7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sylvan Lake

“Dominoes has been my favorite place to order pizza from, for quite a few years. The food is delicious and the prices are very reasonable. The light baked Cinna-Bites with icing on the side, are a must have for desert, at my place.

Dominoes has more than just pizza. Boneless chicken breast, pasta and stuffed bread are on the lunch/supper menu and chocolate brownie cookies and more for desert.

The Sylvan Lake, Alberta, Dominoes has awesome staff, from the person who takes your order, to the cooks and delivery drivers. They have all had a smile on their faces every time I’ve ordered delivery or stoped in for take out. Their friendliness is outstanding even when I only have quarters for a tip. Lots of quarters but still a handful of change.

Thank you, Sylvan Lake Dominoes, for making my supper, tonight, and thank you for your kindness. Both mean so much to me.

* Cinna-Bites and Chocokate Cookie Brownies are no longer on the menu as of September 2026 😢“

“I just want to recognize how incredible the team is at Papa John’s in Sylvan Lake. The staff are always warm, friendly, and genuinely welcoming. It makes such a difference every time we come in.

I had a mix-up with an order recently, completely on my end, and the way it was handled with kindness and understanding really stood out. It wasn’t made into an issue at all, just genuine care and great service.

Experiences like that stick with you, and it is clear this team truly values their customers. Thank you for consistently going above and beyond. It does not go unnoticed.“

“We got the Carnivor and Donair pizzas the other night. It was fast, fresh and delicious! Having family from Bedford, NS, I have to say we were all overly impressed with the Donair pizza! It had diced fresh tomatoes rather than the usual slices you get out here (more authentic!), both the donair meat and sweet sauce were on point! Definitely want to try the Donair Poutine next! 100% recommend!“

“not only was my customized pizza exactly how I ordered it, but it was soooooo good with real bacon! will definitely be ordering again“

“Absolutely fantastic Donaire, saw their shop driving through today and since I always like to try new places I stopped in. I's small and unassuming but the food was delicious. Was NOT disappointed. I'll be going back to try some of the other items on their menu. Thanks for lunch guys.“

“Hello! I had are a really lovely experience and an incredible server the other day that I must mention. I believe her name was Jada. I highly recommend requesting her as a server because not only did she make me feel extremely seen but made my family feel very welcome and catered to their every need. I really appreciated this because of how obviously busy she was, she still made the time and effort to make every single one of us feel comfortable and listen to our every need.“

“Some of the best pizza I've tasted, I always choose this place every time, I need food for a party or a get together with friends, Great price for what you get, My personal favorite is the BBQ cheese pizza or the BBQ chicken they are both delicious highly recommend.“