Patsy's Pizza in elm Grove is really starting to suffer! Used to be so so good. Now the people are great and the service is wonderful but they stopped putting as much cheese on their Pizza. So you have to order extra cheese just to make it look normal and taste normal. So I go to DiCarlo's in downtown Wheeling all the time now! It never disappoints they're always on time. They never make you wait 45 minutes after the time. You 've specified you wanted your order ready. They are awesome!
Whitney Boni
5/5 for a by the slice pizza spot. It's a Valley tradition.
Michael Holtom
Always great pizza!
Shirley Olson
This is a popular, regional pizza. My husband grew up in the area and couldn't wait to get this pizza. He was not disappointed.
Braiden Metcalf
Said they were training new people and they did great. Lunch Special was done in 8 minutes and it was as good as always 10/10 the best DiCarlos location
Pocahontas Bird
I love these slices of pizza. The crust is crunchy and the cheese goes on unmelted. It’s very popular in wheeling and it’s onot 1.55 a slice. If you don’t want pepperoni then you can get another topping for free-like mushrooms.
kurt kleiner
Drove from Dayton ohio to get some take and bake pizza for home. The crew was friendly and helpful! The pizza was fantastic
Carolyn Hughes
Was a little disappointed, crust is much thinner and very crispy, sauce was not hot and less cheese than normal.
Great pizza , different than any pizza I ever had. Cheese and pepperoni added just before serving slices
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lisa Stone
The dicarlos at the highlands is not open on sunday. however, there are signs all around the sports complex that says that they are. please don't be fooled like we were
Anita Johnston
Pizza was as good as usual! Service was fast and friendly!
Parking: Plenty of free parking!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, 2 Liter, Chips, 20oz Bottle, Extra Cheese Pepperoni Pizza Tray, Cheese Pizza Cut, Banana Peppers, Bag of Cheese, Bag of Mild Peppers, Extra Sauce or Dressing, Sausage, Soft Crust, Crispy Crust, Melted Cheese, Pepperoni Roll, Cheeseless Meat Pizza, Half Tray, Tray Cheese Pizza
Angela Watson
Pizza and pepperoni roll was delicious. Fresh ingredients, just pizza but so good ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Glen Clifton
Standard Dicarlos pizza. I enjoyed it. Extra star for atmosphere since u could have a beer while u waited.
My favorite!
Patsy's Pizza in elm Grove is really starting to suffer! Used to be so so good. Now the people are great and the service is wonderful but they stopped putting as much cheese on their Pizza. So you have to order extra cheese just to make it look normal and taste normal. So I go to DiCarlo's in downtown Wheeling all the time now! It never disappoints they're always on time. They never make you wait 45 minutes after the time. You 've specified you wanted your order ready. They are awesome!
5/5 for a by the slice pizza spot. It's a Valley tradition.
Always great pizza!
This is a popular, regional pizza. My husband grew up in the area and couldn't wait to get this pizza. He was not disappointed.
Said they were training new people and they did great. Lunch Special was done in 8 minutes and it was as good as always 10/10 the best DiCarlos location
I love these slices of pizza. The crust is crunchy and the cheese goes on unmelted. It’s very popular in wheeling and it’s onot 1.55 a slice. If you don’t want pepperoni then you can get another topping for free-like mushrooms.
Drove from Dayton ohio to get some take and bake pizza for home. The crew was friendly and helpful! The pizza was fantastic
Was a little disappointed, crust is much thinner and very crispy, sauce was not hot and less cheese than normal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Excellent job to the whole staff
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza , different than any pizza I ever had. Cheese and pepperoni added just before serving slices
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The dicarlos at the highlands is not open on sunday. however, there are signs all around the sports complex that says that they are. please don't be fooled like we were
Pizza was as good as usual! Service was fast and friendly!
Parking: Plenty of free parking!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, 2 Liter, Chips, 20oz Bottle, Extra Cheese Pepperoni Pizza Tray, Cheese Pizza Cut, Banana Peppers, Bag of Cheese, Bag of Mild Peppers, Extra Sauce or Dressing, Sausage, Soft Crust, Crispy Crust, Melted Cheese, Pepperoni Roll, Cheeseless Meat Pizza, Half Tray, Tray Cheese Pizza
Pizza and pepperoni roll was delicious. Fresh ingredients, just pizza but so good ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Standard Dicarlos pizza. I enjoyed it.
Extra star for atmosphere since u could have a beer while u waited.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...