Gatsby Restaurant

1420 Mountaineer Cir, New Cumberland
(304) 387-8000

Recent Reviews

Chris Shultz

Ordered a 34.00& ribeye with mashed potatoes and gravy and this is the garbage we got , I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

Jessica Z.

This place is just ok. We went for brunch and were disappointed that there were no omelettes on the menu. Instead I opted for a chicken club. It wasn't bad but also nothing to rave about. We also thought that the prices were very high for being an outdated restaurant in an outdated casino in the middle of nowhere, West Virginia. The atmosphere was very bland and the lights are very bright. It reminded me of a hospital cafeteria or something.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Nicole

Food isn't

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Ross F

Service was okay they weren't very accommodating. Food was warm and reminded me of a cafeteria.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Joyce Mcbride

Sausage gravy and biscuits as well as pancakes were cold, and refills were not offered we told the waitress who said I'll have the manager come over. Noone ever came except to bring the bill. We ate literally none of our food just paid them to throw it out.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Jason markowski

Server was nice and so was the hostess, but it took a long time to get our food. Could be under staffed, I'm not sure. Potatoes did come out a little on the cold side so makes me wonder how long it was sitting. We will be back

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Morgan Vice

Friendly and prompt service and the Reuben sandwich I had was pretty good ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Debbie Ritter

This was the salad that was served. Not one bite was eaten. Looked like it was leftover from someone else's meal. Used to like taking the ride down here. Not really any reason to go anymore. Food was not up to par, was not busy. Seems like they are dying out fast.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Frank Cole

The food is good and servers are helpful. They are open limited hours, so check ahead of time. The menu is not large but adequate. Pricing is average.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

electrolarry3

Food was mediocre. Waitresses were slow and unpleasant. Waited 1/2 hour just for order to be taken. Sat for another hour til food arrived . It was cold. Go somewhere else..And as far as the slots go, machines were tight. Won’t be back

Barbara Yuzwa

My Cobb salad was wonderful. There was enough salad for three people. My husband's fish was just so so. I really miss the buffet and a real breakfast in the morning that you can sit down to eat and

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Bill Hamilton

Sat after ordering cheese sticks for 30 minutes. Restaurant was only at half occupied. Sever came to my table only to deliver food never to ask how it was or refills pift. Definitely don't

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Gerald Adams

Food not as good as it used to be. Menu is limited.

Lori Novak La Vette

This restaurant is located inside of the Mountainer Casino in West Virginia.There is plenty of seating available ?! I ordered the fried zucchini strips topped with fresh parmaschon grated directly on top of the zucchini strips!They also provided a large amount of dipping sauce for you! OMG, they arrived hot ?, and were out of this world delicious!My friend ordered the onion soup ?. It was loaded with cheese covering the entire bowl! It was loaded with fresh Vidalia sweet onions and fresh croutons to absorb the tasty broth. It was absolutely ? delicious!I definitely would suggest eating here during your stay at the Casino ?!!We didn't have to wait in a long line before being seated.We ordered and received our food quickly and hot!The buffet is still closed; however, the menu selections were awesome ?!The prices are very reasonable for the amount of great food that you get!This restaurant was extremely clean and not crowded for brunch time.You will not be disappointed with eating here!!

Happy Travels

Food was tasty and portions are huge, the server was attentive. The prices are really good, was informed their buffet will not reopen.

Load More