50 Best Bakeries near Worthington

“Highly recommend!! Last minute order for a graduation cake. I gave them a few details over the phone and they absolutely nailed it! Delivered more than expected and the cake was delicious!! Kudos to the team at Mrs. Goodman’s for helping me make my daughters day so special!❤️“

“A cute, tasty little lunch! I had the three course combo with the salad, potato soup, and prosciutto+brie sandwich, plus a quiche lorraine. Nothing was particularly remarkable, but it was all tasty and high quality! The sandwich in particular was delicious, the brie and prosciutto were excellent, but the bread was a bit too hard. The quiche was pleasantly creamy and the crust was great. Soup was delicious. It was a touch pricey for the portions you get, but overall I enjoyed my meal!We picked up some croissants to take home :-)“

“Just being 100% honest...after doing our due diligence with several cake tastings. All of the cake designers decorated a lovely cake, but Jan Kish/La Petite Fleur also focuses on the couple, getting to know them, the flavor combinations and quality of the cake plus fantastic design!! It was a no-brainer to go with Jan. Plus my future son-in-law was psyched about Jan's champagne sabering service! We feel totally blessed Jan was available on my daughter's special day!! ❤️.“

“Amazing service for our wedding and the cake was amazing! Exactly what we would have hoped for. Thank you so much for making our special day so easy!! Guests loved the cupcakes!!“

“I've been enjoying their macrons since I found them at thr Dublin Farmers Market. there are so many wonderful words to describe the experience ❤️ I highly recommend the tea, or strawberry milk with a yuzu macron. the coconut chocolate is one of my favorites.“

“Adam's Yemeni tea spot offers a remarkable experience, blending authentic Yemeni tea with a captivating atmosphere. Visitors are drawn in by the inviting ambiance and Adam's personal touch, ensuring each cup is brewed to perfection. It's a must-visit for anyone looking to immerse themselves in Yemeni culture through the simple pleasure of a great cup of tea in all of Columbus.“

“How did it take me five years to walk into Espresso Air? This is a great local coffee shop. I completely recommend it! I ordered a honey latte with cinnamon. Not only was the coffee perfectly pulled and the milk was nicely steamed, the owner made a beautiful tulip coffee art in my cup. (Thank you! That makes me smile). If you are looking for a place to sit and work for hours... this might not the place for you as its small inside with two cafe tables but.... If you want a great cup of coffee, with beans locally roasted by the owner and a true local coffee shop feel, this is definately the place for you! If you like fresh baked cookies, bagels and savory flat breads... this is the place for you. The owner's family also owns the Tulip Cafe, which is a Turkish bakery and wow, the baked goods are fresh and they're good! The shop is in historic uptown on a cute corner entranced building. He has few cafe chairs inside and a few outside. The decorating and merchandising inside really adds to the aesthetics of his space. Its just such a nice, well done, locally owned business. Come support it! You will not be disappointed in anything.“

“My husband brought me one peanut butter cookie on his break and I went back to the bearded baker for six more, not even an hour later . It was the only thing on my mind . Excellent flavors and super soft cookie that’s the perfect size .“

“All I can say is thank you lion cubs. I literally became husband of the year this week after bringing home some lion cubs cookies for my wife who was not having a fun time. She literally said flowers are great and meaningful but lion cubs cookies really show you love me and know what I want. Thank you lion cubs cookies for making sure I won husband of the year and to all other husbands a little psa get your girl lion cubs on her time of the month you’ll thank me later!“

“Three Bites is my favorite bakery in Columbus!“

“We loved all the pastries we tried as well as the coffee! The staff were super accommodating so I could get the extra space for the milk. The chocolate pastry was exceptional and the barista recommended it, so good call!“

“The cruffin and the cardamom roll were amazing! Prices were high. I get that costs are skyrocketing. I was just surprised they were that high. But delicious and I definitely will be back but more as a treat than a staple. Very talented baker.“

