Isabella's

Name: Isabella's
Address: 12 S Sumner Ave, Newcastle, Wyoming, 82701, US
Telephone: (307) 746-3500
Price range: $
Rating: 4.3

$ • American, Italian, Pizza

Hours:
12 S Sumner Ave, Newcastle
(307) 746-3500

Menu Order Online

About Isabella's

Isabella's offers a welcoming atmosphere with a big bar area and sturdy seating. The friendly and attentive staff serve delicious food, including the popular pepperoni mushroom pizza and BBQ Blue Burger. The menu features a variety of dishes beyond pizza, such as steak egg rolls filled with meat, peppers, and onions served with Thai sauce, which are highly praised as the best ever. The spinach artichoke dip comes with crispy toasted Texas toast pieces that remain in good condition when covered in dip. The fish and chips are well-cooked with a crisp outside and soft inside, although the fish may be a bit bland compared to other dishes. The cranberry and blue cheese salad is one of the best and is highly rated. Outside seating is available, though flies can be an issue on warmer days. The restaurant offers a couple of desserts, though they were not tried during recent visits. Service is consistently good, with a friendly staff that engages in small talk even when busy. Many find the food and service excellent, with reasonable prices and fast service making it a favorite for many. The sausage gravy is notably the best, and visitors are encouraged to stop in for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The restaurant also offers easy parking options from both the lot and street. Recent reviews mention a pleasant experience with good food and a friendly atmosphere, highlighting the meat lovers Pizza as exceptional with a perfect cheese and meat ratio. While service was noted as a bit slow at times, the overall experience remains positive.