Benny Montanaro's
327 Thelma Dr, Casper
(307) 337-1335
Customers' Favorites
Italian Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza Slice AMD Pepperoni Slice
Pepperoni & Italian Sausage Pizza
Slice of Three Little Pigs
Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Italian Sausage
Three Little Pigs Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
20 Oz Bottles
Cheese Slice
Menu
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Starting in 2023, when we enjoyed this new-ish pizza joint that served ENORMOUS slices (the last 4 of 2023, as we were told) that were DELICIOUS! has now become our annual New Year’s Eve tradition! Love the way we can customize per slice or get a whole 28” pie. So fun to share!! Drive your big car though…
Everyone has to try it just once. But don't plan on taking a whole pizza home if you have a tiny car. We will all be sitting inside watching you try to get it in the car and laughing. 😂
This place is BOMB. The pizza has always been fresh everytime I've went there or have had it delivered. Definitely a great place to take the entire family or if you have some friends from out of town visiting feeds everyone for a great price!
You May Also Like
Taco John's - 4031 E 2nd St
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill - 3845 E 2nd St
![]()
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
GRINGO - 455 Thelma Dr
![]()
Food Trucks, Burgers