cake was so moist, it was like biting into a cloud (if clouds were edible and tasted like heaven). And the frosting? Not the usual sugar shock that I’ve been known to just push off because it’s overbearing. I’m talking just-right sweetness that danced perfectly with the cake. That peanut butter icing on the P’Nutty was like floating on a fluffy cloud of peanut butter yum.If you’re reading this with your mouth watering but on the fence about ordering from The Cupcakerie, hop off and just order. Seriously, these cupcakes stole the show at the party which I am really glad too because I’m trying to stay in shape for an upcoming cruise, and I just cannot take the temptation of left over cupcakes. Not these ones.It’s rare for me to leave reviews about something, let alone at 1 am, but here I am, typing away because these cupcakes deserve it. They’re not just treats; they’re little bundles of joy that spark conversations and smiles. So, whether it’s a big bash or a quiet night in, let The Cupcakerie’s magic turn your moments into memories. Although my figure may not like it, I am already looking forward to next month’s cupcake and beer festival so I can dive into their other flavors. Keep that cupcake magic coming!-Ariel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large and Mini Cupcakes
Reached out to them on a Thursday to see if they could make a cake with an image on it. They got right back to me and had the cake ready to go that Saturday. It was for a friend’s Birthday and it was a huge hit. The cake was perfect and it tasted amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Eating my way through the menu! French toast is the best flavor!
Overpriced junk. They charge $20 extra for sprinkles or any slight customization.
For the girls.
Have had a couple different cupcakes from here, never been impressed by them. Cake is usually dry and the icing is too sweet. Wouldn't call cake or icing "gourmet". Very over priced and over rated.
I got a few of their top-selling cupcakes and I thought they were just mediocre for the price. The cupcake itself didn't have much flavor and the frosting tasted like Betty Crocker. I was disappointed for almost $20/half dozen regular sized cupcakes. Personally, I liked Giant Eagle's cupcakes better and they were a fraction of the cost.
I got a few of their top-selling cupcakes and I thought they were just mediocre for the price. The cupcake itself didn't have much flavor and the frosting tasted like Betty Crocker. I was disappointed for almost $20/half dozen regular sized cupcakes. Personally, I liked Giant Eagle's cupcakes better and they were a fraction of the cost.
I’m always impressed with what I get from the cupcakerie! Not only is their location warm and inviting, but their cupcakes are fantastic. For every special occasion, birthdays, anniversaries and even my wedding… it was no question where I’d get my cake! While I’ve tried many of their flavors, I don’t think it gets much better than their red velvet with cream cheese frosting, any of the lemon flavors or the peanutty for chocolate. It’s no surprise that this (woman owned!) precious gem of a shop has been in business for so long! Highly recommend the Cupcakerie
Restaurantji Recommends
I do Not recommend The Cupcakerie.I was told the order would be delivered between 1pm and 3pm and that I would get a text upon delivery.When 3:30pm came and no delivery confirmation, I called only to be told the order would hopefully be picked up in the next hour and taken for delivery. Again, no text received.When I tried to call again, they were closed.I emailed them and was told that the order had indeed been delivered. After going back and forth several times, it turns out that they in fact did not deliver the order! The order finally got delivered after 8:30pm only because I kept pushing back on them sayingit was delivered and they finally admitted they had in fact not delivered the order!!At first I was told I would receive a refund but after a few days of no refund, I inquired and they said that since the order did get delivered, they wouldn't do anything else.After being lied to several times, I would not place trust in this company to take care of your special occasion.Edit to note that they contacted me and said they will be suing me for posting my experience and honest review.
Ordered anniversary cake. Cake is hard. Asked for related design but was thrown with just names. Genuinely not worth $70. Also not sure she is the owner or manager and not at all welcoming and even felt kind of ignored. Based on my experience I would not recommend it.
I ordered cupcakes for a loved one's birthday. We had them delivered to a Morgantown business to be shared with coworkers. The recipient said they were absolutely delicious. Delivery for a reasonable fee exceeded our expectations. Highly recommend.
Ordered my daughters 1st bday smash cake from here and it was beautifully decorated and tasted amazing as well. It was absolutely perfect!
My boyfriend and I tried the cupcakes for the first time a couple weekends ago. Kyle was working and he was kind enough to tell us he had fresh Peanut Butter cupcakes he was getting ready to decorate. He proceeded to tell us he was a master baker. When we got home to try the cupcakes, I knew he wasn't lying. They were amazing!!