East of Chicago Pizza of Salem

66 Valley St, Salem
(304) 782-2400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Galaxy Girl 300

Food is flavorful! Service is good! Amount of toppings used on their pizzas is SAD! Just ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza & the chicken was scarce! Pizza may have had 1- 2 small chicken pieces per slice. So it was basically a cheese pizza with a different sauce.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Ginna Lee Quinn

I ordered 3 Taco Salads, no black olives, extra sour cream, and add onions. Paid nearly $40 for 3 Taco Salads that had black olives, no extra sour cream, no salsa, no onions, and barely any taco meat. The only good thing I have to say is that my delivery driver, Allie, was very sweet and considerate. I’ve given this place too many second chances. Highly disappointed. Shinnston location… 👎🏻

Bryan Wright

We have always enjoyed a pizza from here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

ts_kids

Apparently, this place has decided not to do delivery's any more instead relying on Door Dash, which has a massive price hike and a fairly large risk that your food will get stolen. On top of that, they are no longer taking mobile orders through their app.
Probably not going to order from them very often now since they were already very expensive before the door dash tax.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Jerri Kelley

Great pizza! We've really liked everything so far. Good popcorn chicken, garlic cheese pizza bread, the stuffed crust pizza - all YUM. Except the last time they forgot the pineapple on my pizza ?Still 5 stars!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Benjamin Nice

Fast and friendly staff can't wait to go back again

Vegetarian options: You can't order any way you like

Dietary restrictions: There is gluten free options

Parking: Parking right in front of the store

Kid-friendliness: Staff is very patient

Wheelchair accessibility: No curbs going into the building

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 7 Layer Veggie Sub 12

Connie James

Delicious food and friendly service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isaac J Dennison

have tried to order delivery multiple times and they never have a delivery driver

Chris Putman

They hardly put meat on subs and don't put on what you order

Charles Maxwell

Have ordered multiple meals from this store. Staff is friendly and helpful. The pizza has good flavor and is baked well. The subs have a nice spin and good flavor. Salads had fresh vegetables and fresh sides. My total assessment is quality and flavorful food but the value for what you get is where this restaurant suffers the most. Subs had minimal meats and cheese. Makes Subway Subs appear over stuffed. Salads were minimal at best. You will still be hungary after finishing. Yes, you can order more fixings but you are already paying a premium price for what they refer to as normal. Bottom line, good food but high priced for what you get.

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps to access store but the door does not have an auto open and it is just a standard door opening. A wheel chair will fit through door.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

janice fury

Pizza is awesome

Joseph Richardson

Hardly any meat on the subs.. I expect better paying $60 for food I will NEVER order from there again!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Phoenix Knight

delivery was early all the food hot and fresh I go to any location for the food and friendly staff

Amanda Robinson

My husband and I decided to give the salads a try at the new business location, in Salem. $18 later (after a 15% discount) and we are completely unsatisfied. They both had very little meat on them as well as very little other veggies (minus the lettuce) ~ we paid $9/ salad for lettuce.

April O'Dell

I ordered a large pepperoni and cheese pizza for pickup. When I arrived to pick up the pizza, the gentleman that was working the front counter was on the phone, no big deal, but when he hung the phone up he didn’t even acknowledge the fact that I was standing there. I stood there for 20 minutes knowing that he saw me, but he didn’t say a word to me, but instead decided to open a can of monster and drink it. He then proceeded to make another pizza for a customer without washing his hands first, after touching several things. After almost 30 minutes the guy decides to acknowledge me, and give me my pizza. I understand the short staff, but the least he could have done is acknowledge that I was there.

Loading...

East of Chicago Pizza of Salem

66 Valley St, Salem, WV 26426
(304) 782-2400