The Bread Barn Pizzeria

5 3rd St, Big Piney
(307) 276-4922

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Big Herm

The Bread Barn Pizzeria—what words can do justice to this sanctuary of flavors? It is a rare and blessed thing to find a place where every pizza reflects the care and passion of its creator. And that creator is none other than Frank, a man whose warmth and dedication shine as brightly as the oven at the heart of his establishment.

The moment you drive up to the window at the Bread Barn, you are greeted not just as a customer, but as a cherished guest. Frank himself, ever the gracious host truly loves what he does. He greets each customer with a smile and a word of kindness, eager to share the stories behind his menu and the labor of love that goes into every dish. Each pizza is something more than a transaction—it is an experience, a memory to savor.

And what a memory the Syrian Chicken pizza leaves! From its first golden, fragrant appearance, lovingly packaged in a box hand-crafted from the finest Italian cardboard, it was clear this was no ordinary pie. The crust, crisp yet tender, bore the perfect char of an artisan’s touch. The chicken, seasoned with a masterful blend of spices, carried the warmth and complexity of Frank’s craft. With every bite, the earthy depth of garlic mingled with the rich, savory sauce—a creation so perfectly balanced, it could only come from someone with a profound understanding of flavor.

To dine at the Bread Barn Pizzeria is to be reminded of the joy that food can bring—not just through taste, but through the people who pour their hearts into its creation.

If you find yourself anywhere near the Bread Barn, do not hesitate. Prepare to understand why this humble pizzeria has earned my highest praise. It is a feast for the senses and a celebration of what a restaurant can truly be.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christie DiMarco

I had made a mistake and ordered a pizza here for pickup. Not realizing I had accidentally ordered from here and not my local pizza place with a similar name. In a whole different state. Even the girl on the phone sounded the same as the gal at my spot.

The gal was nice on the phone but when they called back asking where I was, her and a guy were mean. I had realized I made a mistake then after they were yelling at me their business name and location when trying to figure out what’s going on.

I WAS going to pay for the pizza and leave a nice tip for the time and product wasted , but the guy was very rude, like he’s never made a mistake in his life, or like I did this on purpose.

I want folks to still go here and check it out, I’m sure the foods great, I’m mostly writing this for them so that they maybe chill out a bit. Kindness goes a long way. I go out of my way a lot at the place I work even when others make mistakes that cost us, we wouldn’t dare give anyone the tone or words these people gave me.

Again, kindness goes a long way in life.

Service: 1

Ben

The proprietors are friendly and they make some GREAT pizza. Cool weekly special pizzas, but even your standard 1 or 2 topping of your normal choice is delicious. Tasty, hand made thin(ish, not TOO thin!) crust with the perfect amount of crisp. Quality, great tasting ingredients. For the area, prices are pretty darn good too!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks

Richard Baum

After you come off of the trail and get cell service, call ahead and order. Much better than stopping at a convenience store.

Daniel Y

Amazing pizza! The flavors were fantastic, and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. I highly recommend this spot to anyone passing through. The cheesy breadsticks were also a delicious treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Barn Pizza Our Supreme, Mozzarella Sticks

steve hoefler

Excellent service and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason Strong

Very friendly. Great pizza at a good price. Give it a

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Tindell

Absolutely the best pizza around it's always delicious and fresh,But their mozzarella sticks are to die for, They're absolutely nicest and polite people,It's become a weekly habit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Trevor Tindell

I have be let down on pizza, Since I've in Wyoming, I was so delighted to finally have a great pizza and bread sticks,But instead they had homemade mozzarella sticks,That will be a go to comfort food for now on,Plus the pizza was so delicious,And exactly what I wanted.

Kelly Dodds

Can't get enough of these pizzas so fresh right amount of toppings friendly staff the apple turnovers were just perfect reasonably priced

Jade Dodds

Big pizzas value for money very tasty

Rusty Burgett

Good food good service.

K. T RainWater

Made from scratch New York Style Pizza

Kevin Costello

Exceptional pie. Hard working crew with great service. Thank you!

Kevin

Exceptional pie. Hard working crew with great service. Thank you!

Loading...