“The absolute most delicious cinnamon rolls you have ever tasted!! Get there early because 1) they are hot out of the oven and 2) they sell out. The icing is creamy and not overly sweet. You don't feel like you have a mouth full of sugar. Also, they keep well on the counter. Just a quick microwave in the morning and they are fresh and hot again!“

“Everything ❤️the cheesecake is better than Cheesecake Factory“

“Amazing, amazing bubble tea coupled with a comforting atmosphere and impeccable customer service make this a truly euphoric experience! Thank you!!“

“My only complaint would be that the semisweet CC isn’t always an option. Personally think it’s better than the regular milk chocolate ha! Love the variety, rotation of flavor options, softness and served warm (or chilled if needed). So good they often don’t all make the drive home!“

“Most enjoyable! Learning first hand making Macarons Very organized and well planned for their students.“

“Cute little cafe in downtown! I walked here from my hotel after reading about this Lemon Aioli and Rosemary-Lemon Sausage, I knew I had to have it. I placed my order online and headed over. It's super cute and isn't incredibly busy in the area where it's located. It also has its own parking lot which is a plus! My order was ready as soon as I arrived. I ordered the Rosemary Breakfast Sammich. Yum! Totally unique and unlike any breakfast sandwich I've had. Super flavorful, and the marriage of the flavors betwixt the fresh baked croissant bun. Chef's kiss! I also ordered a regular drip coffee. It was tasty! The cafe itself is adorable and cozy, but bright and happy. I also really loved reading about (and supporting!) their mission. Swing by here while you're in the area and have one of their elevated breakfast staples. You won't be disappointed!“

“Such a sweet shop! Would definitely recommend for cupcakes and cake pops“

“The buckeye pie was exceptionally delicious! I enjoy eating it semi-frozen.The peach pie was okay—crust delicious; peaches could have been more tender as they were somewhat crunchy; not a big fan of commercial pies with gel-type fruit filling; taste was perfect… not too sweet. I will probably just stick with the cream pies.The chicken pot pie had a delicious homemade taste, but for whatever reason, the chicken had a “chickeny” smell— it didn’t taste spoiled, but the smell was off— I will not purchase againThe turkey pot pie also had a delicious homemade taste—I will definitely purchase again.I cannot wait to try the key lime pie with whipped topping instead of meringue (with advanced order). I really appreciate that they sell small pies.“

“Our Non-Profit organization held a fundraiser and reception for a visiting author. We chose Mozart's due to our years long appreciation of the food and service. Anand worked with our group to provide a wonderful atmosphere for our event. The staff were attentive and very professional in their assistance. The food was delicous and enjoyed by all the attendees. It was the perfect place and we had a wonderful time.“

“Love these cheesecakes! There’s so many varieties of flavors, it’s hard to choose a favorite but the blackberry lemonade is delicious. The crusts have a great texture and the garnishes look beautiful. Two phenomenal bakers, highly recommend!!“

“Neighborhood bakery, cakes are light and not overly sweet“

“Both of their lattes were great. Real pistachio and real strawberry flavor not syrup. Pistachio gateau was good as well (I personally love desserts with croustillant!!). The éclair has two different cremes and tasted great too. There was almost no good sitting or eating options. Only outside sitting straight under the sun. This is the only reason I'm not sure if I want to come back.“

“The knafeh and the baklava are phenomenal!“

“We visited Pattycake Bakery and purchased a piece of cake. It was Chocolate Cake with caramel flavored frosting I do believe but it was delicious either way. We travel to Columbus for doctors appointments and this will be a regular treat afterwards. I should have gotten a photo before I almost all of it. But I couldn’t wait to dig in“

“I was visiting the area and decided to stop by for a nice snack. I got a maple frosted cream filled doughnut and a cream horn. Both delicious but my favorite had to be the cream horn, I can say my dog also agrees as I put it down and he ended up eating it too.“

“I always come here and the cookies are always amazing but today they were overcooked and dry. But other than today they are always so good and i 100% recommend!!“

