Italian Restaurants near Teays Valley

“Very surprised that this place has such a sub par review. I'm a truck driver and it visited here on. 7/14/25 in the evening with my 2 granddaughters. Our food was great and the service was awesome. Like someone else started, there seemed to only be one person working but he was prompt and very nice. I would definitely come here again. We ordered a Philly sub, honey mustard wings and a calzone. Photos attached“

“We had lunch today at Sergio’s.. Hurricane! Amazing! Service and Food were awesome.— when you feel welcomed and attended to.. you only want to support a restaurant more. This place never disappoints. Bravo! Cheers!“

“We were looking for a place to have dinner in this very cold Saturday night and decided to try the "Red Line Diner." It was a great decision. We read the reviews before visiting the restaurant, but our experience there was even better than we expected. Our hostess, this young lady named Dyamond (yes, with a "y), was extremely kind and always checked on us. Their tea was freshly brewed, and she kept refilling our glasses. The food was marvelous as well. If you like melted cheese, the cheese ravioli may make you very happy. :) Our pastas came with salads and toast. I also loved the 50ish, 60ish style decoration. Another thing that truly got my attention was the great music videos being played on their TV. The 90s and early 2000's R&B songs (everything from Mary J. Blige and Mariah Carey to Faith Evans and Leela James) made the night even more special. The music selection truly made me feel like I was having dinner in one of those wonderful diners in New Jersey. Dyamond was the one responsible for the music selection. Thumbs up, young lady! We are definitely coming back because food is not all when one goes out for dinner. It is also about the service and the atmosphere. And, folks, this place got it all.“

“Cod dinner and appetizers were just right, and wait staff did great job. Nice relaxed atmosphere.“

“Best pizza in the area in my humble opinion. Consistently good. Always ready fast and cooked to perfection exactly as I've ordered it. My pizza is always correct. Once I was missing a ranch dip but I noticed minutes away and they quickly rectified it. I haven't gotten pizza anywhere else in town since I tried theirs after a couple bad experiences at Gino's in Eleanor. They are reasonably priced and have great family deals.“

“we had dinner there tonight an the food an service was amazing! will definitely be back soon!“

“Food was great, hot, tasted, and excellent service“

“I was on my way to Michigan and stopped by this place on the way. While ordering they were having trouble with their system but decided to take care of 2 hungry kids and a hungry dad. I ordered the chicken salad and ordered pasta with sauce on the side, 2 meatballs, and also got some garlic bread. The food was perfect. On my way out, I asked how I could pay and the lady behind the counter said “It’s on me.” I don’t take that lightly and could be more appreciative of the gesture. I’ll be stopping by again on future trips.

Kid-friendliness: They also made a custom pasta dish that the kids liked. Thank you!“