Have eaten here often and for many years. Last time I made reservations for lunch only to arrive and the place was closed. Now I see it's not only closed for lunch but closed entirely! We've seen this place go way down hill after ownership changed. So sad to see this run into the ground. Web site says temporarily closed but I bet it never reopens unless a new owner takes over, one that actually knows how to run a restaurant! Service folks have been awesome through the decline of this place! My heart goes out to them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Susan Taylor
Have eaten here often and for many years. Last time I made reservations for lunch only to arrive and the place was closed. Now I see it's not only closed for lunch but closed entirely! We've seen this place go way down hill after ownership changed. So sad to see this run into the ground. Web site says temporarily closed but I bet it never reopens unless a new owner takes over, one that actually knows how to run a restaurant! Service folks have been awesome through the decline of this place! My heart goes out to them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Natalie Knuth
A must when in Sheridan. Truffle fries with wasabi sauce, wedge salad, pasta, steak... everything is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ustole myMusterd
Great food and atmosphere, but the waiter forgot about us. She took 10 minutes on average to refill our drinks. She also forgot to put our entree order in, coming back and asking us what we had, with the reassurance of "It's coming soon!" It was not. She also forgot about our order of soup. She put our desert order in wrong then abandoned the table, we had to ask another waiter to get the second part of our desert order. Hope next time I come I get a different waiter. Atleast the food was delicious. Good job chefs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Lori J.
Great service, great cocktails, and an incredible meal. Fine dining right in the middle of downtown Sheridan. Highly recommend.
Jason Swindell
I’ve never felt so ripped off in my life. I don’t usually write bad reviews for restaurants, but this one is really bad. $22 for a small appetizer of cold calamari. I paid $36 for an 8 oz. pork chop. No bread, no salad (ya you read that right). The pork chop was mainly bone, over cooked. Very dry. The “side” was literally 4 fingerling potatoes (not even whole ones, they were cut in half. I enjoyed my stay in Sheridan Wyoming so much! This was the only bad part of it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
KEVIN O.
Monica steered us right into The risotto w/ flat iron Steak and Pesto Pasta......desert was carmel salted cake which was SUPER TASTY
peteys575
Great Place To Eat!! just can’t say enough about this restaurant! It has a Wonderful bar, delicious food and a vibe that is as friendly as Sheridan itself!! We will be back!!
Kati Harvey
The appetizer was decent but small. The truffle fries at $8.25 are the best "deal" as far as apps go. The food for our table of 4 took 75 minutes to arrive after we placed our order and our waitress didn't stop by to refill waters, check on us or relay that the kitchen was apparently backed up.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Jan Hardisty
Never had a wedge salad with Gorgonzola. Not much cheese and had to ask for extra dressing. The beet and goat cheese was completely different than we normally experience, but it was delicious and I would order it again.
Never had a wedge salad with Gorgonzola. Not much cheese and had to ask for extra dressing. The beet and goat cheese was completely different than we normally experience, but it was delicious and I would order it again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kendra Shaffer
I absolutely love the service! Everyone is so great ? I have never had a bad meal and have always has a wonderful time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Gnocchi
Will
We have not been here in over 10 years, and it is still great. We enjoyed the fried Calamari, the Caesar Salad, as well as the Mushroom Risotto and the Steak Sandwich. The service was outstanding, and the atmosphere was great. We live a few hours away and will happily plan nights in Sheridan just to eat here. It was such a pleasant meal, and Taylor took amazing care of us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari
Denise C.
Excellent food, excellent service, great ambiance, not too pricey. A hidden gem. Highly recommend.
Robin S
I am very surprised by their high score - folks in Sheridan must have low expectations sorry to say. I have visited the restaurant several times with the last being the other day. All were disappointing, especially the food. The fries were served hot which was delightful but our Cobb salads came looking disgusting at best! When I ordered I had asked if the chicken was fresh grilled, served hot on the salad and was told YES by our server. The chicken was right out of the fridge and not fresh. The avocado was brown and tasted horrible, the bacon was rubbery, and the lettuce was wilty and slimy in spots. I asked for my balsamic dressing on the side - didn’t happen, the dressing was tossed in the dressing. AND to add insult to injury we waited 45 minutes for the salad being told “sorry, we are training in the back”. Your restaurant looks nice from the outside and that’s where I will be staying from now on. You can do better!!