“I was looking for a sweet potato cheesecake for my husband's birthday, so I started to do a little research. I had never heard of Ri'Joyce pies, but she had all 5 star reviews on google, and reviews are a huge part of why I choose a service/product, so I was immediately intrigued! The process was very easy, I went onto the website and ordered. She reached out to let me know that she had received my order and would have it ready for pickup as requested. When I went to pick it up, we chatted, and Sharita was very friendly with a bubbly personality! She said that she is the sole baker, and takes lots of pride in her food. She told me to let her know if I had any problems at all with the cheesecake, and she would be more than happy to fix it for me. But there were no problems at all. The cheesecake was DELICIOUS! I had absolutely no complaints at all. Without a doubt, the next time I need a handmade pie, cheesecake, etc, I'm absolutely going to Ri'Joyce Pies!“

“I have quickly become a regular at Winn Winn Cafe. By far the best cookies in Columbus - especially the sugar cookie and chocolate chip. The coffee cake is also beyond delicious. Very cute and aesthetic location with phenomenal customer service.“

“I've recently moved to the East side of Columbus and have looked around to many bakeries in Gahanna, Bexley, Reynoldsburg, and White Hall. Matt's Bakery is definitely my favorite. The prices are surprisingly reasonable (not boutique/cafe prices for an individual item). There are multiple bakery items that have now become a weekly staple for me: The pita is my favorite, snowball cookies are my go-to party snack, and the pumpernickel is great.Nice options with no egg or no milkVegetarian options: Some products use soy ingredients in place of milk/eggs“

“My Husband & I are so grateful to Woodhouse Vegan for hosting & catering our intimate 40 person wedding in September 2022. My husband and I are both vegan, and found the prospect of finding vegan catering for our small wedding daunting. We were thrilled that Woodhouse, one of the best vegan restaurants in Columbus, was open to not only catering our wedding, but also hosting it! Carla & the entire Woodhouse team made our big day incredible!! They did a fantastic job communicating prior to the wedding- we spoke via email, text, phone, and in person at the Woodhouse space. They answered all of our questions & provided helpful suggestions for how the night should run. On the day of our wedding they were flexible and provided us the stress-free easy going atmosphere we were hoping for. Carla kindly whispered a few things in our ears as the night went on letting us know how the bar tab was doing and to check in prior to serving each course. We had so much fun! The entire Woodhouse team helped us craft a delicious multi-course meal that our vegan and non-vegan guests loved. Their drinks were also fantastic! They happily catered to a few picky eaters on the guest list, as well as provided some non-alcoholic options for our non-drinking guests. The atmosphere was gorgeous, as always, and we were thrilled to use both the patio and indoor space. With 40 guests the space felt lively but not crowded. We even had space to install a small archway in the patio for the ceremony. We’re so grateful to the whole Woodhouse team for all they did to make our dream wedding day come to life!“

“Happened to find this place out of no where because I happened to be in the area. This is just such a gem! I got their savory cookie which was delicious, the baklava which is just so fresh, almond croissant that we all enjoyed (very rich), and milk cake. I mean, if you're looking for good desserts from an unpretentious place at a great price, this is it. So good. Completely fresh.“

“I had to get up early this morning to go to an important appointment and was on this side of town, so I decided to stop in for the first time to look around. I was able to try a cute little citrus lavender heart powdered sugar muffin ? .This coffee shop reminds me of a French inspired café with marble buffet tables and seats outside the entrance. I should have also walked down the street and also got me some Grater's ? ? ☺️?... A must for the summer! ? ?Cute side of town to visit every once in awhile. I should have taken a picture of the pretty heart powered muffin in a cute little brown box, but since it was a busy day ahead I forgot, and just rushed and ate it, lol. Maybe next time. ???Dietary restrictions: Dairy/Lactose Free“

“Our 1st visit. It was restaurant week. Took awhile to be waited on after we were seated - they were quite busy and most likely not expecting the demand. Our waiter (in-training)was excellent). Our 3-course meals were wonderful with very fresh ingredients ..the lobster pasta dish was amazing. Nice atmosphere. We will be back.“

“Great coffee and great baristas! Beautiful patio and I love the outdoor fireplace!“

