11 Best Caribbean Restaurants in Key West

“I made a reservation here for a bachelorette dinner and it was a great choice. This restaurant is big with different areas. There is patio with live music, a karaoke room, a game area and a quieter seating room. The staff took care of our table well. The food was great with good portions. I had the coconut shrimp and the grilled mahi mahi tacos. All of it tasted fresh and flavorful. For dessert had some key lime pie and the hula girl pie with an oreo cookie crust and ice cream on top. We sat on the patio and that was a nice atmosphere with live music.“

“We loved it!!! The place can look modest, which also gives it a warmer atmosphere, very clean, the service is super efficient, the cocktails are very good and the food is really like the one I ate as a child when I went to my grandmother's house!! ! If you are in Key West you have to visit this place, otherwise you will be missing something too good ?“

“Stepping into Blue Heaven is like discovering Key West's best-kept secret—an enchanting blend of delicious food and laid-back charm that instantly wins you over. Right from the moment you enter, the atmosphere sets a unique tone, with its whimsical décor and the soft strumming of a guitar somewhere in the background. The presence of roaming chickens adds a quirky, almost magical touch, reminding you that you're in for something special.The menu is a delightful showcase of local flavors with a twist. Each dish we ordered was a hit, but the standout was definitely the Lobster Benedict. The lobster was fresh and succulent, perfectly paired with a velvety hollandaise sauce that was just the right kind of creamy. Another must-try is the Banana Bread, which is sweet, moist, and just heavenly—no pun intended!Service at Blue Heaven goes above and beyond. Our server was not only attentive but also had great recommendations that tailored perfectly to our tastes. Her knowledge of the menu and the local ingredients made our dining experience feel personal and cared for.Blue Heaven not only impresses with its food and service but also with its commitment to providing a unique atmosphere. Dining beneath the canopy of the trees, with soft lighting and live music, was truly an unforgettable experience. It’s the kind of place that captures the essence of Key West—relaxed, friendly, and utterly delightful. A visit here is more than just a meal; it’s a celebration of what makes Key West so special. This restaurant is a must-visit for anyone wanting to experience the heart and soul of the island.“

“Fun, weird quirky place. Star Wars X-wing fighters hanging from the ceiling. X-men comic book and a Wolverine action figure hanging on the wall. Yet this place still pulls off a romantic vibe.Not easy to find the place I think that might be intentional. It’s almost like they dare you to eat there, if you can find it.Key west is loaded with great restaurants. This was our favorite of them all.A party of two, I couldn’t decide between the snapper and the tasting trio. They were nice enough to swap out the grouper with the snapper. My date had the tasting trio with the grouper and we shared the appetizer tasting trio. Everything was delicious. Don’t miss out on the lobster Mac and cheese it is the way of the Jedi.“

“Old school vibe with the Man himself at the helm in the kitchen, we had a party of 6 unannounced, and we were HUNGRY...Gents handled our orders without issue and even had Mama or Auntie come in for backup and IT WAS DELICIOUS. Expect us back again, Mo...?? ?“

“Great food. I got the Cachapa and the Parillada. I really liked the Parillada. I got the chicken and the beef. The chicken was a little dry but that is probably because I didn’t eat until I got home. I live an hour’s drive from KW. The lady who served me was an absolute gem, with a beautiful smile. Great service.“

“This place is small with a little inside seating and more outside seating. The food is delicious! The orange juice is fresh squeezed and delicious! I had the steak egg and cheese wrap with hasbrown inside it was so good. I like to eat and I got through half and was stuffed out of my mind! Fresh avocado steak cheese eggs hashbrowns all wrapped and grilled! Don't miss this place for the best breakfast!“

“I got jerk pork (they ran out of chicken that evening), oxtail, and curry goat. It was loaded with protein! Even my brother, a big meat eater, was amazed. All 3 dishes were super flavorful! The sides were good as well. I got the oxtail thinking it would be a small portion based on some 1-star reviews, but it turned out to be huge as well. Soooooo tender and plenty of meat! Oxtail is $11/lb where I live so I can understand why the dish is pricey. But if you're a fan of oxtail, I say just go for it! We couldn't finish everything so it was leftovers for breakfast the next day. And yes, it was still delicious the next day!Vegetarian options: Side dishes are vegetarian friendly.“

“Was very disappointed. I was there 2 years ago and had the most delicious shrimp and grits I think I have had. I was told tonight the no longer had it.Crabby tots and jerk steak flat bread were amazing but they were not shrimp and grits. Hope they bring it back before next time we come down.“

“Don't understand the negative reviews. Maybe they have just improved but we had a great experience. Service was excellent and the mahi-mahi special was delicious.  Stunning location right on the sand. Our best food experience during our 10 night stay in Key West.“

“Unfortunately the music was SO loud!! The musician set up about 10 minutes after we'd ordered our drinks. We couldn't hear across the table. He wasn't good enough for us to put up with it. Fortunately there was a garden table available. We moved and that was MUCH better. Food was good and server was incredibly good. She moved us within minutes.“