Have eaten here often and for many years. Last time I made reservations for lunch only to arrive and the place was closed. Now I see it's not only closed for lunch but closed entirely! We've seen this place go way down hill after ownership changed. So sad to see this run into the ground. Web site says temporarily closed but I bet it never reopens unless a new owner takes over, one that actually knows how to run a restaurant! Service folks have been awesome through the decline of this place! My heart goes out to them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Have eaten here often and for many years. Last time I made reservations for lunch only to arrive and the place was closed. Now I see it's not only closed for lunch but closed entirely! We've seen this place go way down hill after ownership changed. So sad to see this run into the ground. Web site says temporarily closed but I bet it never reopens unless a new owner takes over, one that actually knows how to run a restaurant! Service folks have been awesome through the decline of this place! My heart goes out to them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
A must when in Sheridan. Truffle fries with wasabi sauce, wedge salad, pasta, steak... everything is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and atmosphere, but the waiter forgot about us. She took 10 minutes on average to refill our drinks. She also forgot to put our entree order in, coming back and asking us what we had, with the reassurance of "It's coming soon!" It was not. She also forgot about our order of soup. She put our desert order in wrong then abandoned the table, we had to ask another waiter to get the second part of our desert order. Hope next time I come I get a different waiter. Atleast the food was delicious. Good job chefs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Great service, great cocktails, and an incredible meal. Fine dining right in the middle of downtown Sheridan. Highly recommend.
I’ve never felt so ripped off in my life. I don’t usually write bad reviews for restaurants, but this one is really bad. $22 for a small appetizer of cold calamari. I paid $36 for an 8 oz. pork chop. No bread, no salad (ya you read that right). The pork chop was mainly bone, over cooked. Very dry. The “side” was literally 4 fingerling potatoes (not even whole ones, they were cut in half. I enjoyed my stay in Sheridan Wyoming so much! This was the only bad part of it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Monica steered us right into The risotto w/ flat iron Steak and Pesto Pasta......desert was carmel salted cake which was SUPER TASTY
Great Place To Eat!! just can’t say enough about this restaurant! It has a Wonderful bar, delicious food and a vibe that is as friendly as Sheridan itself!! We will be back!!
The appetizer was decent but small. The truffle fries at $8.25 are the best "deal" as far as apps go. The food for our table of 4 took 75 minutes to arrive after we placed our order and our waitress didn't stop by to refill waters, check on us or relay that the kitchen was apparently backed up.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Never had a wedge salad with Gorgonzola. Not much cheese and had to ask for extra dressing. The beet and goat cheese was completely different than we normally experience, but it was delicious and I would order it again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Never had a wedge salad with Gorgonzola. Not much cheese and had to ask for extra dressing. The beet and goat cheese was completely different than we normally experience, but it was delicious and I would order it again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I absolutely love the service! Everyone is so great ? I have never had a bad meal and have always has a wonderful time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Gnocchi
We have not been here in over 10 years, and it is still great. We enjoyed the fried Calamari, the Caesar Salad, as well as the Mushroom Risotto and the Steak Sandwich. The service was outstanding, and the atmosphere was great. We live a few hours away and will happily plan nights in Sheridan just to eat here. It was such a pleasant meal, and Taylor took amazing care of us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari
Excellent food, excellent service, great ambiance, not too pricey. A hidden gem. Highly recommend.
I am very surprised by their high score - folks in Sheridan must have low expectations sorry to say. I have visited the restaurant several times with the last being the other day. All were disappointing, especially the food. The fries were served hot which was delightful but our Cobb salads came looking disgusting at best! When I ordered I had asked if the chicken was fresh grilled, served hot on the salad and was told YES by our server. The chicken was right out of the fridge and not fresh. The avocado was brown and tasted horrible, the bacon was rubbery, and the lettuce was wilty and slimy in spots. I asked for my balsamic dressing on the side - didn’t happen, the dressing was tossed in the dressing. AND to add insult to injury we waited 45 minutes for the salad being told “sorry, we are training in the back”. Your restaurant looks nice from the outside and that’s where I will be staying from now on. You can do better!!