Pie Lady

#A, 3515 E Lincolnway, Cheyenne
(307) 637-8838

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tim DeVoss

Great Food and Nice People

Korrie Dawn VanGorder

Beyond rude! We called and put in an order for take-out and the first guy I spoke to seemed friendly but then another lady got on the phone and acted like I was a complete inconvenience to her day. I couldn't find a website to view a menu so I eventually found a photo of the menu on this site. Upon ordering, I was treated like I was incompetent when I ordered something that, apparently, is no longer made. The entire phone call was incredibly unpleasant. Then, while we were th

Karla Malone

Great homemade food and a super affordable price.

Chad Kuepker

Excellent chicken pot pie and coconut cream pie. The lady that runs it is a wonderful person as well. I would recommend everyone give it a shot

Sally Ives

Amazing service. Best hamburgers in town.

shain rhodes

We love the place! nice, clean, and great food

Tomas McCartney

Super pie. The potato soup did not hit the mark but the pie well made up for it.

Jodie Boley

Good food, nice quiet place.

Chester Barkell

It's great. It has good food and salads. The service is great.

Jim Peters

I have been going to the pie lady for a years and Ray and Jackie have always been welcoming and helpful. The food is delicious!

Paula Lee

Extremely disappointed. We drove way out of our way to eat here. My sandwich was lacking meat and the bread was simple white bread and smelled bad. The soup tasted like it came out of a can. My friend had a salad and she liked it. We both wanted to try the pie because that's what they are noted for. I had lemon and I could barely taste the lemon in it. The pie crust tasted like the one you buy pre-made at the store. Super thin, tough and tasteless. My friend ordered chocolate pecan, and the pecans tasted stale and the chocolate filling was just weird and not very tasty. We were the only ones there at 1 PM which seemed a little odd to me. Now I know why.

Tim Holzer

Pies are superb. Food is great. Prices are good.

Jean McClun

Always great food and service

Ted Hallberg

Best pies in town.

Kimberly Shupe

OMG!!! Super impressed with The Pie Lady! Not only are the pies amazing, so is the food! I highly recommend this cute lil restaurant!!!

Loading...