Great food wonderful service. The pimento cheese burger is amazing! I will be back for sure!
Jerry Collins
Wonderful food. Everything is pretty much homemade.
Terry Curry
Exceptionally good food...nice waitress
Robert Linton
Very good home cooked food
Teresa Doss
Food is delicious
Andrea Sherry Pearson
April 20, 2019 - another great “McAllister Easter Dinner†around 36 in attendance hosted by Pickaway Pickins! They did a great job! We love the fact there is space to share time with, great buffet bar- everyone finds something they love! The roast beef and fried chicken is our most favorite! Not mention home made pies (which you can order in advance for carry out)! If you family gatherings have out-grown your dining room as our have we highly recommend this restaurant! Hope to see you in September!
Becki Allen
The buffet is perfection.. probably the best scalloped potatoes and peanut butter pie I've had. Thanks for the comfort food and the casual environment!
Michelle Myers Vance
We had Valentine's dinner at Pickaway Pickins and it was wonderful. Our steaks were cooked just right. The chef was spot on with the Valentines special menu. We loved it. We eat here quite often and we have never been disappointed. We drive a good way to eat here because it is well worth the drive. Great food, friendly and accommodating wait staff, and a wonderful atmosphere.
Larry Kelley
Came in almost at closing time but was treated very well. Food was excellent, especially the salad. Waitress was very attentive and friendly. Great experience.
What a hidden gem!!! My family and I went to celebrate our oldest s straight A s, the food was great and the service was wonderful!!! The kids got the buffet, they have a wide variety of meats and vegetables, and it was a great way to let the kids start eating while we waited on our meals (the special, steak and shrimp). The steak was grilled exactly as ordered. We do not eat out a lot, do I tend to be picky, this is a DEFINITE repeat!!
April Glasser
Home cooked food without the cooking! Have been several times and it's been great..the open faced roast beef and homemade mashed potatoes is the best!..variety of desserts, soups and fresh salad bar. Thank you all...Keep up the great work!
Great food wonderful service. The pimento cheese burger is amazing! I will be back for sure!
Wonderful food. Everything is pretty much homemade.
Exceptionally good food...nice waitress
Very good home cooked food
Food is delicious
April 20, 2019 - another great “McAllister Easter Dinner†around 36 in attendance hosted by Pickaway Pickins! They did a great job! We love the fact there is space to share time with, great buffet bar- everyone finds something they love! The roast beef and fried chicken is our most favorite! Not mention home made pies (which you can order in advance for carry out)! If you family gatherings have out-grown your dining room as our have we highly recommend this restaurant! Hope to see you in September!
The buffet is perfection.. probably the best scalloped potatoes and peanut butter pie I've had. Thanks for the comfort food and the casual environment!
We had Valentine's dinner at Pickaway Pickins and it was wonderful. Our steaks were cooked just right. The chef was spot on with the Valentines special menu. We loved it. We eat here quite often and we have never been disappointed. We drive a good way to eat here because it is well worth the drive. Great food, friendly and accommodating wait staff, and a wonderful atmosphere.
Came in almost at closing time but was treated very well. Food was excellent, especially the salad. Waitress was very attentive and friendly. Great experience.
Better than RIO In Myrtle Beach!
Restaurantji Recommends
What a hidden gem!!! My family and I went to celebrate our oldest s straight A s, the food was great and the service was wonderful!!! The kids got the buffet, they have a wide variety of meats and vegetables, and it was a great way to let the kids start eating while we waited on our meals (the special, steak and shrimp). The steak was grilled exactly as ordered. We do not eat out a lot, do I tend to be picky, this is a DEFINITE repeat!!
Home cooked food without the cooking! Have been several times and it's been great..the open faced roast beef and homemade mashed potatoes is the best!..variety of desserts, soups and fresh salad bar. Thank you all...Keep up the great work!
Loading...