“Paris 75 is a charming little shop and art gallery. I was specifically looking for the macarons and didn't realize it was tucked away in a shop. There are many different items you can buy that come from Paris and the macaron case is near the back. I tried 12 of the macarons. They were beautifully displayed and came in flavors I have never tried before. They were quite tasty and didn't get stale within a day like other competitors I have tried before. The shop owner was extremely friendly. She was talking about the changes coming. They are working on getting the gallery switched out with more French artists, and are currently adding a small kitchenette area to offer coffee.“

“This coffee shop is so cute! I got the chocolate chip muffin, it was pretty filling but I personally am not a fan of vegan pastries. It's great to have a place with all vegan options though! I also got the almond milk chai latte and it was really good. Service was really great, the barista was really nice and quick. This cafe also had a very nice atmosphere. Music plays a bit loudly, so I left to take meeting calls. There were lots of seating options but not many outlets upstairs if you're looking to WFH. Maybe downstairs (I didn't check). I would come again!“

“So freaking good! I’ve had Bakes By Lo a few times while at Center Street. This year I ordered a birthday cake for my husband because he loves cookie cakes. The cookie was delicious and the frosting - omg! It was so good I could eat it by the spoonful. Will be ordering again for the next birthday!“

“We loved all the pastries we tried as well as the coffee! The staff were super accommodating so I could get the extra space for the milk. The chocolate pastry was exceptional and the barista recommended it, so good call!“

“Very beautiful and tasty Eggless cakes. Have ordered several times and every time it is more and more awesome. Never had any disappointing experience. All flavors are good. The owner is very nice and kind, and she exactly understands what we need and goes beyond and make our day special. Even all guest had a big praise on it. Pics are from yesterday's birthday event. All kiddos were like Wow... Thank you Fatima.“

“These are my favorite cookies. The lemon and almond are so delicious!!“

“One just opened in Smithtown and we've already been there twice this week. Today my husband brought me a donut and it was so amazing. I had brought him some cake a few days ago. Can't wait to try the bread.“

“If you really like or even love cookies, this place is a really good option. The choices are few, but I'm partial to chocolate chip so I'm always covered. However, I've tried a few of the others, and they're not bad.The service at this location is pretty good. I've never had to wait more than 10 minutes for my order, even when they were busy. The ordering process is pretty simple. There are ordering kiosks available, or you can place an online order, which speeds thing up even more.My only issue is that you are forced to buy their massive cookies every time. They have smaller cookies, but they're only available with their catering. These should be available as purchase options as well.Other than that, I would recommend them if you're looking to satisfy that sweet craving.“

“Nice place and very accessible to the neighborhood“

“5 Star delicious real Italian food. First visit 2 hour drive too!! We will definitely be back. Everyone was so nice too..“

“I stopped after seeing their sign as I can rarely pass up a bakery! Staff was friendly and helpful. Store is adorable and very clean. Products are nicely displayed in case. I chose the cutout with buttercream and chocolate chip caramel sea salt cookies. Cutout was thick, soft and delicious! The icing was sweet and smooth and really quite perfect. Loved the simple and pretty decor of the flower. Chocolate chip cookie was just as wonderful in its own way. Slightly crunchy around the edges yet soft and chewy in the center. Nice balance of chocolate, caramel and cookie batter topped off with salt. Would highly recommend checking this place out!“

“I highly recommend the Cupcakery. I did extensive research (tastings!), received many quotes and decided on them based on their great flavor. I could not have asked for better people to work with planning a covid wedding. I am thankful for their flexibility and support. The cake and cupcakes the day of tasted SO GOOD! The lighted display was worth every penny. I am beyond happy with my choice!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!! Cant wait for my anniversary cake!“

“Wow! What a gem! Hidden cbus experience! Nicest employee, friendliest patrons and even some dogs to pet. Thank you to the owners of these shops! Will be back!“

“Fantastic local bakery, the scones and ‘pop tarts’ are some of my favorites. The pizza dough is also amazing, and at $5 it makes 2 personal sized pizzas!! Stuff goes fast though, so I do occasionally pre order on their website and just do pickup.“