Jersey Mike's Subs

12071 Old Glenn Hwy, Eagle River
(907) 522-1234

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anna Reichenbach

This was my first time going to Jersey Mikes. I expected the mid, dry, unfriendly Subway experience. This Jersey Mike well exceeded my expectations. The staff are phenomenal. Serenity is the sweetest! She leads the team like a boss. Don’t even get me started on the sandwich. I could tell it was handcrafted with care. Thank you for being the best part of my day, today, tomorrow, and everyday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Caitlin Adair

Always stupid loud music thats super inappropriate for a place of business. They also set the new slow workers to work the rush time with 0 help. Something is always wrong with our order. Get rid of slow bad workers and pay the actual good nice people more. Would rather drive into Anchorage than come to this one closer yo my home. Ridiculous honestly

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Vance Zakrzewski

I've had a couple of less than ideal experiences in a row. This last one was an app order I placed for a tuna bowl I placed the order at 10:25 and was given a 10:43 pick up time. When I arrived at the pick up time I was informed they hadn't started the order and it would be further delayed because they were out of Tuna. Eventually they did offer a refund. I'm not likely to visit this location again.

Chuck Taylor

Food is great staff is really nice. They just needed more staff there

Keith Harris

Came in right after opening. The music was so loud and they certainly didn't bother turning it down. 6 team members walked by my without acknowledging me as a customer. I stood there for 5 minutes before a girl asked me if I'd like to order.....obviously. I had to tell her what I wanted twice and yell my name 3 times, because of the deafening music. Really love their food, but this was ridiculous. Might want to take a look at management.

Greg “Gregory” M

Coworker and I just happened to see they were open, and were pondering were to have lunch. It turned out great since neither of us ate here. Bought the regular chicken bacon Ranch 9$, regularly Mike's Philly 9$, and the Large Club20$. Overall, I loved the Ranch on the chicken bacon Ranch. Wow, amazing. I also tried Philly. The Philly had a burst of sweet pepper flavor I enjoyed. Both were heated. And both were great for being different. I would get the chicken bacon ranch again. The Philly was just ok. Personally straight outta Philly and even Wings and Things has better Phillies. Coworker had the Club. He said it was good and only ate half. So, with all that, it was great to try something different. Greetings from the staff and great atmosphere made it more enjoyable. This was at lunch. We sat down and could talk even though it was busy. They had music playing too but not too loud. It was a pleasant suprise. Not sure the size of the sandwiches were worth the price. They could have loaded them up more. But all in all maybe it was just slightly more. I believe it was 5$ for chips and drinks. To me, that was very high.

Lucille Gunnip

So I kept trying. I've ordered probably 15 sandwiches since opening 2 two have been right some are totally wrong, wrong meat everthing. Last night again ordered big kahuna no jalapeño. Said 3 times no jalapeño got home you guessed it jalapeño everywhere. It doesn't matter if it's counter or web order..the quality control is not there..

G B

Third trip in two weeks
Stale regular bread each time.
When first opened bread was fresh.

Patz Skate clips

Nice people good food

Ross Arter

Very scripted chitchat.
Employees following corporate rule and engaging customers in conversations. Doesn't come across as sincere or genuine and is more canned or scripted. Employees appeared to feel uncomfortable as most of them are mumbling or talking very low, making the conversation difficult.
Each employee asking the same questions.
I appreciate and understand the importance of engaging the customer, but it should come across as more natural and sincere from the employee.
A+ for the effort but the delivery needs help.
Overall good sandwich and experience.

Meghan Smith

Went into the store to order 4 sandwiches. 3 out of 4 came home wrong. They were busy yes but couldn’t follow written instructions on how we wanted our sandwiches. I highly advise looking at your order before you leave the store to double check. This has happened twice now our order was wrong when we asked for stuff. Asked for lettuce got no lettuce, asked for jalapeños for no jalapeño. My kid even wanted mayo on her sandwich and they didn’t even get that correct. They have gone down hill in the last 2 months.

Erk Esco

Lol don’t pay for extra meat. This is extra meat on the club according to the manager

Ethan

Is ok. Our order was messed up but we were 40 minutes away once we figured it out.

Alice Landers

Wonderful Italian sandwich!

Christa Swain

I've been here at least three 3x. I ordered online each time, and the food was ready at or close to time website said. Sometimes the bread is a bit soggy, but I figure if I ate it there fresh, it would be bomb. I love the jersey favorite. My husband has tried a few others.

Loading...