Best pizza in Eagle River. We don’t have much of a choice here but if you want pizza, this is the place to go. They also have very good hot wings.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Angie Balmer
Always great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven E.
This is pretty good pizza.It's constantly good, too.I'm not a big breadstick or knots guy, but they have these cheesesticks that when dipped in marinara or garlic sauce, are tasty as hell. There's four small tables to eat there, but most carry-out.Since it's inside Walmart, we pick up a few things and while I go through the checkout, Mrs. E walks down and orders the pie. Our routine is asking the cashier what their favorite topping is. Then Mrs. E decides what would be a complimentary addition to that topping and that's what we eat. Only 10-15 minutes later, it's time to munch. We were going back to the cashier with a carry out box containing a couple of slices, management frowned upon this, so we had to stop.03/23
Justin Matley
I don't want to see anyone touching their phone and texting, then touching my food ingredients. Yuk! Plus everyone should have a hat or hair net on plus gloves. One person has no hat. The other no gloves. Are these not rules anymore? These are basic food service industry standards. Come one.
Loren M.
its really cool that its in this Walmart I can shop and get pizza at the end of shopping, pizza it's always good and fresh. Thank you to all the employees for coming to work.
Melissa Rappleye
We've been getting pizza here for a while now, the food is always spot on and we've never had a problem. But we've had had a couple issues with the employees. We will order using the app and will pick up ourselves. Lately we've been sending our children in with our card and giving them a chance to practice walking in by themselves and paying by themselves. Well we had several of the employees trick the kids into giving them tips with the machine, when the children would ask a question. We got pretty frustrated and had to give the children strict instructions to not tip them ever. We were pretty frustrated that they would do that.We love their deals, we use their $8.99 pairing deal all the time. The app is fantastic and it's nice to save up points and save some cash on pizza night. I would recommend the store, but be very mindful about the employees.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Jonathan haulbrook
In a world where lackluster pizza is the law of the land, one small franchise pizzeria stands tall, looks to the mediocrity of today's delivery dough discs and says "no". This papa John's stands above the rest in culinary mastery. This Eagle River eatery b**** slaps its local peers in service quality and timeliness. THIS fine establishments workers and delivery drivers go the extra mile to make damn sure your ultimate pizza experience is achieved, and they do it with a fantastic attitude 100% of the time. If you're looking for a quality pie delivered by absolutely delightful individuals, then look no further!
Alaskan100
Always a great stop by especially when/if you shop at ER Walmart! The employees are always nice and the pizza is always fresh!The best part is my name is always different than the last time! Always having to joke around with that everytime I go in!
Johnny Skinner
Our good friends brought this Pizza for us, and this is rediculous!! It seems moronic to have to drive to purchase uncooked food? We can get that at the grocery store.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
John R.
Are you kidding me? I ask what large pizzas they have. Answer 16". So I order 2 16" pizzas. $48. Seriously? 48? Ok Waiting for my pizzas I hear them tell the next guy "we have a special on large (14") for $9.95. Are you Kidd me? I could have bought 4 of them for less than they charged me for 2. Then another guy comes in, and asks us "Did you buy with the app? They are giving 25% discount if you buy on the app. Are you kidding me? Well, you lost this customer for life. I'll be buying at some place that cares a little more about their customers. But you did make a few extra bucks, which apparently is what you wanted.
Best pizza in eagle river. No lie, they never disappoint.
Ann Onymous
We always have a great experience here
Joel Iff
Fast friendly ,,,Jonithan gave us great customer service
Brian H.
Place the order, get the notification it's ready, drive all the way to the store only to have them tell me that one of the two pizzas wasn't made. How the hell do you mess up a two pizza order? This place is complete and utter chaos. How are they even open still!
Jesse B Nixon
Gotta love good ol papa johns , everyone in this store was nice , polite and very helpful . I can't tell what to get because all of them are great and everyone is different but the store was clean and the pizza was great
Best pizza in Eagle River. We don’t have much of a choice here but if you want pizza, this is the place to go. They also have very good hot wings.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Always great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is pretty good pizza.It's constantly good, too.I'm not a big breadstick or knots guy, but they have these cheesesticks that when dipped in marinara or garlic sauce, are tasty as hell. There's four small tables to eat there, but most carry-out.Since it's inside Walmart, we pick up a few things and while I go through the checkout, Mrs. E walks down and orders the pie. Our routine is asking the cashier what their favorite topping is. Then Mrs. E decides what would be a complimentary addition to that topping and that's what we eat. Only 10-15 minutes later, it's time to munch. We were going back to the cashier with a carry out box containing a couple of slices, management frowned upon this, so we had to stop.03/23
I don't want to see anyone touching their phone and texting, then touching my food ingredients. Yuk! Plus everyone should have a hat or hair net on plus gloves. One person has no hat. The other no gloves. Are these not rules anymore? These are basic food service industry standards. Come one.
its really cool that its in this Walmart I can shop and get pizza at the end of shopping, pizza it's always good and fresh. Thank you to all the employees for coming to work.
We've been getting pizza here for a while now, the food is always spot on and we've never had a problem. But we've had had a couple issues with the employees. We will order using the app and will pick up ourselves. Lately we've been sending our children in with our card and giving them a chance to practice walking in by themselves and paying by themselves. Well we had several of the employees trick the kids into giving them tips with the machine, when the children would ask a question. We got pretty frustrated and had to give the children strict instructions to not tip them ever. We were pretty frustrated that they would do that.We love their deals, we use their $8.99 pairing deal all the time. The app is fantastic and it's nice to save up points and save some cash on pizza night. I would recommend the store, but be very mindful about the employees.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
In a world where lackluster pizza is the law of the land, one small franchise pizzeria stands tall, looks to the mediocrity of today's delivery dough discs and says "no". This papa John's stands above the rest in culinary mastery. This Eagle River eatery b**** slaps its local peers in service quality and timeliness. THIS fine establishments workers and delivery drivers go the extra mile to make damn sure your ultimate pizza experience is achieved, and they do it with a fantastic attitude 100% of the time. If you're looking for a quality pie delivered by absolutely delightful individuals, then look no further!
Always a great stop by especially when/if you shop at ER Walmart! The employees are always nice and the pizza is always fresh!The best part is my name is always different than the last time! Always having to joke around with that everytime I go in!
Our good friends brought this Pizza for us, and this is rediculous!! It seems moronic to have to drive to purchase uncooked food? We can get that at the grocery store.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Are you kidding me? I ask what large pizzas they have. Answer 16". So I order 2 16" pizzas. $48. Seriously? 48? Ok Waiting for my pizzas I hear them tell the next guy "we have a special on large (14") for $9.95. Are you Kidd me? I could have bought 4 of them for less than they charged me for 2. Then another guy comes in, and asks us "Did you buy with the app? They are giving 25% discount if you buy on the app. Are you kidding me? Well, you lost this customer for life. I'll be buying at some place that cares a little more about their customers. But you did make a few extra bucks, which apparently is what you wanted.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in eagle river. No lie, they never disappoint.
We always have a great experience here
Fast friendly ,,,Jonithan gave us great customer service
Place the order, get the notification it's ready, drive all the way to the store only to have them tell me that one of the two pizzas wasn't made. How the hell do you mess up a two pizza order? This place is complete and utter chaos. How are they even open still!
Gotta love good ol papa johns , everyone in this store was nice , polite and very helpful . I can't tell what to get because all of them are great and everyone is different but the store was clean and the pizza was great