Papa Johns Pizza

408 E Lincolnway, Cheyenne
(307) 778-8181

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Aleks Trabert

Barbara the gal who helped w my order on the phone was very friendly and provided great customer service even being so close to closing. They had a door dash driver deliver and the driver was very friendly and they got my order correct and included parmisan cheese. Driver was very friendly with my dog 5/5 stars greatly appreciated close to after hrs delivery. Barbara at the restaurant was amazing and very friendly and helpful with my order. Delivery was quicker then estimated delivery time. I'd give 6/5;stars they went above and beyond thank you :)!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nathan Cline

First off, they let my order sit for 1 hour until they closed. Second off, I had to call them twice; once 30 minutes after I placed it, and the second when they were about to close 30 minutes later. As a customer I should be let know. DoorDash or not (I didn’t even order off DoorDash and got transferred over.) 2 years ago this business ran well, without DoorDash. This business has fallen off and I no longer respect them. Not even for the peppers they serve with their sometimes delicious pizza. Haha, you guys were my #1. No more.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dee Aldridge

Gave the employee my name to pick up the pizza I had ordered on the app. The employee looked around with a puzzled look and said "someone stole your pizza." I said "no one stole my pizza. You gave it away to the wrong person." Something is not stolen when you willingly give it to them. The employee didn't first ask the other person the name on the order to confirm the correct person was there to pick it up. The employee did make me a new pizza but didn't offer a discount on a future pizza. That would have been nice since I had to wait around for the new pizza.

Food: 3

Service: 1

Dee

Arrived to pick up my order. They didn't have it. Gave it away to someone else already. They didn't ask for the name on the order. Just gave it away to someone who said they were here to pick up an order. So had to wait while they remade it.

Service: 1

Subena Lucas

Got home with a pizza with hardly any cheese, overloaded with onions, scant sausage/green pepper. I could barely choke any of it down, so most of it went in the trash. Ew.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jazz S

Ordered delivery. We live literally 2 miles from Papa John’s and the pizza was cold by the time we got it

Food: 2

Jason McCaslin

Ordered a pizza for pickup and was told it would be 30-35 minutes. When I got to the store they told me it would be another hour.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Anthony Seal

1) don't tip credit card in store, the managers keep those tips
2) they refuse to fix the hand washing sink by the make line, it's only cold water
3) they charged us to keep us hydrated
4) they had an employee appreciation day they told customers the employees were going to get a percentage of and never did
5) they pay 12.50 an hour with no benefits
I put my time in there. Go to blackjack. It's better to their employees and their food is better too.
Ps Tim you got more problems you should be worrying about then ten minutes and a wrong shirt. But I guess we just don't see eye to eye. Pos

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Misty Garrett

Garlic Knots were way over cooked and had no garlic flavor.. And pass on the boneless wings they are just cheap chicken nuggets with sauce. On the plus side I loved my grub hub driver..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

D S

Come on? , a one topping pizza with more than half of the large pizza without the single topping. Do better, be real!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Michael Means (Wholesoulfood llc)

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Imran Khan

Great Food, Great Service provided by Josh, I really appreciated.
Thank you all @ #2395.
Imran

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Worthy Pizza, Cheese Sticks

Danny Van Vleet

Cheese sticks and pizza were done fast and to perfection. Customer service was friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Purple Rain

I was sadly very unsatisfied with Joshua’s customer service and due to that fact I have been forced to take an extra 15 minute drive to drive to the other papa John’s since they actually know how to attend there customers! Think a little harder next time Josh Josh….

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mi chelle

I am a door dasher the people making the pizzas have no gloves on! Pretty disgusting really! Common have some decency for the public and who knows what y’all done with your bare hands

Loading...