Sarah's Cookie Jar

3508 32 Ave NE #311, Calgary
(403) 975-0120

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nabeel Nisha

Drove an hour just for these and NO REGRETS!! Definitely one of the best cookies ever! Especially love the mini eggs and ferroro rocher ones.

R

Came in just before close for the first time and I'm going to assume it was they Sarah who was the sweetest. She was so nice to give us an up and coming Cinnamon bun cookie which was absolutely DELICIOUS! The other two flavors we had were so good too! What I like about the cookies is they are the perfect crunchy but still soft cookies. Without being overly sweet!

Ty Emerson

I bought a box of assorted cookies and brought them over to a family dinner. Everyone was complementing how good they were.

Justin Cook

Delicious! Recommend!! Very friendly.

Sabrina Van Der Voet

These are some of the best cookies we have ever had!!! The Dunkaroo is to die for!! Texture is out of this world!! So soft but holds up well. I love the thickness of the cookie and the icing is delicious! Better than Crumbl!! Highly recommend trying these out! Sarah herself served us, she is so sweet and soooo talented!!

Krista Olsen

The peanut butter cookie is 10/10. I’ll be dreaming of this cookie!

T\u0026J Power

Crumbl who? These cookies are far superior, have an amazing flavour and are the perfect combination of crispy and soft. I will absolutely be back to try new flavours. If you haven’t tried yet you should, this girl needs her own shop.
While the staff were nice, kind, my only observation was that some cookies were on trays out of the display just behind the counter - I’m sure it’s fine don’t want to be too negative it just took me back for a second.

Maureen Crandle

Amazing cookies. Best to order ahead as they do sell out. My favourite cookies by far!

Andrew Cao

Huge and delicious cookies. Friendly staff

Heartbroken Damage girl

Lady nice and sweet but the cookies are Basically Pure Butter it's like biting into butter mixed with sugar and one cookie is 6.30$ sorry not worth it my hubby loves cookies and eats cookie every day and he couldn't even finish 1 out of the 2 I got cuz of how much Butter there was

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

M E S

Cookies were good, but was difficult to find as I didnt know it was located in a shawarma restaurant, I didnt see the sign

Rachel Arnold

I went with a friend yesterday, we drove all the way from the south based on a word of mouth recommendation and let me tell you it was worth every time. Each cookie is made with true thought and love, Sarah herself is incredibly kind and thoughtful. She provides excellent service and is truly a splendid business owner doing something truly amazing!

If you love Crumbl, you will die for Sarah's cookies! Absolutely amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nessma

her cookies are so good

Paulina Westergard

Meeting Sarah was a treat as she is as lovely as her delicious cookies! We will back to try every flavour

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fatina Hattum

Me and the kids Decided to try out these cookies, let me tell you we are forever hooked!!! The best cookies we have ever had! Customer service was great, very kind and helpful. Did I mention the cookies are huge!! We definitely will be ordering again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...