Stopped by Evan's Sweets with my family while staying at Four Fillies Lodge cabin rentals in Peterstown, West Virginia, and I was very impressed with Evan's Sweets! First of all, the custard was delicious! Everything we had was great. And secondly, the shop itself is adorable. Will definitely be back when I stay again with Four Fillies Lodge!
Kaycee Runyon
I wanna start by saying I love this place, MOST of the time the customer service is great, Lauren, and a girl with curly blonde hair are the sweetest. But I went today and a girl named Ava who is semi-new was sooo sooo rude to me and my grandma, we asked for something and to start she insisted they didn’t sell it, so we asked the manager and she said they did, so as she was making it the same girl was mean-mugging both of us the whole time we were waiting, she also slammed the window in our face, she was extremely disrespectful and rude to us all because was told her something was on the menu when she didn’t think it was. I hope if a manager is reading this they fire her ASAP. I’m used to being treated so nicely, this was a complete turn around.
Casey Herzfeld
Great local ice cream spot! This place is so cute, brings you back to different times, and is so tasty. Highly recommend stopping in for a treat!
Cory STCLAIR
Quick service, great prices and portions! I'll definitely be back. Clean place with inside, outside and drive-thru options.
Hunter Cumbee
Amazing
Ruth Alessi
I needed a pit stop along my drive up I-77, and this ice cream shop fit the bill. Yes, it’s a bit of a drive from the interstate, but well worth it. It’s decorated in a 50’s retro style, with indoor and outdoor seating.
I split a brownie sundae with my daughter, and it was more than enough for both of us. The brownie was hot and gooey. Cute place, nice atmosphere, and yummy ice cream.
kelly dee
The ice cream is just good. The customer service is so unfriendly. The two young women really made us feel like they were doing us a favor by deigning to wait on us. Won’t go back.
Jennifer Schade
What a delight! In fact, I will call it the highlight of the trip!
Maria Martin
Always good tasting. Staff is friendly
Phil Rarich
Great little ice cream shop. But kind of basic flavors for ice cream.
Super tasty, I got black berry cobbler with lemon custard. It's where I chose to go for my birthday if that says anything.
Jane A.
It's not Birkshires. It's renamed Evens Sweets Frozen Custard no ice cream.
Mary Blair
Took a long time before anyone came to take my order and they were not even busy.
seth druggish
I don’t want to bad mouth any business and typically I will not do a review, but changes need to be made at this (what used to be great) frozen custard spot. Over the past few months service has declined extremely. Tonight was the worst. I had a very simple order of a chocolate milkshake with some Reese’s cups added in. The first time the milkshake came out after a 45 minute wait it was watered down and just looked like chocolate sludge. It also had no Reese’s cups in the mixture. I decided to politely ask for some Reese’s to be added in to which wasn’t an issue but this was also another 10 minute wait just to be seen. I also want to note that when I walked in the door I wasn’t spoken to or greeted. I had to bring an employee’s attention to my issue. Then I watched as the other employee didn’t seem to have a clue as to how to add Reese’s into the already made milkshake. I stood there for another 10 minutes and watched as the employee with NO GLOVES kept using my straw to try and mix in the resse’s. I want to note that no employee was wearing gloves while handling money and then preparing the food and drinks. By the time that I got the milkshake it was completely melted and discolored. I don’t want to blame the employees completely because it appears as though they have not had proper training. Unfortunately what used to be my favorite place to get a sweat treat has just lost a loyal customer. Berkshires was doing something right that Evan’s sweets is not. The quality and taste isn’t the same. The customer service is non existent. I hate to see what used to be a flourishing business fail in this way. Change needs to be made. I could’ve given this a 1 star but I’m giving it 2 as a courtesy and hope for changed to be made.
MsBigdog#1
I absolutely love their ice cream! Especially the chocolate, I have never had such rich, delicious chocolate ice cream anywhere. Most places you can get ice cream have the pale chocolate with very little, if any flavor, but the chocolate here is amazing. We love it and stop by almost every time we're in Princeton.My son loves their footlong hot dogs and I get the regular Ball Park, very good.I wish they had fries and maybe onion rings to go with the dogs and burgers but that's NOT a deal breaker for us, lol.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotdog with Slaw, Oreo, Frozen Custard, Small Waffle Cone, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Custard in a Waffle Cone
Stopped by Evan's Sweets with my family while staying at Four Fillies Lodge cabin rentals in Peterstown, West Virginia, and I was very impressed with Evan's Sweets! First of all, the custard was delicious! Everything we had was great. And secondly, the shop itself is adorable. Will definitely be back when I stay again with Four Fillies Lodge!
