New American Restaurants in Key West, FL

“Andrea T., our server, was amazing. Very attentive and provided great suggestions for food, which was also delicious. Can’t beat the views, especially the sunset. All around fantastic culinary experience. A special evening celebrating our bro-in-law’s 55th birthday.“

“It would be nice if they would cook their food separately from their seafood for people with seafood/fish allergies. I was very restricted to the sides that I could eat last night because they fry everything together. You would think for this type of five star restaurant they could at least fry their food separately“

“It was an enjoyable evening watching Randy Roberts singing Cher, Bette and others at LaTeDa. The outfits were amazing!!!! He was very interactive with the audience and very funny!!! Would recommend going just to hear him sing. No lip syncing here!!!!“

“We were there on a Monday evening and it was quiet, the service was outstanding, wait staff was attentive and accommodating. The food was excellent, I had the branzino and my husband had the seafood risotto, both were delicious. We would definitely go back the next time we are in Key West and I will be sure to recommend it to everyone.“

“Fun, weird quirky place. Star Wars X-wing fighters hanging from the ceiling. X-men comic book and a Wolverine action figure hanging on the wall. Yet this place still pulls off a romantic vibe.Not easy to find the place I think that might be intentional. It’s almost like they dare you to eat there, if you can find it.Key west is loaded with great restaurants. This was our favorite of them all.A party of two, I couldn’t decide between the snapper and the tasting trio. They were nice enough to swap out the grouper with the snapper. My date had the tasting trio with the grouper and we shared the appetizer tasting trio. Everything was delicious. Don’t miss out on the lobster Mac and cheese it is the way of the Jedi.“

“I was looking for a nice restaurant at a pretty good price in Key West and this place was perfect. Got some happy hour drinks and the Mahi mahi bites which were cooked perfectly. I’ve worked at the top seafood restaurant in my home state for 8 years and the Tuna Nachos and Tuna dinner platter were right on par with my home restaurant!! Great place and a great value! Would have preferred Caribbean music rather than country but that just a personal preference ?“

“Stopped in after 8 on a Thursday hoping to get a drink and bite at the bar. It was packed with a fun combination of locals and visitors and the host went out of his way to ensure we had drinks and watched over us until two seats opened up. Then we met Eric, who continued to provide the best service in town and did his best to make sure everyone at the bar knew each other. We shared a flavorful mushroom quesadilla and Caesar salad with mahi. The mahi mahi was so beautifully prepared it flaked apart with a fork, and the dressing was much lighter than the creamy version too many restaurants serve these days. Even with the wait at the beginning (get those reservations in!), it was a leisurely hour and a half of good food and wonderful company.“

“Great hidden gem in key west. Perfect atmosphere with a great sunset view and a little tucked away from the typically key west commotion. Service was excellent and food was great too. This is the perfect spot if you are looking for a quiet place to watch some boats go by and feel like you have a little slice of paradise all to yourself.“

“Amazing Amazing, Amazing ! There was not one thing about our dinner that wasn't absolutely perfect and delicious. Our server was attentive and so knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Our appetizer, our salads, the conch chowder just so delicious. The yellow snapper with mango and cucumber salsa, was so fresh and light, I never clean my plate and I didn't leave a crumb for my husband! We are usually in Key West once or twice a year and we will be back the atmosphere is fantastic too!“

“White table cloths and a menu that matches. Had lunch with my wife and we shared two dishes - Salade Salmon Nicoise - the perfect amount of dressing, fresh vegetables, and salmon was cooked perfect.Flat bread was great - rustic, authentic.Key Lime Pie for dessert- gooey graham cracker crust, punching key lime flavor.“

“Been here over the years and it's always one of my first stops when I come to Key West. Lance was absolutely amazing tonight. Extremely educated on wines and menu- great personality and dealt with us as a late walk in. We just got here and wanted real good food and that it was!!! Never disappoints. Oysters are phenomenal and grouper special was out of this world! Can't wait to be back this week.“

“We were given the happy hour recommendations from our Hyatt Windward staff and the restaurant did not disappoint! We have traveled extensively and these were some of the best bar bites we have ever had. The salmon bites and lamb lollipops were seasoned so well; delicious. The dessert we had was not overly sweet, but a complex mix of flavors. Shout out to the staff who waited on us from Hungary; very attentive and professional.“

“Christine H deserves more than 5 stars for her excellent friendly attentive service. She's very knowledgeable about the food, cocktails and the local area. A great personality.The terrace has a great location overlooking the harbour, and the food and drinks there are great.“

“A Culinary Gem Along Key West's Waterfront: The White Tarpon**A Gastronomic Delight:** If you're seeking an unforgettable culinary experience amidst the vibrant tapestry of Key West, look no further than The White Tarpon. Nestled along the scenic docks of A-B Marina, this hidden gem promises not just a meal, but a journey through the flavors of the Florida Keys.**Blackened Fish Tacos:** Prepare your taste buds for a symphony of flavors with their signature Blackened Fish Tacos, crafted from fresh yellowtail snapper. Each bite is a harmony of spices, perfectly complemented by the delicate texture of the fish.**Conch Fritters:** Dive into the essence of Key West cuisine with their succulent Conch Fritters, a true delicacy of the region. Crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, these fritters are a testament to the chef's mastery of traditional flavors.**Hummus Plate:** Elevating the dining experience with finesse, The White Tarpon offers a Hummus Plate that transcends ordinary appetizers. Fresh veggies, crisp sesame crackers, marinated olives, and creamy goat cheese come together in a symphony of textures and tastes, accented by the refreshing sweetness of watermelon.**A Slice of Key West Life:** Immerse yourself in the laid-back atmosphere of Key West as you dine amidst the gentle breeze and the sound of boats returning from their charters. The open-air ambiance of The White Tarpon sets the stage for relaxation and indulgence.**Impeccable Service:** From the moment you step foot in this culinary haven, you're greeted with warm hospitality and attentive service. The staff at The White Tarpon are dedicated to ensuring that every aspect of your dining experience exceeds expectations.**Key Lime Pie:** No visit to Key West is complete without savoring a slice of authentic Key Lime Pie, and The White Tarpon delivers perfection in every bite. Pair it with a cup of coffee for a blissful conclusion to your meal.**Worth Every Penny:** While the prices may be slightly higher than neighboring establishments, the unparalleled quality of the cuisine and the serene atmosphere make every dollar spent at The White Tarpon worth it. At around $40 per person plus tip, it's an investment in an experience you'll cherish forever.**Final Verdict:** In a town brimming with culinary delights, The White Tarpon stands out as a shining star. With its exceptional food, inviting ambiance, and impeccable service, this establishment is not just a restaurant – it's an experience. Whether you're a visitor or a local, do yourself a favor and treat your palate to the wonders of The White Tarpon. It's no wonder why it could easily merit consideration for a Michelin star.**Bon Appétit and Happy Dining!**Thomas CorraoStray Compass Restaurant Reviews#straycompasslife“

“Great location off of Duval Street. The outdoor dining is the major draw. The food and cocktails are good and affordable. If you want an outdoor Key West dining experience that is not associated with a lively and noisy bar, this is the place.“

“Unfortunately the music was SO loud!! The musician set up about 10 minutes after we'd ordered our drinks. We couldn't hear across the table. He wasn't good enough for us to put up with it. Fortunately there was a garden table available. We moved and that was MUCH better. Food was good and server was incredibly good. She moved us within minutes.“

“Always our go to while we are here in key west. Bruschetta was amazing , and the chefs tasting plate / seafood pasta aswell. Service was a bit short and Abrupt, and seemed a bit irritated, as we asked him to separate the bill between two parties.“