Pony Up Pub and Grub at the Affordable Inns.

339 Wasatch Rd, Evanston
(307) 789-2220

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Melanie Harker

Travis made us a wonderful dinner. With hand pounded real steak chicken fried steak and home made batter... I was extreamly impressed ?. The waffle fries were super yummy and hand mashed potatoes you don't find that kind of love in the restaurant biz any more. The last time I was in this restaurant I thought "this will be closed within the year," but they blew me away and have even stepped it up a notch or two. Thanks Travis, keep it up an that place will be back to too busy in no time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Fried Mozarella Sticks with Marinara Sauce

David Pasenelli

I joined 2 other folks for New Years dinner at the Round Table. The food was fabulous, the steak being cooked to perfection. The shrimp were small but they tasted great otherwise. The meal included soup and salad both. Everything was served fast with good timing with the courses and the waitress was the best. Service like she gave was appreciated very much and was also reflected in the huge gratuity. As I was in the service industry I recognized awesome friendly efficient and genuine service by a gal who could serve us a great meal as well as add friendly comments when we chatted with her.

Parking: We got there before the party crowds so plenty of room to park

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Castillo

2nd time stopping in this great place for a meal. 1st time finding this place, was out of desperation for a meal, as our first choice did not fair so well. Loved the the rib-eye with home made mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables the first time around, that I got it again. By far one of the best rib-eye steaks that I have ever had. Priced well, perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. Environment was very welcoming. Definitely highly recommend that you stop in for a great meal.

Gabriel Granger

Excellent food! Phenomenal prices for the high quality food they serve!

Parking: Free parking

Gay Kohl

After a scenic ride from Park City via Mirror Lake we decided on this steak house for dinner. Salad was crisp and topped with a generous amount of cheese. There were numerous dressings to pick from. We chose mashed potatoes (real potatoes and a huge serving)with gravy as a side to complement the 2 Parmesan breaded butterfly pork chops. Very tasty! The New York Strip steak was tender and cooked to perfection! Our wine choice (Dark Horse) and dinner made a perfect ending to a great day!

Parking: Easy access off the freeway with ample parking. Room for RV’s and vehicles with trailers to park.

Ross Appleyard

I have had many ribeye steaks in Wyoming in the past 30 years on my road trips from Denver to the PNW. Your steak tonight was BY FAR the best ( so far). This includes (iconic) Svilar’s in Hudson, WY Rib& Chop (multiple) and The Cowboy & Snake River Grill in Jackson. Tip of the hat to Travis the chef. Earlier testimonials are spot on-cannot eat ambiance, drinks are hearty pours. Steak-delish.

Macksimus Prime

First off after coming to the Roundtable Steakhouse oh, I ordered the cheeseburger and it took an hour and 50 minutes for 2 minute. At the time that I ordered my food business traffic was slow and the waitress and cook we're sitting down in the dining room. I've never had an experience like this before and I only pray that no one has to go through this like I did.

Debbie S

Ribeye was to die for! Absolute best steak we've ever had! Cooked & seasoned to absolute perfection. Tender enough to almost cut it by fork. We found the restaurant by happenstance on a road trip from California back to Virginia. It was so good we want to take a trip back to WY just for dinner. 5 stars ?

Glowing Trebstep

Pretty good mozzarella cheese sticks, the place smells like my grandmothers house. So it is quite homey. Other then the fact that it's in a bar.

Brian Lupkes

Great food, terrible ambiance. It's in an older hotel. You don't eat the ambiance, so I highly recommend this place if you are in Evanston.

Jayme

Ribeye steak was outstanding!Drinks were generously poured.Definitely not fancy but that's ok after being on the motorcycles for 15+ hours.Love the the hospital ❤️

Carlton Miller

Without going on a tandem but I'm going to say this to say that I have a cleaning service and I subcontract two other services in their areas I did online contractor goes with my bid I get to that location when I get to those locations I tried the various restaurants I don't do the fast foods I try to various restaurants in the town and the motels that I stay at I asked the front desk where can I find a good steak they make recommendations I go with the recommendations the first day if I like it I like it if I don't I don't usually the recommendations are not very good from the front desk this restaurant has a quality product and I would give it five stars for the product the food five stars for the environment people entertainment I'm trying not to be long-winded here but I want you to get what I'm saying I travel a lot and I would definitely recommend it five stars I had the quarter pound burger the fishing chips kicked it at the bar with the owner was treated like royalty what more can I say

Kevin Munoz

The Round Table steak restaurants have great breakfast, lunch or dinner. The food is outstanding. Love our meal alot. We had place to our self too. Come try it out for self hope it will be good for u... The one morning we came for breakfast they had all you could eat breakfast food was amazing. Then we came in for dinner couple time it great too. They price are not high from most. We got good service and good was great too. We will have to remember come here more often.

Parking: Parking was nice didn't have to walk to much on entering.

Wheelchair accessibility: They have great handicap parking too.

Kip Pearce

It’s pretty awesome to have a quaint little bar and great live music. Great place

James Hogan

This is the restaurant in the dumpy hotel I stayed at. Breakfast was a small bottle of OJ and a cellophane wrapped danish.

Loading...

Pony Up Pub and Grub at the Affordable Inns.

339 Wasatch Rd, Evanston, WY 82930
(307) 789-2220