I wanna start by saying I love this place, MOST of the time the customer service is great, Lauren, and a girl with curly blonde hair are the sweetest. But I went today and a girl named Ava who is semi-new was sooo sooo rude to me and my grandma, we asked for something and to start she insisted they didn’t sell it, so we asked the manager and she said they did, so as she was making it the same girl was mean-mugging both of us the whole time we were waiting, she also slammed the window in our face, she was extremely disrespectful and rude to us all because was told her something was on the menu when she didn’t think it was. I hope if a manager is reading this they fire her ASAP. I’m used to being treated so nicely, this was a complete turn around.
Great local ice cream spot! This place is so cute, brings you back to different times, and is so tasty. Highly recommend stopping in for a treat!
Quick service, great prices and portions! I'll definitely be back. Clean place with inside, outside and drive-thru options.
Amazing
I needed a pit stop along my drive up I-77, and this ice cream shop fit the bill. Yes, it’s a bit of a drive from the interstate, but well worth it. It’s decorated in a 50’s retro style, with indoor and outdoor seating.
I split a brownie sundae with my daughter, and it was more than enough for both of us. The brownie was hot and gooey. Cute place, nice atmosphere, and yummy ice cream.
The ice cream is just good. The customer service is so unfriendly. The two young women really made us feel like they were doing us a favor by deigning to wait on us. Won’t go back.
What a delight! In fact, I will call it the highlight of the trip!
Always good tasting. Staff is friendly
Great little ice cream shop. But kind of basic flavors for ice cream.
Restaurantji Recommends
Super tasty, I got black berry cobbler with lemon custard. It's where I chose to go for my birthday if that says anything.
It's not Birkshires. It's renamed Evens Sweets Frozen Custard no ice cream.
Took a long time before anyone came to take my order and they were not even busy.
I don’t want to bad mouth any business and typically I will not do a review, but changes need to be made at this (what used to be great) frozen custard spot. Over the past few months service has declined extremely. Tonight was the worst. I had a very simple order of a chocolate milkshake with some Reese’s cups added in. The first time the milkshake came out after a 45 minute wait it was watered down and just looked like chocolate sludge. It also had no Reese’s cups in the mixture. I decided to politely ask for some Reese’s to be added in to which wasn’t an issue but this was also another 10 minute wait just to be seen. I also want to note that when I walked in the door I wasn’t spoken to or greeted. I had to bring an employee’s attention to my issue. Then I watched as the other employee didn’t seem to have a clue as to how to add Reese’s into the already made milkshake. I stood there for another 10 minutes and watched as the employee with NO GLOVES kept using my straw to try and mix in the resse’s. I want to note that no employee was wearing gloves while handling money and then preparing the food and drinks. By the time that I got the milkshake it was completely melted and discolored. I don’t want to blame the employees completely because it appears as though they have not had proper training. Unfortunately what used to be my favorite place to get a sweat treat has just lost a loyal customer. Berkshires was doing something right that Evan’s sweets is not. The quality and taste isn’t the same. The customer service is non existent. I hate to see what used to be a flourishing business fail in this way. Change needs to be made. I could’ve given this a 1 star but I’m giving it 2 as a courtesy and hope for changed to be made.
I absolutely love their ice cream! Especially the chocolate, I have never had such rich, delicious chocolate ice cream anywhere. Most places you can get ice cream have the pale chocolate with very little, if any flavor, but the chocolate here is amazing. We love it and stop by almost every time we're in Princeton.My son loves their footlong hot dogs and I get the regular Ball Park, very good.I wish they had fries and maybe onion rings to go with the dogs and burgers but that's NOT a deal breaker for us, lol.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotdog with Slaw, Oreo, Frozen Custard, Small Waffle Cone, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Custard in a Waffle Cone
Loading...