Benny Montanaro's
327 Thelma Dr, Casper
(307) 337-1335
Customers' Favorites
Italian Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza Slice AMD Pepperoni Slice
Pepperoni & Italian Sausage Pizza
Slice of Three Little Pigs
Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Italian Sausage
Three Little Pigs Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
20 Oz Bottles
Cheese Slice
Menu
Photos
+13 photos
+12 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This was our first time having pizza from Benny's. We had very friendly service and the wait for two 28" pizzas wasn't a very long one. My family loves pizza, I'm not a huge fan of pizza in general, this is my favorite pizza in town. I was surprised that my daughter and I were the only ones in there at the moment. It's such a nice space. I know they are pretty expensive but I saw the by the slice prices and they were reasonable for the portion size.
Huge 28" pizza. Plenty for everyone. We love it. Three Little Pigs is the best. It's a bit tricky to carry in your car because of its size, and you kinda have to turn box on its side to get it through your front door, but it's worth it.
Under $20 for two gigantic slices and a couple sodas. I thought the slices were a little under cooked for my taste, so ask for well done if you prefer a crispy crust. Fun atmosphere, super clean kitchen and dining area, and the staff is always nice. We've tried most all of the different slices and prefer either pepperoni or plain old cheese.
You May Also Like
Taco John's - 4031 E 2nd St
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill - 3845 E 2nd St
![]()
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
Wendy's - 4281 E 2nd St
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers